THESE FORUMS NOW CLOSED (read only)

Fun Stuff => BAND => Topic started by: backtobasics on 01 Feb 2007, 07:08

Title: top 10 bands
Post by: backtobasics on 01 Feb 2007, 07:08
OK so what are your favorite 10 bands, and why? I thought it would be interesting to get everyone?s takes and opinion.

(in no particular order)
Libertines (just a good band)
Babyshambles (Pete Doherty is a great lyricist, and I love British music)
Reel Big Fish (amazing live shows, and the songs are full of energy)
Streetlight Manifesto (Jersey ska I rest my case)
Arcade Fire (Melodic and all around great)
Architecture in Helsinki (can't beat upbeat pop)
Playradioplay (happy electronic indie)
Jerry Garcia (I'm a hippy enough said)
Zolof the Rock and Roll destroyer (another upbeat band)
Sufjan Stevens (songs are just written very well)
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: öde on 01 Feb 2007, 07:23
Libertines (just a good band)
Babyshambles (Pete Doherty is a great lyricist, and I love British music)

No.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: kablaaamo on 01 Feb 2007, 07:43
Hah. Alright, I'll bite. Judge me.

Apostle of Hustle
Final Fantasy
The Most Serene Republic
Malajube
Wax Mannequin
Islands
The Weakerthans
Grizzly Bear
the Mountain Goats
Destroyer

I am too lazy to put why.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Scytale on 01 Feb 2007, 07:52
Therion
Summoning
Judas Iscariot
Burzum
At The Gates
Nargaroth
The Mars Volta
Pink Floyd
Limbonic Art
Opeth
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: ScrambledGregs on 01 Feb 2007, 07:53
The Fresh Prince and DJ Jazzy Jeff
The Partridge Family
That One Band They Had On Saved By The Bell Once
Steve from Blues Clues
Puddle of Mudd
the chick from Friends who sings on the show sometimes
The B Sharps
Kevin Shields (post-Loveless)
The bee from the Nasonex commercials (he signs, doesn't he??)
Fergie
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: BillAdama on 01 Feb 2007, 07:57
All time output:

Bob Dylan
Radiohead
Nirvana
Rolling Stones
Beatles
Joni Mitchell
Neil Young
Wilco
David Bowie
White Stripes

Recent output:

Wilco
White Stripes
Radiohead
Sleater-Kinney
Joanna Newsom
Bob Dylan
Flaming Lips
Sufjan Stevens
Bob Dylan
New Pornographers
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: carrotosaurus on 01 Feb 2007, 08:01
Steve from Blues Clues

He actually has an album out and one in the process. Steve Drozd plays drums for him, and Dave Fridmann is his producer. I can't make up shit this wacky if I tried.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: valley_parade on 01 Feb 2007, 09:12
1. Lawrence Arms
2. Sigur Ros
3. Motorhead
4. Queen
5. Ted Leo & Pharmacists
6. Zep
7. The Ramones
8. The Police
9. Bad Religion
10. Chris Walla as a solo artist, so much better than the combined efforts of DCfC.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Kyros on 01 Feb 2007, 10:19
As of right now(this is always subject to change):

1) The Dismemberment Plan
2) Ted Leo + RX
3) Sonic Youth
4) Guided by Voices
5) Built to Spill
7) Modest Mouse
8) The White Stripes
9) Belle & Sebastian
10) Radiohead
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Jackie Blue on 01 Feb 2007, 10:33
Hm...

Joy Division
Spiritualized
The Legendary Pink Dots
A Silver Mt. Zion
Tom Waits
Mogwai
Sonic Youth
Yo La Tengo
Broken Social Scene
Acid Mothers Temple
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Ernest on 01 Feb 2007, 11:29
OK so what are your favorite 10 bands, and why? I thought it would be interesting to get everyone?s takes and opinion.

(in no particular order)
Libertines (just a good band)
Babyshambles (Pete Doherty is a great lyricist, and I love British music)
Reel Big Fish (amazing live shows, and the songs are full of energy)
Streetlight Manifesto (Jersey ska I rest my case)
Arcade Fire (Melodic and all around great)
Architecture in Helsinki (can't beat upbeat pop)
Playradioplay (happy electronic indie)
Jerry Garcia (I'm a hippy enough said)
Zolof the Rock and Roll destroyer (another upbeat band)
Sufjan Stevens (songs are just written very well)


It's very clear that you are new to these forums, because you clearly are looking for some sort of validation.

Whatever, off the top of my head:
Fugazi
Sonic Youth
Polvo
At the Drive-In
Propagandhi
Jethro Tull
Neutral Milk Hotel
The Pixies
Drive Like Jehu
Dinosaur Jr
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Inlander on 01 Feb 2007, 13:51
Tommy, you forgot Wet Wet Wet!
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Thrillho on 01 Feb 2007, 13:58
Well, I'll go for this. In no order:

1. Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds
2. Wilco
3. Joy Division
4. Weezer
5. The Beatles
6. Pink Floyd
7. Hope of the States
8. Blur
9. blink-182
10. Hundred Reasons

By the way; I am actually going to rape you for liking Babyshambles.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Inlander on 01 Feb 2007, 14:00
What is it with you and rape?
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: ScrambledGregs on 01 Feb 2007, 14:01
Steve from Blues Clues

He actually has an album out and one in the process. Steve Drozd plays drums for him, and Dave Fridmann is his producer. I can't make up shit this wacky if I tried.

