Fun Stuff > CHATTER
Mafia 2 - Wolf Forest
henri bemis:
--- Quote from: riccostar on 24 Dec 2012, 21:01 ---The priest wouldn't be protecting him though. Why would the priest take a chance on a possibly fake hunter when the priest could spend his prayers on a for sure important innocent, namely, himself.
--- End quote ---
This stands out to me. Our GM said the Priest cannot protect himself, which is something the ricco would surely know if he were, indeed, the Priest.
Was that statement really intentional, or are you just retconning an alibi? I'm honestly not sure which answer is more convoluted/diabolical/crafty...
I do understand why you'd state your role, though, IF you are the Priest - You're facing a lynch, and you might get killed by the werewolves tonight, but if you survive the day, you can at least go down protecting someone. That would be noble.
The question is are you really the Priest, or just trying to save your ass?
Patrick:
--- Quote from: henri bemis on 27 Dec 2012, 00:36 ---The question is are you really the Priest, or just trying to save your ass?
--- End quote ---
This is exactly the point in my thought process where I thought, "...and if the latter, why?"
I was iffy at first because I don't wanna bandwagon it, but I'm slightly more certain now.
Lines:
After reading what the others have said and analyzing posts again, I am revoting to hang riccostar. I was confused, but ricco, if you were the priest, you should have known more about the role. I think you're a wolf trying to disguise yourself as the priest and are doing anything/everything to save your hide.
henri bemis:
After re-reading the thread, I'm voting for Unicorn.
Speculating about what the werewolves will do is one thing, but you always seem so certain, like you're trying to set us up. You were right about cesium, but he got killed at night (by the hunter, I think?), and it's not unheard of for the mafia/werewolf/whatever faction to turn on each other. I think you either took a calculated risk in making him suspicious (figuring we wouldn't vote to lynch him), or you ARE the hunter, and killed him after we failed to. But I think Gareth's case for being the hunter is pretty strong, so I'm leaning toward the former scenario. You also said you believed J, but didn't change your vote, which would have saved him.
Zingoleb:
Yeah, no, I'm definitely not the hunter.
I'm honestly not sure why you say I seem so certain, given that most of what I say is accompanied by something to the effect of "I have no idea if this person is innocent or not, so I'm kind of vaguely suspicious but can't really prove anything". The people I did vote for and finger were people that I thought were guilty because I was poring over everything they said and trying to dissect the intent behind it.
...which I guess kind of hurts me, since I've said a lot myself to be dissected.
I'm honestly unsure what it would benefit me, though, were I a werewolf, to turn on the other one? That would just limit our numbers if that were the case, and that's just practically shooting myself in the foot.
That said, I can do my best to assure you that I'm pretty sure I'm not the werewolf, unless something's going on that I'm unaware of.
Also, changing my vote wouldn't have saved J, which is why I didn't change it. There still would have been a majority to lynch him if I retracted my vote or not.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version