Fun Stuff > BAND
Most Hurtful Record Review Ever
Freezey:
http://www.punknews.org/reviews.php?op=albumreview&id=2881
Wonderful.
Merkava:
Now THOSE are good concept reviews. :P
McTaggart:
Some of the comments are even better.
Kai:
--- Quote from: La Creme ---Dog Fashion Disco
--- End quote ---
Dog Fashion Disco is like, really fucking boring and shitty. To the 16th power.
tomgadd:
--- Quote from: Se7en ---
No, i dont think you HAVE a point. Art is entirely subjective right? Music is art. So is writing. And you critisise a peice of creative writing on the subject of music, on objective grounds?
--- End quote ---
Art is entirely subjective? But by applying the objective categories of subjectivity/objectivity to art, havnt you denied its subjectivity even as you speak it? And furthermore, is all art subjective? When art is trying to make a point, as a lot of art does (ever actually been to an art museum?), then its success in conveying the feeling, reasoning, or information that it wanted to convey is an objective criterion by which we can judge that art. Furthermore, why should we take beauty to be subjective? For what reason (remember, if it is entirely subjective then you cannot legitimately criticise my views about it on objective grounds, but by believing it to be objective I am free to ask for objective grounding for your belief. The wonders of self-referentially incoherent opponents) should we believe that art actually IS subjective? I am inclined to believe that art has some objective criteria by which we can judge it, especially if that art has a purpose. Such as reviewing a record. If the point of a piece of art is to review a record, then maybe it can give me some fucking information about said record. Otherwise, I am pretty fucking certain that its a heck of shitty piece of art.
And all of this notwithstanding, why the heck did someone ressurect this thread? I havn't been on the forum in years, but is this a new trend? Or has noone noticed the timestamp on the first post?
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version