I did know that actually, I just don't take it seriously because it's a competent but not amazing album.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Thrillho on 01 Feb 2007, 14:03
What is it with you and rape?

[size=20]RAPEZ LOL[/size]
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Jackie Blue on 01 Feb 2007, 14:06

1. Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds
2. Wilco
3. Joy Division
4. Weezer
5. The Beatles
6. Pink Floyd
7. Hope of the States
8. Blur
9. blink-182
10. Hundred Reasons

Blur, Weezer and blink-182 on the same list as Joy Division, Pink Floyd and Nick Cave?

*head explodes*
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: TheFuriousWombat on 01 Feb 2007, 14:11


these are my top ten current favorites (not all time, but some of these are certainly on this list). it's not in order

sigur ros
mono
mogwai
neutral milk hotel
do make say think
the lovely feathers
godspeed you! black emperor
eluvium
the decemberists
joanna newsom
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Thrillho on 01 Feb 2007, 14:11
OMGZ DUDE!

A great deal of the music by both Blur and Weezer is as literate, eclectic and varied as Joy Division, Pink Floyd and Nick Cave.

In fact, I'd say that Blur have a lot more variety than Joy Division for certain.

But feel free to splutter at blink-182; they are a guilty, shameless pop pleasure for me.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: minkles on 01 Feb 2007, 14:20
This may or may not be in order.  Don't get offended.

Pixies
Neutral Milk Hotel
Modest Mouse
The Velvet Underground
The Decemberists
The Who
The Beatles
Belle and Sebastian
Spoon
The Clash
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Jackie Blue on 01 Feb 2007, 14:22
I actually like early Blur and Weezer's second album, but... Weezer as varied as Pink Floyd?  Dude.  I think you need to listen to Piper and Meddle again.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Thrillho on 01 Feb 2007, 14:23
I actually like early Blur and Weezer's second album, but... Weezer as varied as Pink Floyd?  Dude.  I think you need to listen to Piper and Meddle again.


I wasn't saying that both of them were all three compared to all three.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: KharBevNor on 01 Feb 2007, 14:31
1 Skyclad (Best lyrics ever, witty, satirical, human, eccentric Skyclad is everything I love about Britain as an anti-nationalist)
2 Sol Invictus (Incredible atmosphere, and again, brilliant lyrics, this time just hitting like a punch to the stomach)
3 Current 93 (Intricate personal mythology creates a fascinating and illuminating journey through beautiful soundscapes)
4 Edge of Sanity (One of the most innovative and under-rated metal bands of all time. DAN SWANO IST KRIEEEG!)   
5 Coil (Gayer than Elton John sitting on a wedding cake, more experimental than William Burroughs turning Einsteins brain in to a cut-up poem)
6 Inkubus Sukkubus (My guilty pleasure? Ecstatic pagan goth rock. I don't really know why I like them so much, but I just DO)   
7 Sopor Aeternus & The Ensemble of Shadows (A tortured, strange human heart opened up in music. Beautiful)   
8 Agalloch (Post everything, a drift of smoke through dead forests, a leaf-strewn path of bones, the ultimate apocalyptic music)
9 Death in June (Layers of occult metaphor and meaning woven over some of the catchiest hooks and drum beats ever written)
10 Ewigkeit (Pure insanity, bought to you by one man and his basement, live from the doors of perception. I want to meet James Fogarty so badly.)   

...possibly. But there's lots of worrying ommissions from that where I just can't remove another band. I can't believe Bathory, My Dying Bride, Ancient Rites or Pink Floyd aren't up there.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Jackie Blue on 01 Feb 2007, 14:47
I can't believe you put Current 93 on and NOT The Legendary Pink Dots.   :oops:
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: godinpants on 01 Feb 2007, 17:57
Hmm I think I could narrow it down to 10.

First and foremost.

Phish - Pure musical heaven.

Now everything else in no real order.

Pink Floyd - mostly for the Animals album.

Primus - As a young bassist they turned me to the world outside of punk.

Rage Against the Machine - Just excellent.

The Frog Brigade - This band is like the band to end all bands, awesome jams, Claypool, Eenor, Skerik. What more do you need?

The Living End - Ive seen these guys so many times and I still love them.

Yes - Especially the Rick Wakeman albums.

Mogwai - I only got into these guys in the last 6 months but I'm hooked.

Trey Anastasio's solo work.

Bela Fleck and the Flecktones - Bela Fleck and Vic Wooten in the one band. Oh, whats this FUTUREMAN. I think yes. (Going to see them in April)


Thats mine.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: backtobasics on 01 Feb 2007, 18:13
whats wrong with the babyshambles?
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Inlander on 01 Feb 2007, 18:20
Other people don't like them and those people believe themselves to be cooler than the people who do like them.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: fish across face on 01 Feb 2007, 18:41
Why "bands"?
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Scytale on 01 Feb 2007, 19:14
Inkubus Sukkubus

Fuck I thought I was the only one who had ever heard of these guys. A friend of mine used to be pretty into them... Any reccomendations, All I've heard is parts of "Vampyre Erotica"...
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: onewheelwizzard on 01 Feb 2007, 20:13
Kyuss
Dead Meadow
OM
Acid Mothers Temple
13th Floor Elevators
Love
Donovan
Ramona Cordova
Jack Rose
Masters of Reality

I've been on a Super Furry Animals kick recently, though.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: KharBevNor on 01 Feb 2007, 20:30
I can't believe you put Current 93 on and NOT The Legendary Pink Dots.   :oops:

I like the Legendary Pink Dots. I like hundreds of bands. I just prefer those ten.

