Fun Stuff > ENJOY
Harry Potter and The Deathly Hallows
Thy Dungeonman:
0bsessions:
Snape gon' give it to ya.
CmonMiracle:
Johnny, you used to be cool
Until you ruined my thread!
0bsessions:
Ruined...or made excellent?!
CmonMiracle:
--- Quote from: 0bsessions on 11 Jul 2007, 06:54 ---No offense to LeeZion, but that's one's pretty weak in comparisson. The random resurrection has been done to death, is a major copout and I, for one, am glad Rowling's claiming Dumbledore's staying dead. I'd also have to agree that the Boggart angle is pretty flimsy. Aside from it being a copout in and of itself in terms of a big, epic, final battle, it's also completely unbelievable. Voldemort, even paniced and without his Horcruxes, is still one of the most powerful wizards in the story's canon. A boggart just maintains the shape of what you fear, not the legitimate power (As I doubt Snape would ever have allowed Neville to dress him up like an old woman). It wouldn't take Voldemort particularly long to determine that "Voldemort" was not what he appeared to be.
--- End quote ---
You forget, Harry faced a boggart in the shape of a Dementor and it still affected him. It should have some of the powers of whatever it is imitating, I think.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version