Fun Stuff > ENJOY
Heroes
0bsessions:
Gah! Am I the only one paying attention?
The reason Sylar didn't need Claire's powers is because Hiro never stabbed him. In the original timeline, the events went as follows:
Sylar kills Claire--->everyone collects in NYC (Minus Ted, he presumably bites it beforehand)--->Hiro stabs Sylar--->Sylar regenerates and goes splodey
Then future Hiro went back in time to warn Peter, the following resulted:
Peter rescues Claire--->Hiro accidentally transports five years into the future/
At this point, the timeline is broken with Hiro stuck in the future. With Hiro scared to travel back in time again, he's not present at the explosion to stop Sylar. This is the timeline that occurs if Hiro doesn't stab Sylar. With Hiro back in the present, this aspect changes. As evidenced by Future Hiro's confusion at present Hiro's arrival in the future, that was never supposed to occur and was an anomoly likely created by his warning to Peter. From here it gets VERY confusing and VERY complicated. It will likely be cleared up in the next episode or next season.
I've learned a lesson from reading Days of Future Past, Crisis on Infinite Earths and watching Back to the Future: don't think too much about it. Your brain will self-destruct.
Pshha:
I was confused LONG before I imagine I was supposed to be. That actually cleared up alot though. There are an immense amount of theories about how time travel and such, laws, would work out. Its hard to determine which one a movie or book or TV show is going by.
0bsessions:
Fortunately for me, I've been reading comics for about fifteen years now. With multiple people involved heavily in the industry involved in this show, it's mostly comic book rules that seem to apply, so I'm in my element with this.
axerton:
I'm only watching this show as it comes out in austrailia ( just saw matt and ted arive at Bennet household) but i just want to throw my theroy down in writing, though it may have already been debunked. Nathan dies. Then Peter meets niki and copies her power to channel jessica and revives nathan within himself.
That would be cool.
doki:
--- Quote from: 0bsessions on 17 May 2007, 06:02 ---Gah! Am I the only one paying attention?
Sylar kills Claire--->everyone collects in NYC (Minus Ted, he presumably bites it beforehand)--->Hiro stabs Sylar--->Sylar regenerates and goes splodey
Then future Hiro went back in time to warn Peter, the following resulted:
Peter rescues Claire--->Hiro accidentally transports five years into the future/
At this point, the timeline is broken with Hiro stuck in the future. With Hiro scared to travel back in time again, he's not present at the explosion to stop Sylar. This is the timeline that occurs if Hiro doesn't stab Sylar. With Hiro back in the present, this aspect changes. As evidenced by Future Hiro's confusion at present Hiro's arrival in the future, that was never supposed to occur and was an anomoly likely created by his warning to Peter. From here it gets VERY confusing and VERY complicated. It will likely be cleared up in the next episode or next season.
I've learned a lesson from reading Days of Future Past, Crisis on Infinite Earths and watching Back to the Future: don't think too much about it. Your brain will self-destruct.
--- End quote ---
that doesn't explain to me how Claire is still alive in the future. I mean, if future Hiro believed that the reason Syler regenerated was Claire she would have to be dead. she wasnt, she was waitressing. Not only that, Bennet knew about her (he went to see her), so even if she had been saved in the past and reappeared in her future, then the explosion would already have been avoided, right?
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version