THESE FORUMS NOW CLOSED (read only)

Comic Discussion => QUESTIONABLE CONTENT => Topic started by: Gyrre on 02 Jan 2021, 09:14

Title: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Gyrre on 02 Jan 2021, 09:14
So I completely spaced out when typing in this week's thread dates, so I went back to the forum page and saw that we actually don't have a consistent dating format between WCDTs amongst us. Hell, I don't even do consistently from thread to thread unless I copy-paste an older thread's title to just change the numbers. And just out of curiosity, I dug way back to the first two dozen pages to to see what the WCDT format was when they were first started.

Anyways, thank God* 2020 is finely over. Here's to hoping 2021 is at the very least not any worse.

*or whatever deity/ancestor(s)/higher consciousness/being suits your beliefs
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Wingy on 02 Jan 2021, 15:00
I much prefer YYMMDD, so I would nominate WCDT #### - #### (yymmdd - yymmdd).
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Dandi Andi on 02 Jan 2021, 15:22
Ah, an ISO 6801 fan I see.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Gyrre on 02 Jan 2021, 17:47
I'm kind of torn, myself. As an American, I'm used to putting the month first. But some of them just look better visually.

Any graphic designers amongst us who want to weigh-in on this from that angle?
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: hedgie on 02 Jan 2021, 18:59
I have a preference for D/M/Y, but Y/M/D works as well.  It just doesn’t seem as useful as a human reading it, since the year and month change less often than the days, and a rollover in days is a quick visual shorthand that it’s a new month.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Gyrre on 02 Jan 2021, 21:54
If memory serves, the USA didn't actually standardize the M/DD/YY format until the 1960s or 1970s.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: sitnspin on 02 Jan 2021, 22:22
Honestly, YYYY/MM/DD is, for me, the most logical, aesthetically pleasing, and easily organised format. I wish that was the universal standard.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: anahata on 03 Jan 2021, 01:06
It is the universal standard, more or less, hence the mention of ISO 6801. If only everyone would use it...
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Wingy on 03 Jan 2021, 07:46
Ah, an ISO 6801 fan I see.
Not so much.  I just have a habit of using it since I've been in the position of creating files (meeting minutes, etc.) that are best organized by date.  Now that the year is out of the teens for good, YYMMDD is far less likely to be misconstrued than DDMMYY.  As an old programmer, it's also easier to keep files with names beginning YYMMDD blah blah blah since it's not always straightforward to sort files by date in some OSs, especially if in the process of reviewing the file you change it somehow.  So I've landed on YYMMDD as a preference, not as a standard.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Gyrre on 03 Jan 2021, 08:03
Honestly, YYYY/MM/DD is, for me, the most logical, aesthetically pleasing, and easily organised format. I wish that was the universal standard.

Because it functions similar to integers with the last digits being the first to increase, then the slowly increasing with the month serving as a hundreds place, then the year as a thousands place?
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: sitnspin on 03 Jan 2021, 09:48
Because, when listed in numerical order, they are also in chronological order.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: oddtail on 03 Jan 2021, 10:03
I picked "other", but basically I like the first option best, just without the comma.

In the end, anything BUT month-first is fine with me. That's just super weird and unwieldy for me.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Case on 03 Jan 2021, 10:20
I picked "other", but basically I like the first option best, just without the comma.

In the end, anything BUT month-first is fine with me. That's just super weird and unwieldy for me.

Seconded on the month-first. Just can't get used to it.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Pilchard123 on 03 Jan 2021, 10:54
Because, when listed in numerical order, they are also in chronological order.

And when sorted lexicographically too.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Is it cold in here? on 03 Jan 2021, 13:29
Honestly, YYYY/MM/DD is, for me, the most logical, aesthetically pleasing, and easily organised format. I wish that was the universal standard.

Because it functions similar to integers with the last digits being the first to increase, then the slowly increasing with the month serving as a hundreds place, then the year as a thousands place?