@Scytale: I'm going to be brutally honest, most of their stuff is pretty samey. On an intellectual level I just should not like them, at least not as much.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: jcknbl on 01 Feb 2007, 21:13
Pixies (Ridiculously consistent, perfect song writing, Surfer Rosa might be better mixed than any album ever)
Deerhoof (I love how they can write a great pop hook as well as they can dismantle one. They're one of the few bands that make me laugh with glee at their surprises)
David Bowie (What the hell am I supposed to say?)
Kraftwerk (Well electronic music would barely exist without them. Their work manages to be transcendent while encapsulating post-war cultural shifts)
Can (Krautrock legends, another band that makes me laugh without telling jokes. The weirdest act on this list)
The Field Mice (This band will probably never be on any official "greatest" lists. The were the top act on Sarah records which only put out singles- that doesn't really give you legend status. The singles aren't even THAT incredible, they're special for me though.)
My Bloody Valentine (Believe it or not Loveless isn't the only thing they good they put out. But yeah... that album)
The Fugees (One album. But its the best hip hop album ever- they manage to have excellent production to match the best rhymes of the 90's)
Q and Not U (post-hardcore from my home city. Partly dance punk without all the terrible things that dance punk became, partly beautiful guitar melodies and solid drumming that all fits perfectly)
Yo La Tengo (Consistent, superb noise pop (if you haven't noticed I have a thing for that sub genre)
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: magnanimusman on 01 Feb 2007, 21:16
1.  The Beatles (lyrics...sheer volume and variety of really great music)
2.  Led Zepplin (Amazing...just amazing.)
3.  Red Hot Chili Peppers (Sometimes fun and sometimes soulful.
4.  Miles Davis (Phenominal and brilliant improvisationalist)
5.  John Colhtrane (where Davis was cool Colhtrane had heart)
6.  Bob Dylan (Amazing lyrics and an addictive voice
7.  Pixies (Great just great
8.  Architecture in Helsinki(damned if I know why...its really different from what I normally listen to)
9.  Beastie Boys (they are so damn fun to listen to)
10. Gilberto Gil or Baden Powell i think...its tough.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: debaser24/7 on 01 Feb 2007, 21:43
The Decemberists (This is mostly because of Castaways and Cutouts. The combination of the lyrics and thesound they had back then just floors me. Their other albums have their moments too.)
My Bloody Valentine (Mostly because of Loveless, but I like how that sound on that album was developed over time)
Menomena (They have a unique sound and do it well)
Nick Drake (A great musician and songwriter)
M. Ward (he has a fantastic voice)
Architecture in Helsinki
Andrew Bird
Vetiver
Ted Leo & The Pharmacists
Arcade Fire
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Johnny C on 01 Feb 2007, 21:48
I think I can only give you my top four.

1) Talking Heads
2) Huey Lewis & The News
3) Genesis
4) Whitney Houston
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Ernest on 01 Feb 2007, 22:10
Fuck I forgot The Fall.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: blackmage on 02 Feb 2007, 01:03
I can't put it in any order, but here's my current top 10:

Thrice
My Chemical Romance (Yes, my guilty pop love)
Mogwai
The Faint
Saosin
Cursive
Muse
UnderOath
Death Cab for Cutie
AFI
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Evil_Lathander on 02 Feb 2007, 01:13
Judas Priest
Nightwish
Slayer
Dream Theater
Black Sabbath
Nine Inch Nails
Scar Symmetry
Rammstein
Rhapsody
System of A Down
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Gridgm on 02 Feb 2007, 04:26
The Living End - Ive seen these guys so many times and I still love them.

fucking A

whats isn't wrong with the babyshambles?

sorry jsut fixed your quote
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Thrillho on 02 Feb 2007, 07:16
whats wrong with the babyshambles?

I'm not sure you want me to get into that, mate.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Vanilla Gorilla on 02 Feb 2007, 07:52
man, i havent heard of 80% of these bands you guys listed...i have a lot of searching to do
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: ScrambledGregs on 02 Feb 2007, 08:49
Hmm I think I could narrow it down to 10.

First and foremost.

Phish - Pure musical heaven.


Hello, friend!!
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Takeru on 02 Feb 2007, 09:06
In no particular order...

The Academy Is...
As Cities Burn
Chiodos
Fall of Troy
Gatsby's American Dream
He Is Legend
Jimmy Eat World
Northstar
The Receiving End of Sirens
Under Oath
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: BillAdama on 02 Feb 2007, 09:10
For some reason I totally blanked on Pixies and Sonic Youth in my list.

So tack them on.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Kai on 03 Feb 2007, 07:22
1. The Stooges
2. The Stooges
3. The Stooges
4. The Stooges
5. The Stooges
6. The Stooges
7. The Stooges
8. The Stooges
9. The Stooges
10. Boston
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Thrillho on 03 Feb 2007, 07:29
Dude, Iggy Pop's not a band.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Kai on 03 Feb 2007, 07:30
Fixed for technicality
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: ScrambledGregs on 03 Feb 2007, 08:03
Dude, Iggy Pop's not a band.

