Fun Stuff > ENJOY
Harry Potter and The Deathly Hallows
ThePQ4:
::gasp:: Blashphemer!
Jimmy the Squid:
Uh PQ4 I'm a little disappointed you're too up for a Harry Potter argument to see a joke when it is fairly obvious. It's like when pirates say that for legal purposes, it will be the ocean that kills you.
Lines:
--- Quote from: LeeZion on 11 Jul 2007, 13:27 ---Also, Harry would NOT have to spend a lot of time traveling. He can Apparate.
--- End quote ---
I meant not spend a lot of time traveling, but traveling to many places. I don't expect him to stay in on place for long periods of time. He has searching to do and he's got to go out and do it. There may be a place he goes to in between, like headquarters or Hogwarts or something, but I think he's mostly going to be abroad. Apparate is still traveling, just a quick version of it.
And about Dumbledore, even if the possibility that Snape didn't use the AK, I severely doubt Dumbledore would have survived much after what he'd just gone through. He'd already pretty much lost a hand and he was very old (150 according to what people have been saying on Leaky Cauldron), so I don't think he would have survived after that potion he drank anyways. And I feel he had a noble death. Sirius didn't come back, Harry's parents didn't come back (and won't), so I am going to stick with Dumbledore staying dead.
ThePQ4:
Riiiiight...
Yeah, it's been to long since I've had a decent Potter-related argument. I tend to walk away from them, as those who get into them with me are idiots who don't know what they are talking about... But i get it now...sort of. I need to go back to sleep, I think.
0bsessions:
--- Quote from: LeeZion on 11 Jul 2007, 13:27 ---
--- Quote from: Linds on 11 Jul 2007, 10:41 ---Dumbledore is dead. He was killed by an Avada Kedavra and is dead.
--- End quote ---
But how do you know Dumbledore was hit by an Avada Kedavra curse? Yes, Snape said the words, but as we learned in the fourth book, if the words are spoken without any real power behing them, the intended victim wouldn't get so much as a nosebleed. We also know that it's possible to say a curse silently. So perhaps Snape said the words while using an entirely different curse, to make it look good for everyone else.
Also, Harry would NOT have to spend a lot of time traveling. He can Apparate.
But it's a moot point. For one thing, I never wrote my version — the amount of time I would have had to devote to it, plus my having to wrap up all those side plots (elves, giants, the werewolf who attacked Lupin, etc.) made it too difficult a task. And besides,we'll all find out for real in 10 days.
--- End quote ---
Dumbledore IS dead. Read any interview from Rowling since book six. He's dead and buried.
The traveling time is not a concern, but the searching is. Harry has no idea WHERE the Horcruxes are. He can't just apparate to where they are without knowing. He's not likely to have time in between TEACHING (Which takes a lot more time than merely attending school) classes to look for them, he'd need to dedicate all his time.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version