a;jdhalkjsh! YES.
Clap Your Hands Say Yeah are great. I wouldn't be too ashamed of buying a CD based off of a Pitchfork review. I don't agree with them all the time, but generally when they give an album a good review, it's truly a good album. I still give the poorer fair a chance, too, and I like tons of shit "they" could care less about. If you feel too ashamed for Pitchfork, check out MetaCritic to see reviews from multiple sources, then make your own decision.