Fun Stuff > BAND
Album Nomination Game -- ROUND THREE
Johnny C:
--- Quote from: SilentJ on 12 Apr 2009, 21:09 ---Not trying to just shit all over you guys
--- End quote ---
Just vote for the albums you think are best.
MrBlu:
ME:
Beatles
Bob Dylan
Yeller:
Public Enemy
AB-Freakin'-STAIN
Money&Cabbages:
Mogwai
Beatles
Mmm, Citrus:
Abstain
The Clash.
pwhodges:
Now it gets really interesting. As has been said, no strategic voting - we're not trying for a predetermined outcome, are we? Each match is on its own, and only the album counts (we could conceivably have Beatles vs Dylan in three votes, but it wouldn't go the same way each time for me). What matters is the criteria for deciding, and those will be personal as they have not been defined. For me, each album is first judged against its own critereria, in its own time, then against other criteria as a tie-breaker. So how well do the Beatles do music? or Dylan do social commentary? I can also judge these in their own times; but some will only be able to see them as coming from a past they are less familiar with. Sometimes it's just a matter of simple preference, though.
Sgt Pepper (sorry NMH, but you don't match the musical variety and innovation)
Bringing it all back Home
Deciding between these will get really hard...
OK Computer (I just can't stand rap)
Kind of Blue
Happy Songs
Highway 61 revisited (Abbey Road is good, but not as wide-ranging or interesting as Sgt Pepper)
Things we lost
Pet Sounds (Shame to lose The Clash, though)
Cire27:
BLUE:
NMH
Bob Dylan
YELLOW:
Public Enemy
Abstain
GREEN:
Joy Division
The Beatles
ORANGE:
Low
The Clash
mberan42:
Again, RL stuff cropped up; apologies.
Give me 12-14 hours.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version