Comic Discussion > QUESTIONABLE CONTENT
Congrats Jeph on a great comic (2-16-2009)
Strike Da Mic:
--- Quote from: Gilead on 24 Feb 2009, 07:17 ---
--- Quote from: viatriphop on 20 Feb 2009, 07:15 ---[ giving Jeph some positive feedback so he won't die of all these lazer beams of death.]
Don't know if I'm the only one who is thinking this but I feel if the storyline or art is pressured it in anything it ruins everything.
So all this " this comic's strip is better then yours wah wap wah" stuff is kind of a buzz kill at least for me if I was in his shoes.
I think QC is alright how it is- its a comic that entertains people and has its up and downs like every other comic or anything else for the matter. So yeah thats my two cents aimed at all the HxC crazy QC fans who drive me up a wall.
I mean the stuff I read its like you live in the QC town and all the QC cast is your BFF.
Take the red pill blue pill red pill people!
--- End quote ---
An artist should consider the criticism he recieves and try to push himself in new directions and improve his work or he'll become shitty and stagnant. Debaser's advice was actually really really good and sucking jeph's dick and telling him to never change just because it's 'good enough' is really dumb.
--- End quote ---
Yes it is, but expressing it like Jeph was some kind of absolute newbie to the process and absolutely helpless without his help isn't really productive and/or constructive either, right?
Gilead:
Apparently it did since jeph is not a 14 year old girl and took it in to consideration instead of crying about the fact that it wasn't phrased in the nicest way.
Also your analogy to what debaser said was really innacurate.
Strike Da Mic:
--- Quote from: Gilead on 24 Feb 2009, 09:14 ---Apparently it did since jeph is not a 14 year old girl and took it in to consideration instead of crying about the fact that it wasn't phrased in the nicest way.
Also your analogy to what debaser said was really innacurate.
--- End quote ---
The first line in your post, quoted above, is really inaccurate (see bold text). I wouldn't say that he "cried" about it, but he remarked it in a rather clear way, I'd say. And I think he was right about doing that.
I don't consider it inaccurate (except for the 'relationship going bad' part maybe, because Jeph's comic is obviously doing great), only exaggerated to emphasise the point.
Anyway, I think he should just leave it like it is and continue. I admire his work, and in all the strips he has created so far, there wasn't a single one which I really disliked (and I don't mean the 'meh, I dunno, this one wasn't really THAT good' way of disliking something).
debaser:
ok, I've come to terms. After reading this latest strip I now see what you want QC to be and I can respect it. I was just confused
Anyway, sorry for being a dick, that was uncalled for. OP and QC are entirely different comics done by entirely different people with entirely different goals and I shouldn't have made such a rude comparison. I was young and dumb.
jwhouk:
I find it ironic that it wasn't Faye who laid him out with a roundhouse right, but Dora.
Faye not doing anything was so against her character that it was about the only thing she could do.
Either way - awesome sauce with a slice of cheesecake, Jeph.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version