So wait, this thread was ONLY about music made by groups of people?? Doesn't that necessarily eliminate a lot of people from our lists??
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Valdemar on 03 Feb 2007, 08:21
Not to mention that plenty of groups are really just one person's vision and compositions.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: kallisti on 03 Feb 2007, 08:31
This is probably a mix of "right now" and "ever ever ever" but here you are:


David Bowie
Neutral Milk Hotel/Jeff Mangum
Pavement
Pulp
The Pixies
The Smiths
Architecture in Helsinki
Blonde Redhead
T. Rex
The Unicorns

I already want to edit it again. A top 15 might be easier, or a top 5. Sigh.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Luke C on 03 Feb 2007, 08:34
1. Led Zep
2. Pink Floyd
3. Metallica
4. System of a Down
5. Megadeth
6. Chili Peppers
7. Black Label Society
8. R.E.M.
9. Pantera
10. Dragonforce
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: kallisti on 03 Feb 2007, 08:55
Hooray!  So very happy am I!
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Joseph on 03 Feb 2007, 09:57
The Stooges
The Doors
Bruce Springsteen (& The E Street Band for all you picky "bands only" people)
Wolf Parade
Godspeed You! Black Emperor
Owls
Wilco
Massive Attack
Stars
Sonic Youth

Weezer was close to making this list, and definately would've if it weren't for Make Believe.  If I was judging them based on their first three or four albums, they'd be top five, I'm fairly sure.

Oh, and of course, there's no order to the list, and it's subject to change.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Thrillho on 03 Feb 2007, 12:53
I'm not the one who said this thread was for top 10 bands, guys. Bob Dylan would have been high in my list otherwise.

To Dark Flame: you'd judge Weezer on the first four??? I judge them on the first two and the deluxe edition of the first one...
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Joseph on 03 Feb 2007, 15:17
The first two albums are two of my favourites of all time, easily.  In fact, I'd say Pinkerton is a strong contender for my absolute favourite album.  I also really love the third.  It's not nearly as excellent, but it's still a great pop album.  The fourth is still good, though not amazing, it's not a bad mark on them.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: ScrambledGregs on 03 Feb 2007, 18:31
I wish Weezer had somehow changed frontmen after Pinkerton so we could argue over who was a better frontman ala Van Halen, making Weezer's current semi-wholesale theft of the Van Halen logo for their own use all the more pertinent. Are you a Diamond Dave or Sammy man?? More importantly, are you a Rivers Cuomo or Evan Dando man??
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: E. Spaceman on 03 Feb 2007, 19:05
Right now:


REM
New Order
Wilco
Neutral Milk Hotel
Belle and Sebastian
The Kinks
Fugazi
Mogwai
The Beatles
The Velvet Underground

Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: MusicScribbles on 05 Feb 2007, 06:13
OMGZORZ, Guys, you're forgetting Slint! Okay, maybe I'm not enoug of a forumite yet to start that joke up again. How about this list, which is in no particular order as I've decided not to put any thought into it.
Pavement
Boredoms
Deerhoof
Animal Collective
Blonde Redhead
David Bowie
Velvet Underground
Pixies
Broken Social Scene
Neutral Milk Hotel
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: kokeyjoe on 05 Feb 2007, 06:30
Toby Keith pwns you all.  Right in the face.

Okay, actually attempting to take this thread semi-seriously now...

Me likey deez bandz and arrtists..
Dream Theater
Spock's Beard
Danzig
Anthrax
Steve Vai
Opeth
Led Zeppelin
Transatlantic
King's X
Megadeth

That's about the best list of 10 I can compile without looking at any of my CDs or mp3s.  Manja.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Johnny C on 05 Feb 2007, 07:46
Guys, you're forgetting Slint! Okay, maybe I'm not enoug of a forumite yet to start that joke up again.

Joke?
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: ScrambledGregs on 05 Feb 2007, 07:49
Well, it's sort of a half joke. Most of us do in fact love Slint.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Thrillho on 05 Feb 2007, 08:58
OMGZORZ, Guys, you're forgetting Slint!

(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v77/DynamiteKid156/Sigs/Wrong03.jpg)
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Jackie Blue on 05 Feb 2007, 15:06
Slint had one highly influential but questionably great album and one rather bad album that nobody listens to.  I don't think I have ever seen anyone say they were one of the best bands of all time based on that extremely limited output.

I have a problem putting Neutral Milk Hotel that high for the same reason - sure, Jeff and co. made two great albums, but does that really make them a "great band of all time" compared to artists who have done 10, 20, 30, 40+ great albums?  I think quantity and diversity of output should factor in it somewhere.  At least it does for me, which is why I had to give it up for Tom Waits the the Legendary Pink Dots.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: TheFuriousWombat on 05 Feb 2007, 15:34

I have a problem putting Neutral Milk Hotel that high for the same reason - sure, Jeff and co. made two great albums, but does that really make them a "great band of all time" compared to artists who have done 10, 20, 30, 40+ great albums?

yes. yes it does.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Kai on 05 Feb 2007, 15:40
Slint had one highly influential but questionably great album and one rather bad album that nobody listens to.

and an EP that was better than either of them.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Jackie Blue on 05 Feb 2007, 16:31
The EP was alright, but I'd say less people have heard that than even Tweez.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Aidan on 05 Feb 2007, 16:54
My tastes are pretty random (not in order):
1. Bob Dylan
2. Explosions in the Sky
3. Neil Young
4. The Beatles
5. Nickel Creek
6. Modest Mouse
7. Red Hot Chili Peppers
8. The Offspring
9. Pink Floyd
10. Leather Addiction
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Melodic on 05 Feb 2007, 17:16
GUYS JOHNNY WAS BEING FUNNY.
YOU DIDN'T CATCH THAT?
SRSLY.
I like all my music equally. Top 10s are lame.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Johnny C on 05 Feb 2007, 17:27
I feel validated! This is what life is for.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Jackie Blue on 05 Feb 2007, 18:38
I know Johnny was kidding.  My response was more in response to the new guy's apparent attempt to be humorous by referencing something that I've never actually seen happen.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Johnny C on 05 Feb 2007, 19:04
Yes but what you failed to realize is that American Psycho is always comic gold.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Caspian on 05 Feb 2007, 19:17
this is going to freaking hard..

