Fun Stuff > BAND

BEST Fictional Tribute Album

<< < (6/7) > >>

Rubby:
But...But guys, "Been Smokin' too Long"?

Thrillho:

--- Quote from: hey_there_fatty ---Pink Floyd-A Saucerful Of Tributes

 The Arcade Fire:Bike
 Idina Menzel:Money
 Mogwai:A Saucerful Of Secrets
 Iron and Wine:Wish You Were Here
 The White Stripes:Fearless/Seamus
 The Dresden Dolls:Us and Them
 Opeth:Echoes
 Tool:One Of These Days I'm Going To Cut You Into Little Pieces/Shine On,You Crazy Diamond
 Mushroomhead (With Jeff Nothing doing all of the vocals):Have A Cigar/Empty Spaces (Which they have already done..well!)
 Porcupine Tree:Comfortably Numb (GOD YES)
 Queens Of The Stoneage:Set The Controls For The Heart Of The Sun
 
 There would be more,of course..but these are all most important!
--- End quote ---


Good idea, but horrific choices from where I'm standing.

Did they put 'What Do We Do Now?' on the end of Empty Spaces?

Cartilage Head:

--- Quote from: KharBevNor ---The Dresden Dolls should definitely do Bike. The Arcade Fire can bugger off and be replaced with any of the following:

Ewigkeit - One Of These Days
Swans - High Hopes or Careful With That Axe, Eugene
Bauhaus - See Emily Play
Coil - Time
Placebo - Mother
British Sea Power - Echoes
Nightingale feat. Diamanda Galas - The Great Gig in the Sky
Alien Sex Fiend - Comfortably Numb
Throbbing Gristle - Another Brick in the Wall pts. 1, 2 and 3
Tan-Hauser Gate - Brain Damage-Eclipse
Hawkwind - Astronomy Domine
Nurse With Wound - Several Species of Small Furry Animals Gavered Together in a Cave and Grooving With a Pict
--- End quote ---


Hmm..you might be on to something. But The Arcade Fire MUST be involved to me..perhaps I will have them do Run Like Hell. No..Mushroomhead kept it as it was on the album..however,it would have been brilliant if they had added "What Do We Do Now?"

Bastardous Bassist:

--- Quote from: DynamiteKid ---Good idea, but horrific choices from where I'm standing.
--- End quote ---


I still agree with this one.  I don't think any of those have a style that wouldn't take everything that made Pink Floyd good out of it.  Not to say those bands are bad, they just don't have what Pink Floyd had, nor are they anywhere close.  They do completely different stuff!

Thrillho:
I'm sorry, I don't care what KoRn did, there's loads and loads of songs between the three parts of Another Brick. You can't just staple them together like that, you can hardly get away with just Another Brick Part II on its own.

Okay, if we're doing Floyd tribute albums, here's how it'd go down for me:

1. The Mars Volta - Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Parts I-V and VII)
2. The Alamos - Astronomy Domine
3. Nick Cave - Mother (that would be SO AWESOME)
4. Rocky Votolato - Fearless
5. U2 - Take It Back (OH THE IRONY)
6. The Scorpions - In The Flesh?/In The Flesh (well, they've done it before...)
7. Explosions In The Sky - One Of These Days
8. Interpol - Two Suns in the Sunset
9. Graham Coxon - Bike
10. Wilco - Hey You
11. Radiohead - Welcome To The Machine
12. Sigur Ros - Sorrow

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page

[*] Previous page