One little two little three little-endian
Three big, two big, one big-endian
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Gyrre on 03 Jan 2021, 14:39
I could swear I had formatted at least one of those poll options with having an 'of' before the year at the end.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Gyrre on 03 Jan 2021, 14:55
Honestly, YYYY/MM/DD is, for me, the most logical, aesthetically pleasing, and easily organised format. I wish that was the universal standard.

Because it functions similar to integers with the last digits being the first to increase, then the slowly increasing with the month serving as a hundreds place, then the year as a thousands place?

One little two little three little-endian
Three big, two big, one big-endian

thousands/hundreds/tens
         year/month/day
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Dandi Andi on 03 Jan 2021, 15:41
ISO 6801 gives the date as YYYYMMDD but also allows the inclusion of dashes for visual clarity such as YYYY-MM-DD. This format is also (as IICIH illustrated with his little song) called "Big-endian". I like this one because, as Sitnspin pointed out, if it's in numerical order, it's in chronological order as well, so it is very useful for indexing. It's written left to right with the most significant digits on the left just like any other numbers we write. It is, its way, elegant.

Little-endian, DD-MM-YYYY, is more intuitive for conversational use. It truncates very well in casual conversation. If I ask my librarian for a copy of the newspaper from the 23rd, they'll very likely assume I mean the 23rd of December. If I say that I need the paper from the 23rd of November, they'll very reasonably assume (as you did in the last sentence I am sure) that I mean November 2020. So it makes sense to use little-endian order since the most relevant information is closest to the front (in most casual applications).

Middle-endian, MM-DD-YYYY, is only used in the US, as far as I know. And not without good reason. It isn't simple or elegant. It makes no sense. Why do we do this? Why are we so stubbornly foolish? It is the same reason we do anything. Someone did it that way once and it stuck and we're too embarrassed to admit that we've been wrong this whole time.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Farideh on 03 Jan 2021, 18:51
I agree with the YYYY-MM-DD format.

Also: comic's up. May is doing quite well 🙂
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Gyrre on 03 Jan 2021, 18:53
Your explanation for Big-endian is basically what I was trying to get at.

Let's just be glad that going by the julian date basically only happens in factories. The last two digits of the year followed by the day number of that year. For examples; today (Sunday, the 3rd of January, 2021) would be 21003, and the 31st of this December will be 21365.

EDIT: typo fix
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: shanejayell on 03 Jan 2021, 20:31
That was cute. Faye is jealous of no longer being the 'cool big sis'. Ha.
Title: Re: WCDT 2021w01 (4431--4435)---short enough to epithet.
Post by: N.N. Marf on 03 Jan 2021, 21:32
Given that it's weekly comic discussion.. thread titles would be neater if we used the week number, rather than month/day ranges, which are irregular on mid-week month or year changes, unless we write out the whole year and month twice. There's an international standard (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ISO_week_date#First_week) having the 1st week with more than half it's days in the new year as week 1.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: BenRG on 03 Jan 2021, 23:14
Ever since May got her new body, I've noticed that she's cooled down a lot. He's less abrasive and more willing to reach out and be friendly with people. This fits in with my feeling that a lot of her behaviour was due to her environment - a broken body that was causing her only pain and stress.

Meanwhile, I find myself wondering just how deep Faye's jealousy about her 'baby sister' making a new friend might run!

Regarding the poll question, I prefer to do dates in what, to me, is their intuitive correct format. Today is the 4th day of January 2021, so the date would be written as '4th January 2021'. To me, other formats are back-to-front. Seriously, though, it's also not a big thing and certainly not something that needs to be changed. So long as everyone can get the necessary data, there is no need to have fixed thread title formats.
Title: Re: WCDT 2021w01 (4431--4435)---short enough to epithet.
Post by: Gyrre on 04 Jan 2021, 01:22
Given that it's weekly comic discussion.. thread titles would be neater if we used the week number, rather than month/day ranges, which are irregular on mid-week month or year changes, unless we write out the whole year and month twice. There's an international standard (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ISO_week_date#First_week) having the 1st week with more than half it's days in the new year as week 1.