Sigur Ros
Jesu
Metallica
Isis
Jars of Clay
My Bloody Valentine
Meshuggah
Neurosis
Explosions in the Sky
The Angelic Process
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: kallisti on 06 Feb 2007, 02:02
I have a problem putting Neutral Milk Hotel that high for the same reason - sure, Jeff and co. made two great albums, but does that really make them a "great band of all time" compared to artists who have done 10, 20, 30, 40+ great albums? 

Yes because In the Aeroplane Over the Sea is the only non-bowie album I would put in my "best albums of all time" list and that's saying a fuckload for me.  So...yes.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: The extra letter on 06 Feb 2007, 03:16
In a very vague descending order.

Manic Street Preachers
David Bowie
Bauhaus
My Life With The Thrill Kill Kult
Placebo
Ween
The Sisters of Mercy
KMFDM
Peter Murphy
PIG

Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: The Kangmiester on 06 Feb 2007, 05:41
Pink Floyd - Dark Side of the Moon man!
The Stone Roses - Saved British guitar music for a short period
Joy Division - Where do I start?
Oasis - I know Elitist Indie's will scream, but fck you
Nirvana - I don't really need to explain myself
The Clash - hell yeh. punk as it should be
Sex Pistols
Rolling Stones
Beetles
ok not the best band ever, but i do love them, Kasabian
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Thrillho on 06 Feb 2007, 08:50
Pink Floyd - Dark Side of the Moon man!
The Stone Roses - Saved British guitar music for a short period
Joy Division - Where do I start?
Oasis - I know Elitist Indie's will scream, but fck you
Nirvana - I don't really need to explain myself
The Clash - hell yeh. punk as it should be
Sex Pistols
Rolling Stones
Beetles
ok not the best band ever, but i do love them, Kasabian

How have you listed so many of my favourite bands and still made me hate you?

I see you have those few recordings made in the late fifties by John, Paul, George, Pete and Stuart?
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: kallisti on 06 Feb 2007, 09:28
Beetles

They're crunchy.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Jackie Blue on 06 Feb 2007, 11:06
Sigur Ros
Jesu
Metallica
Isis
Jars of Clay
My Bloody Valentine
Meshuggah
Neurosis
Explosions in the Sky
The Angelic Process

If you have not yet listened to Boris' Pink, I think you may find it is the greatest thing you have ever heard, based on your tastes.

And yes, tommy.  Tweez is a bad album.  It grates on my nerves.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Misereatur on 06 Feb 2007, 11:24
As much as I like Pink, I still think Akuma No Uta was better.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Jackie Blue on 06 Feb 2007, 12:09
The new Boris album, the one with Michio Kurihara, sounds like it will be better than Pink.

Akuma No Uta is good, but it doesn't have that... something... that Pink does.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Kadlin on 06 Feb 2007, 12:15

10 Ewigkeit (Pure insanity, bought to you by one man and his basement, live from the doors of perception. I want to meet James Fogarty so badly.)   

Funny enough I had been plugging Ewigkeit for a very very very long fucking time. Since I've always loved his work. Although everywhere I posted about him... people told me it was the worst thing they had heard in many years, now all of a sudden he's huge and all the kiddies like him. I'm so fucking confused.


Anyway top bands.

Vintersorg
Solefald
Arcturus
Borknagar
Ayreon
Therion
UneXpect
Lost Horizon
Blind Guardian
Wintersun

One major problem is.... I actually don't listen to half thos ebands much anymore, but they;re my top bands on lastfm.
The only bands on that list who I listen to regularly is Vintersorg, Solefald, Arcturus, Borknagar and Ayreon.
The others are just... I dunno, I listened to them a lot years ago, now I'm bored.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: SeanBateman on 06 Feb 2007, 12:54
Lose the image sig, doggtown. We do not like those round these parts.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: TheFuriousWombat on 06 Feb 2007, 13:21
Slint had one highly influential but questionably great album and one rather bad album that nobody listens to.

'Tweez' is a bad album


you should have left it at that
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Jed on 06 Feb 2007, 14:56
Branded Women
Cleaning Women
Sigur Ros
Children Of Bodom
Aavikko
CMX
Tom Waits
Jason Webley
Cradle Of Filth
The Mars Volta
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: The Kangmiester on 07 Feb 2007, 05:15
Pink Floyd - Dark Side of the Moon man!
The Stone Roses - Saved British guitar music for a short period
Joy Division - Where do I start?
Oasis - I know Elitist Indie's will scream, but fck you
Nirvana - I don't really need to explain myself
The Clash - hell yeh. punk as it should be
Sex Pistols
Rolling Stones
Beetles
ok not the best band ever, but i do love them, Kasabian

How have you listed so many of my favourite bands and still made me hate you?

I see you have those few recordings made in the late fifties by John, Paul, George, Pete and Stuart?

