THESE FORUMS NOW CLOSED (read only)
Fun Stuff => ENJOY => Topic started by: Johnny C on 18 Sep 2007, 23:26
-
Do yourselves a favour and watch this Western. It's absolutely masterful.
For those of you who haven't heard of it, it's based on an Elmore Leonard story and is in theatres right now. If I somehow have to convince you beyond that sentence, I suppose I can summarise the premise. Dan Evans (Christian Bale) is an Arizona rancher, down on his luck due to a drought and in debt to the railroad company who are going to kick him off of his land within the week. By a sequence of events best attributed to poor luck, he finds himself helping capture and then helping deliver to Contention, AZ, the outlaw Ben Wade (Russell Crowe). Unfortunately, Wade's gang has other ideas.
The filmmakers clearly took into account everything produced by pillars of the genre like Ford, Peckinpah, Leone and Eastwood; however, where lesser folk would merely turn the film into a simulacrum of those other pictures, stealing setpieces and nicking dialogue, Mangold has taken what he's learned and applied it to create a stunning and memorable piece of cinema. There was literally not a single moment where my eyes left the screen save for one brief second where I turned to one of my companions for the evening to see if he shared in my excitement for the scene which was about to come. (And even that scene defied my expectations, seeing where they were set and demanding that I raise them immediately or face the consequences.)
Each member of the cast pulls out an extraordinary performance for what could have easily become, in the hands of less capable actors, rote performances. Bale and Crowe carve out truly great characters, but the supporting cast does an outstanding job as well. Of special note are the performances of Logan Lerman as Dan's son, William, Ben Foster as the creepy, ruthless right-hand man of Wade and Alan Tudyk in a surprisingly endearing role as a small-town doctor who becomes a member of the posse escorting Wade to his destination.
I cannot stress enough how excellent this film is. A dusty wind blows passionate, exciting, clever and just damn expert filmmaking out of every frame. It's a film which meets its audience's expectations and then exceeds them by leaps and bounds. It deserves your money.
-
I've never had a tremendous liking for Westerns, and honestly I have to say I wasn't exactly riveted by this one either. The actors were certainly capable, but I just didn't really like the story or the ending. I did like Wade's sidekick.
-
I love westerns. i haven't seen this yet but am going to very soon since i got paid today. i'm pretty excited.
-
I've heard good things about this film (it hasn't opened here yet). However, as far as new westerns goes, I'm looking forward to this (http://jessejamesmovie.warnerbros.com/) one much more.
-
See, I'm looking forward to that one too, but for different reasons. It looks to be a really compelling drama disguised as a Western. 3:10 To Yuma, on the other hand, is a really great Western with compelling drama woven throughout. Plus, the latter film has seriously awesome action scenes.
-
I love westerns, so I need to get out and see this.
I'd suggest to other folks who like Westerns to check out The Proposition from 2005.
-
I was trying to remember the name of that movie. I know it's supposed to be really good. Black as pitch but really good.
-
It's excellent, but not for people who are in the least bit unsettled by realistic and disturbing violence. It's not wanton violence though, as the film is considered extremely realistic in it's portrayal of life, particularly of indigenous culture, in Australia's outback during the 1880s.
-
I saw The Proposition when it first came out and it was pretty amazing. Even if you don't like westerns that much (and I don't really) it is just an absolutely beautiful film.
-
Well, it's more a period piece than just a western, it doesn't follow the formuliac guides that would make it a true western. I also love how it's just long periods of quiet, but compelling storytelling punctuated by "holy shit that guy's head just blew up."
-
JohnnyC, you couldn't have written down my sentiments about this movie any better.
After seeing it I was so excited that I got together a group of friends to go out and see it again.
Amazing.
Also, Dead Man anyone?
-
The Proposition is the western with David Bowie in it, right?
Have any of you guys or ladies seen the orginal 3:10 to Yuma? I want to know how it compares, because the old one is pure awesome.
-
Nah, The Proposition was written by Nick Cave, and stars (among others) Danny Huston, Ray Winstone, Guy Pearce, and Emily Watson
-
JOHN HURT, MOTHERBITCHES.
Does anyone know when 3:10 to Yuma comes out in Australia? I am really looking forward to it. So are my housemates, although I think they're less a fan of westerns and more a fan of Christian Bale being a cowboy and looking scruffily attractive.
-
That is definately not a crime. Christian Bale... mmm...