Fun Stuff > ENJOY

Heroic film deaths! (Might contain FILM ****SPOILERS*****)

<< < (19/19)

Jedit:

--- Quote from: Tergon ---That's a good argument, but there's one important flaw in it.

Norton-Tyler saw himself as a seperate entity from Pitt-Tyler.
--- End quote ---


I need to ask at this point if you are or have been an Honours candidate in Psychology.  That you think of Norton-Tyler not believing his imaginary friend to be himself as a flaw in my argument suggests to me that you are/have not - in which case, please accept that I know more about this than you do.  (If you are an Honours candidate then you're simply mistaken, but there's nothing wrong with that, I'm sure.  :))

I do agree with you that "Norton-Tyler" probably isn't called Tyler Durden, though.  I used it only as a convenient label to identify that they are the same person, but in different aspects.

Tergon:

--- Quote from: Jedit ---I need to ask at this point if you are or have been an Honours candidate in Psychology.  That you think of Norton-Tyler not believing his imaginary friend to be himself as a flaw in my argument suggests to me that you are/have not - in which case, please accept that I know more about this than you do.  (If you are an Honours candidate then you're simply mistaken, but there's nothing wrong with that, I'm sure.  :))

I do agree with you that "Norton-Tyler" probably isn't called Tyler Durden, though.  I used it only as a convenient label to identify that they are the same person, but in different aspects.
--- End quote ---

No, no, you're quite right.  I was putting forth the situation as I saw it, but I have no professional knowledge of multiple personality disorder.  I've studied a thing or two about it, but not in detail and only enough to use as a plot device in works of fiction.  If you know what you're talking about then I bow to your superior knowledge.

Jedit:

--- Quote from: Tergon ---No, no, you're quite right.  I was putting forth the situation as I saw it, but I have no professional knowledge of multiple personality disorder.  I've studied a thing or two about it, but not in detail and only enough to use as a plot device in works of fiction.  If you know what you're talking about then I bow to your superior knowledge.
--- End quote ---


My knowledge probably isn't that superior, but it does range wider.  I have more choices available for best fit.  Anyway, I think we were mainly arguing over the colour of the elephant's shirt.  Let the thread get back on topic.

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[*] Previous page