Fun Stuff > ENJOY
Book to movie inconsistencies that are genuinely annoying and unneeded
Inlander:
What? I was practically dancing in the streets when I heard they'd axed that prattling fool of a character!
McTaggart:
Wait, Witch King? And who was Eowyn again? Man there was so much more crap in these books than any story really needed.
MadassAlex:
Agreed on Tom Bombadil, but disagreeing with the post right above mine. If you don't know who the Witch King or Eowyn are, then you pretty much missed a fair bit of the plot anyway and have no place in such a discussion.
Jimmy the Squid:
Just re-watched Order of The Phoenix and there is only one real problem I have with that film. At the beginning when Harry and his escorts arrive at 12 Grimmauld place, Moody taps his stick/cane/staff on the ground and the house appears. How much harder would it have been to have the letter from Dumbledore knocked up by the prop department and just have Moody give Harry the parchment? Maybe a quick close up of the letter over Harry's shoulder and there, done. That kind of irritated me.
scarred:
Speaking of Order of the Phoenix, did anyone else catch what Sirius says to Harry right before he dies?
"Nice one, James!"
I thought it was a really nice and subtle, nuanced way of summing up Sirius' mental confusion / wishful thinking without wasting a ton of screen time on it.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version