THESE FORUMS NOW CLOSED (read only)
Fun Stuff => ENJOY => Topic started by: Inlander on 12 Nov 2006, 16:37
-
. . . by Margaret Atwood. Just finished reading it. Anyone else read it? (Or, at a stretch, seen the movie?)
Seems like a book worthy of discussion.
-
I've read it. But it was a while ago, so if I were to make an attempt at discussing it, I'd need something to go on in terms of reminding me what went on in it.
I recall being disappointed by the ending, although the book itself was good.
-
Which aspect of the ending, the ending of the novel itself or the "historical notes" appendix?
I thought the ending of the novel itself was fine, it's certainly not the only novel or story to end on such an ambiguous note. But the appendix fudged the issue a bit - while it was amusing to read, it seemed to be almost as if Atwood was saying "But really it's okay, I got a bit dark in this novel but it all ends happily eventually." Which weakened the impact of the novel for me, somewhat.
-
I have read the book MANY times and seen the movie! Margaret Atwood is one of my favorite writers.
I do see what you guys are saying about the ending. But here's my question: If you think it's unsuitable, how would you have ended the book?
-
I think the novel is great and ends perfectly, and in a perfectly suitable manner. I think that the appendix, though amusing, is unnecessary and possibly a little detrimental to the novel that's gone before it. I'm not really sure why Atwood put it in there, other than for a bit of a laugh. I really see the novel and the appendix as two seperate entities.
-
i'm going to go on record as saying that i don't like margaret atwood the novelist. she gets the recognition that a number of more interesting and far superior canadian writers deserve. she is, on the other hand, a splendid poet and a great literary analyst.
-
My brother read a load of Atwood books since he was studying The Handmaids Tale and loved them all except the Handmaids Tale (unlucky I suppose, or perhaps an inevitable consequence of studying a book?) which sort of put me off since we have a pretty similar taste in books, films, music etc. Oryx and Crake by Atwood is currently on my 'to read' list but Ive got a stack of books I HAVE to read for my studies first so its a fair way down the list. If I enjoy that I will probably read Handmaids Tale at some point.
-
I have a huge seething hatred for this novel. And most of Atwood's stuff, come to think of it. But particularly this novel. Been a while since I've read it, but I'll always remember how much I loathed the main character, she was so objectionable at times.
And yes, it may be a realistic study of what somebody would do under the circumstances, but I just found it quite depressing.
-
This is one of my top 5 books of all time. It's perfectly conveys the idea of essentially living in the corner of a bedroom. Such an amazing dystopia, although I really abhor the appendix. It should have ended when the novel ends.
-
I liked the appendix, the light-heartedness and the distant treatment of the main story gave it a cruel twist.
-
Oryx and Crake is a good read as well, but my favorite Atwood novel is The Blind Assasin.
Edited for sticky keyboards and not reading the post before clicking "submit"
-
The movie was strange for me because it was shot in places that I frequented.
Also, it's "Crake".