Fun Stuff > CHATTER

Mafia - Big Village

<< < (45/56) > >>

Patrick:
Yeah, but if voting for people makes you mafia, and if staying silent means you're shady and therefore either mafia or vigilante, then that's something of a catch-22.

I think we should focus on less pathetic ways to figure out who's suspicious or not. Such as common denominators.

henri bemis:

--- Quote from: J on 04 Dec 2012, 23:43 ---
and if i were in the mafia, wouldn't i be more likely to cast votes, since i would know who all the other mobsters were & could make sure to only lynch the innocent?


--- End quote ---

not necessarily - we've been pretty good at attacking our own so far without much help :/

but I do agree that there's probably at least one mafioso among those who voted for Whitey Fats (which does include me, but I know I'm not mafia, even if I can't prove it).  It wouldn't be wise for all of them to vote the same way, but Carl-E did start it.

Black Sword:
Welp. Three for Patrick, one for idontunderstand, one for theevildog, one for J, one for Carl-E. Sorry, Patrick.


After much debate and accusation, Patrick was voted to be hanged by the barest majority. It seems the poor fellow, with his thousand-mile stare, had offended quite a few of his fellow villagers by existing. Over his protestations of innocence and pleas of exhaustion, he was hung by his earlobes until he could wear ear rings. Then he was hung from cesium133's tree with said ear rings in his ears.

Only after a search of his home was it discovered that Patrick was formerly a member of the police, and likely the only sane cop left in the village. Appalled, the villagers scurried home and barred their doors.

Night 3
Send in your actions, folks.

Carl-E:

--- Quote from: Carl-E on 29 Nov 2012, 08:26 ---Bear's dead. 


Good steak, though. 


Oh, I know!  Who hasn't posted yet?

--- End quote ---

--- Quote from: Carl-E on 29 Nov 2012, 19:46 ---I usually think Gnomes is on something (have you seen him in the welcome thread?).  However, his general randomness is probably as good as anything else right now - unless we hear from an officer of the law about something he or she has found.

--- End quote ---

--- Quote from: Carl-E on 30 Nov 2012, 05:46 ---OK, just going on the "no posts makes them suspicious" idea, the only one who hasn't posted yet is Whitey Fats.  You may recall him, his avatar (and real name, apparently) is Randy...

I mean, I tend to believe Patrick about his job...

And though J makes a good point about idontunderstand's speed with his pitchfork, that can be chalked up to general excitability. 

*sigh*

I'm just going to wait a bit.  THis is getting difficult!

--- End quote ---

--- Quote from: Carl-E on 01 Dec 2012, 00:52 ---[lots of meaningless analysis]

I agree Gareth probably got whacked because he was acting out, I'm sure the mafia thought he was covering something up; but since he wasn't revealed to be the vigilante or a cop or even a mason, it all must have been a ruse.  But here we seem to be going the other way, thinking that people who are quiet are covering something up.  But even idontunderstand didn't feel right about his vote [for Patrick]. 

*sigh*.  We're going to wake up tomorrow to another death (probably two), and we've really got nothing to go on.  All we can do at this point is hope we're lucky enough to take out a mafiosi. 

But I'm going to make it a real race, and nominate the one person who hasn't felt the need to defend themselves - I move we take Whitey Fats out back.

--- End quote ---

Sorry to self quote, but you'll notice that between my suggesting that we go for someone who didn't speak yet and finally settling on Whitey Fats, there were nearly two days of deliberations!  Patrick finally joined in the game, too.  If I wanted Whitey dead, I would have nominated him earlier! 



Yes, mistakes were made, but with nothing to go on, it was a random choice based on a bad criterion.  Unfortunately, no one's raised anything better to use yet.  Patrick, what kind of commonalities are you thinking of?  Voting blocks?  Do we even have any?  Anyone want to make a list? 

Warning - while you were typing someone you were talking to was lynched. You may wish to review your post.

Dammit! 

TheEvilDog:
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO! NOT PATRICK! NOT HIM!

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page

[*] Previous page