I like the new album a lot, actually. Sure, it's more 'standard' pop/rock than their first disc, but they do it really well. Yes, it's very much the same in tone and pace as their first disc, but there are enough differences for me to make it enjoyable.
Also, "Goodnight, Goodnight" is a terrific song, I listen to it hellsalot. The chorus slays, I tell you! SLAYS>