OK, I know there aren't a lot of Bright Eyes fans on here - if any - but I would still recommend this album as it has a pretty markedly different sound, and a new lyrical depth and maturity that he often lacked before. When I first played it, I was kind of surprised at how much of a classic rock/classic country/Americana sound it has, and not in the folk-centric way he did on I'm Wide Awake It's Morning.
At the risk of being stoned (lol) I would dare to say that if you like the last two Okkervil River albums you should give this a shot, because I would say it is very nearly as good as The Stand-Ins.