Fun Stuff > CHATTER

Mafia 2 - Wolf Forest

<< < (42/54) > >>

riccostar:
goodness! (posting for my life here)
Why won't Gareth trust me after we saved him by believing his claim to be hunter?   :cry:

If I didn't take into consideration Gareth's claim to be the hunter I'd definitely be looking to him as a possible werewolf.  The night after he was saved by his claim the werewolves probably should have killed him, if he is the hunter they would have killed the hunter and if he isn't the hunter they would have killed a villager.  He would be an ideal target for them unless he is a werewolf himself.  Because of this I believe that Gareth has the highest chance out of all of us to be a werewolf and I would be voting for him except that I probably won't because I'm too afraid that he in fact is the hunter...

Zingoleb:
Except that the priest is very likely protecting him, so they'd have to target the priest before they could remove the hunter, so your logic fails once more.

riccostar:
The priest wouldn't be protecting him though. Why would the priest take a chance on a possibly fake hunter when the priest could spend his prayers on a for sure important innocent, namely, himself.

Lines:
What evidence is there that he's NOT the hunter? Or that the priest isn't protecting him? You wouldn't know that unless you are one of the two characters. And at this point in the game, you can't disprove you aren't a wolf by speculating what others may or may not be.

The reason I chose to believe Gareth is because he would totally chop into heads and disembowel people. (Sorry dude, but uh, you're sick like that.)

Game and Watch Forever:
Oh god, I hope Gareth is using a sharp implement to do all this and not his pe-- *brain shuts down*

*one brain reboot later*
Whether Gareth is being protected by the priest is dependent on the priest's faith. No, not in God. In Gareth. If they believe him, they are probably protecting him. And if they're not, then they're probably protecting themselves (or someone else if they know or believe something else entirely). Either way, the werewolves (assuming he isn't one of them) aren't going to take that risk.

Here's a follow up question... if Gareth isn't the hunter, then what's the real hunter doing about it? I would imagine they'd be doing two things:
1) Aiming to kill Gareth at night
2) Argue against Gareth during the day (either with sound reasoning or counter-claiming)

Would you, as a hunter, seriously target cesium at night if you knew beyond a reasonable doubt that Gareth was lying and probably a werewolf? I wouldn't, though maybe somebody else can explain why it would make more sense....

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page

[*] Previous page