I guess I'm just talented lol.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Thorondel on 07 Feb 2007, 21:00
In no order

Pink Floyd
Led Zeppelin
Sufjan Stevens
David Bowie
Radiohead
Emery
Iron & Wine
Jamie Cullum
Mew
Fair to Midland
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Caspian on 07 Feb 2007, 21:24
Sigur Ros
Jesu
Metallica
Isis
Jars of Clay
My Bloody Valentine
Meshuggah
Neurosis
Explosions in the Sky
The Angelic Process


If you have not yet listened to Boris' Pink, I think you may find it is the greatest thing you have ever heard, based on your tastes.

And yes, tommy.  Tweez is a bad album.  It grates on my nerves.


I've got about 20 or so Boris albums. My favourite one is probably Flood, or Sun Baked Snow Cave (their collaboration with Merzbow). Pink is good.

Also, I would like to mention how damn awesome the Angelic Process is. If you like, Shoegaze, Noise, Metal, or good music in general, get their album Coma Waering. One of the best albums ever, although no one seems to have heard of it.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: KharBevNor on 07 Feb 2007, 22:02
now all of a sudden he's huge and all the kiddies like him. I'm so fucking confused.

Where are all these kids then? I hardly know anyone who's even heard of Ewigkeit. They have 1,135 unique listeners on last.fm, and, let me tell you, that is not very many at all. Four times as many people listen to Theatres Des Vampires. I've been listening to him for two and a half years now, discovered them completely at random off an Earache sampler CD on an issue of Terrorizer the month before Radio Ixtlan was released. I tend to get very good reactions from people when I play them his stuff, especially off the last two albums. But he's so obscure, especially now he quit Earache, that people rarely seem to bother following it up. It's a shame really. 'Conspiritus' could have been fucking huge if it had been promoted right.

If you've been on it for a while, your last.fm top list tends to come to represent what you've been listening to longest, not what you like most.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: kokeyjoe on 08 Feb 2007, 03:41
I know nothing of the band Ewigkeit, but I'd just like to say it's one of my favorite German words.

I also like ausgezeichnet, because it sounds funny when you say it.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: AlexAttack on 08 Feb 2007, 08:05
Firstly: The Ramones

Now in no particular order:

Screeching Weasel
The Queers
Descendents
Satyricon
Deicide
Mayhem
Darkthrone
Avail
Riverdales
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: tania on 15 Feb 2007, 17:51
broken social scene
talking heads
deerhoof
sonic youth
the blood brothers
fugazi
hot snakes
the flaming lips
modest mouse
sloan

not in any particular order. sonic youth and talking heads are both tied for #1 i guess, whichever's my favourite sort of depends on the mood i'm in that day.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Lines on 15 Feb 2007, 18:06
the beatles
the dandy warhols
queen
the doors
the who
the white stripes
snow patrol
the rolling stones (older stuff, mostly)
muse (i don't care what you say, i like them, dammit)
abba
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: ekmesnz on 15 Feb 2007, 18:11
In no order,

Four Tet
Godspeed You! Black Emperor
Thursday
The Books
Isis
Pelican
Abandoned Pools
Mogwai
Bell Orchestre
Forget Cassettes
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Storm Rider on 15 Feb 2007, 18:17
broken social scene
talking heads
deerhoof
sonic youth
the blood brothers
fugazi
hot snakes
the flaming lips
modest mouse
sloan

not in any particular order. sonic youth and talking heads are both tied for #1 i guess, whichever's my favourite sort of depends on the mood i'm in that day.

You're such a liar, Mrs. Claudio Sanchez.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Mr u Suk on 15 Feb 2007, 18:17
god damn, i can usely make it around the top 5, but then i all falls apart.

#1: Led Zeppelin - undisputed
#2: Robin Trower - best guitarist ever, fuckin' loud live
#3: LadyTron - i am overly obsessed with this band
#4: The Cult - the most under rated band to ever come out of the 80's (Guadicanal Diary could fight for that title to)
#5: Gorillaz - the funky uniqueness draws me in like no other
#6: David Bowie - prolly the most talented vocalist i can think of
#7: R.E.M. - i have no idea why but i love them
#8: Stars - the music is so eloquent that it could bring tears
#9: The Muggs - a Detroit local band, absolutly 100% arena rock (also there is a very amazing backstory to this power trio)
#10: Tragically Hip - just pure rock

Honorable metions:
Pink Floyd
Arcade Fire
Secret Machines
Maximo Park
Ratt
Tesla
Tenacious D
Spoon
Massive Attack
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: timehat on 15 Feb 2007, 21:45
I'll probably want to change this as soon as I post, but I'll give it a shot:

Voivod
Thought Industry
Cynic
Cocteau Twins
Porcupine Tree
Death
Meshuggah
Area (the 70's Italian band, not the more recent U.S. one, although they're cool too)
Genesis
Mew

and to be honest, you could probably switch some of the bands out for these

Antonio Carlos Jobim
Steve Reich
Anekdoten
Landberk
Os Mutantes
Henry Cow
Slowdive

decision making isn't one of my strong points
edit: (5 seconds later) and Magma! I fucking knew that would happen.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Bennett the Sage on 15 Feb 2007, 23:13
Hmmm..I cant put these in order, but I can give an explanation to there awesomeness.

Frank Zappa. Progressive electric rock in the time of disco, british punk and glam metal? Sign me up!
Elvis Costello. I always appreciate an artist that is prolific as he is insightful and brilliant.
Electric Light Orchaestra. Combining catchy rock riffs and orchaestral flair, they have me successfully hooked. Doesnt help that im a sucker for concept albums, i.e Eldorado.
Pink Floyd. How can a self respecting rocker not have these guys on their list of all timers? R.I.P Syd.
Victor Wooten. Ever wondered what flaminco would sound like on an electric bass? Listen to this guy and youll find out.
Tsutchie. I usually dont like hip hop, but the idea of a japanese hip hop artist got me intrigued, and now I cant stop listening.
Men at Work. Once you get past the "Land Down Under" 80's pop sound, youll realize that Colin is an incredible songwriter.
Visual Audio Sensory Theater (I know its VAST, but I love saying all that). Its a guilty pleasure of mine; the concept of emo metal has me giddy.
Peter Gabriel. Its odd that anyone can have a pop sound and following, but still have an odd sense of individuality and uniqueness, but that was the 80's for you.
The Eurythmics. Mostly for Annie Lennox, the only TRUE diva.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: TheoristB on 15 Feb 2007, 23:52
These really aren't in order except for my number one.

Radiohead - This band changed the way I thought about my guitar, keyboards and rock music.

The Beatles - amazing songwriters with super creative arrangements and structures.

The Beach Boys - Best Pop music ever.

Peter Gabriel - pretty much exactly what the above poster said about him, allthough if he hadnt made the album UP he would not be in my list.

Oingo Boingo - How can you not love a dancey new wave band fronted by Danny Elfman.

Pavement - So loose and sloppy but in the best way possible.

Elliot Smith - one of the best songwriters of the 90's

Foo Fighters - the last two albums sucked... but the first two were amazing and the 3rd one was solid.  I saw them do their Acoustic Tour over the summer and have not been that moved by a band in years.  I see and play alot of shows.  No band I have seen with the exception of Radiohead has gotten me that excited about live music again.

Andrew Bird - fantastic songwriter, great voice, and i love his violin playing.

Pulp - just for the album Different Class alone they deserve a place in my Top 10
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: KaosPilot on 18 Feb 2007, 05:23
deftones
the smashing pumpkins
sleater-kinney
65daysofstatic
stapleton
biffy clyro
the new pornographers
mogwai
sufjan stevens

that's all i can think of at the moment. there are an absolute truckload more bands i really like, but these are the ones i will buy new material by regardless of financial situation, travel out of town to see them etc...
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: RivyD on 18 Feb 2007, 09:27
god this is tough. off the top of my head...

modest mouse
built to spill
explosions in the sky
flaming lips
neutral milk hotel
pavement
red stars theory
sparklehorse
my bloody valentine
ugly casanova
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Technetium on 18 Feb 2007, 19:26
Opeth
Tool
Godspeed You! Black Emperor
King Crimson
The Flower Kings
Pain of Salvation
Transatlantic
Agalloch
Pink Floyd
Dream Theater

There are some other musicians and composers (Coltrane, Miles Davis, Al Di Meola, Beethoven) I wanted to put instead of some of those, but they're not "bands".
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: ElleryMSG on 27 Feb 2007, 12:53
Emilie Autumn (excellent voice, violin playing, and body)

Dresden Dolls (Cabaret FTW)

Inkubus Sukkubus (nothing can be said)

Nightwish (what would I be without some kind of metal...)

Miranda Sex Garden (hence the MSG in my name 'nuff said)

Faith and the Muse (another of those just plain excellent bands)

Mediaeval Baebes (Miranda Sex Garden evolved into this 'nuff said)

Blackmore's Night (similar to mediaeval baebes but with more instruments and less voices)

Cruxshadows (awesome band, but I can't really describe it)

Die Form (too good for a description)
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Liz on 27 Feb 2007, 13:31
In no particular order...

Explosions in the Sky
The Spill Canvas
Streetlight Manifesto
Jonny Lang
Shearwater
Damien Rice
Jack's Mannequin
Blu Sanders
Amsterband
Minus the Bear

Say what you wish. I like them all.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Lukeypoo on 27 Feb 2007, 14:54
In no particular order and subject to change within the next week.

Ratatat
Daft Punk
Menomena
Mogwai
The Decemberists
Final Fantasy
Queen
Polysics
Violent Femmes
Air

I don't think I really need explain each one. I just really love their music.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Arsis on 27 Feb 2007, 17:46
My top ten bands right this moment.
1. Obscenity(obscenity.de)
2. Mors Principium Est
3. Arsis
4. Beheaded
5. Human Mincer
6. October Tide
7. Prophecy
8. Bloodgasm
9. Kalmah
10. Blind Guardian

a bunch of weird underground metal stuff.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: schimmy on 28 Feb 2007, 09:43
Skyclad
Belle and Sebastian
The Decemberists
Sonic Youth

pre-Marr Modest Mouse
Fugazi
Iron and Wine
Of Montreal


I know that's only 8, but, looking through my music library, there are genuinly not that many bands that I absoloubtly have to listen to every once in a while. There's a whole lot of stuff that is definitley very good, just not top-ten material
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: dancarter on 28 Feb 2007, 12:06
Okay, taking a stab and it will be hard:

1. Skinny Puppy(and all related projects).  Every post I make in this music section seems to have something to do with them.  I love 'em.  I drive my friends crazy with them.
2. Godhead.  Amazing.  Noise.  Period.
3. Killing Joke. Still making great music!
4. Placebo.  My guilty pop pleasure.  Great songs.
5. Antigen Shift.  The Way of the North is probably the best album of the past few years that no one has heard.
6. Tom Waits.  No reason need be made.
7. Android Lust.  Four really consistently great and evolving albums.  Bjork meets glitch and industrial.
8. The Smiths.  They're just cheeky and total posturing, but that's the fun.
9. Haujobb.  Essential electronica.  ninetynine still gives me chills.
10. Pop Will Eat Itself.  Another guilty pleasure maybe, but they are so good.  No disputes.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Shortoier134 on 02 Mar 2007, 11:37
I don't like 10 bands in total but i'll give you my favorites.
1) Avenged Sevenfold
2) Billy Talent
3) Thrice
4) The killers


(Judge me) I'm curious to see what you think of my music interests.
kay i'm editing this i cannot believe i forgoot to put
5) Greenday
on here!
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: thebignothing on 02 Mar 2007, 13:43
Oh fun. I think I shall put recommended songs next to the names, just in case you are curious.

one- Elliott Smith (Pitseleh)
two- Minus the Bear (This Ain't a Surfin Movie)
three- Jimmy Eat World (For Me This Is Heaven)
four- Bruce Springsteen (Thunder Road)
five- Simon and Garfunkel (America)
six- Cursive (Sink to the Beat)
seven- Death Cab for Cutie (Styrofoam Plates)
eight- the Streets (Sharp Darts)
nine- Regina Spektor (Apres Moi)
ten- Margot and the Nuclear So and So's (Skeleton Key)

These are definitely my top ten as of right now. Of all time? I have no idea.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Liz on 02 Mar 2007, 14:58
two- Minus the Bear (This Ain't a Surfin Movie)
Oh, Minus the Bear, how I love thee. My favorites are The Fix and Hooray.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: thebignothing on 02 Mar 2007, 19:50
Oh, Minus the Bear, how I love thee. My favorites are The Fix and Hooray.

Yes! Have you seen them in concert? Amazing, is all I have to say.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Liz on 02 Mar 2007, 22:35
No, but a friend of mine has. I am jealous. Very much so.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Caspian on 03 Mar 2007, 00:01
I don't like 10 bands in total but i'll give you my favorites.
1) Avenged Sevenfold
2) Billy Talent
3) Thrice
4) The killers


(Judge me) I'm curious to see what you think of my music interests.

Pretty crap. It wouldn't be as terrible if A7X were on there though.
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: ImRonBurgundy? on 03 Mar 2007, 06:29
At least A7X writes the occasional nifty guitar wank.  The same cannot be said for, say, The Killers.

I'm kind of reluctant to try to put together my top ten favorite artists ever.  I'd have to think about it for a while.  I know that Jawbreaker and Hot Water Music would be on it, and probably The Replacements, but other than that...
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Skibas_clavicle on 03 Mar 2007, 10:19
I don't like 10 bands in total but i'll give you my favorites.
1) Avenged Sevenfold
2) Billy Talent
3) Thrice
4) The killers
Too easy. It's like making fun of the mentally challenged kid in your 7th grade class.

Current List:
Wilco
The Lawrence Arms
Mogwai
Built to Spill
Alkaline Trio
Ryan Adams
Jawbreaker
Fischerspooner
Elliott Smith
Modest Mouse (my latest addition)

Have been/very close to being on the list:
Sufjan Stevens
Broken Social Scene
Mos Def
Misfits
Iggy & The Stooges
Sleater-Kinney
Pixies
Of Montreal
Jawbox
Turbonegro
The Album Leaf
Death Cab For Cutie
Hot Water Music
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Yorkekida on 04 Mar 2007, 08:02
Ok..Don't be a hipster snob...That's kinda funny...Anyway heres my list..

1)Radiohead
2)Sigur Ros
3)Arcade Fire
4)The Smashing Pumpkins
5)Massive Attack
6)Tool
7)The Stone Roses
8)Pixies
9)Belle and Sebastian/Blur
10)Godspeed You!Black Emperor
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: izekiel on 06 Mar 2007, 16:27
In no particular order...(and probably not really my true top 10 but it's what i've been listening to lately...)

Breaking Benjamin
Modest Mouse
Sufjan Stevens
Papa Roach
Lamb of God
Eve 6
State Radio
Guns and Roses
The Offspring
The Decemberists
Jonathon Edwards

oh my...11...
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: Coming Home on 07 Mar 2007, 10:04
Helken (local band)
In Flames
Lamb of God
Killswitch Engage
The Autumn Offering
Disturbed
Avenged Sevenfold (Yes, I know they're Pop-Metal. Shush. Their songs are fun to play)
Slayer
Iced Earth
Audioslave
Title: Re: top 10 bands
Post by: JediBendu on 07 Mar 2007, 14:01
The Band (Because... well... just because they're the shit.)
The Rolling Stones (Because Exile and Let It Bleed own so much ass.)
Deerhoof (Because they does makes me happy.)
Jedi Mind Tricks (Just cause they've got like the fucking best hip hop producer around. Vinnie's pretty hardcore too.)
Eels (Basically it's all I listened to for a long time a while back.)
The Roots (Two words... Game Theory)
Edan (Psychadelic rap by Jews is cool?)
Motorhead (Roar^2)
Belle & Sebastian (After Motorhead roars at me they make me feel better.)
Queens of the Stone Age (Because I love Rated R and Songs For The Deaf)