It beats using the julian, but I think we'd still need to include the date range in some fashion. Perhaps week X, [thread poster's preferred date format]?

[snip]

Regarding the poll question, I prefer to do dates in what, to me, is their intuitive correct format. Today is the 4th day of January 2021, so the date would be written as '4th January 2021'. To me, other formats are back-to-front. Seriously, though, it's also not a big thing and certainly not something that needs to be changed. So long as everyone can get the necessary data, there is no need to have fixed thread title formats.

I was mostly just curious as to everyone's preferred date format. Personally, the most 'sensible' date format depends on what's being dated. As previously mentioned, ISO works really we for archiving. But, 'big-endian' doesn't really feel natural in terms of speech or dialogue, so one of the others might do better. Hell, format preference could be used to convey information about a character's personality. Granted, author bias can come into play pretty easily.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: snubnose on 04 Jan 2021, 02:55
Ah yes.

US americans and dates.

I've literally seen places in which people used both M/D/Y and D/M/Y. Good luck finding out what date was actually meant if D <= 12.

I dont understand it. Its so easy. Just use YYYY-MM-DD (the international format) and you'll be all set. I use that all the time.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Meander on 04 Jan 2021, 05:23
I personally use YYYY_MMDD, but I think that YYYY-MM-DD is that best.

Look at May being all charming and supportive!
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Perfectly Reasonable on 04 Jan 2021, 05:40
The snake needs to be puking knives.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: cesium133 on 04 Jan 2021, 06:21
Ah yes.

US americans and dates.

I've literally seen places in which people used both M/D/Y and D/M/Y. Good luck finding out what date was actually meant if D <= 12.

I dont understand it. Its so easy. Just use YYYY-MM-DD (the international format) and you'll be all set. I use that all the time.
Canada seems to have the worst of both worlds, where they use both MM/DD/YYYY and DD/MM/YYYY at the same time.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Gnabberwocky on 04 Jan 2021, 09:09
That's a great quote from Faye in panel 3. I may use that.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: DaiJB on 04 Jan 2021, 09:22
The snake needs to be puking knives.

And be on fire.


Favourite date format? - maybe Long Count Date 13.0.8.2.16 to 13.0.8.3.0 ? 
Or Month 11, 21 - 25, 4718? 

(I know, I know, I'm being a pain in the behind...)  :-D
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Oenone on 04 Jan 2021, 10:08
My human-ing is failing me -- is Faye jealous of the kiddo getting complimented or jealous of May being so comfortable with the kiddo? Or of how her art isn't appreciated by their clients in the same way?

ETA: Is Faye's art something she still works at? Or is she just satisfied with being naturally talented? Like, Renee seems pretty disciplined in her pursuit of "the best of its type" baking, and just the fact that that she's allowed in the same kitchen with Elliot and tries to share what she's good at with her friends speaks to how important it is to her. Is Faye jealous because the art she doesn't spend time on or share with others is less appreciated?
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: notStanley on 04 Jan 2021, 10:29
CCYYMMDD is the only way to go!  It sorts properly.  Been using that since 1978, first job was a home loan company, and calculating 30 year mortgages had to worry about that CC rollover.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: BenRG on 04 Jan 2021, 10:36
My human-ing is failing me -- is Faye jealous of the kiddo getting complimented or jealous of May being so comfortable with the kiddo? Or of how her art isn't appreciated by their clients in the same way?

I think it is mostly jealousy that May is threatening to become a closer adult-ish friend to Sam than she is.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Dock Braun on 04 Jan 2021, 13:14
CCYYMMDD is the only way to go!  It sorts properly.  Been using that since 1978, first job was a home loan company, and calculating 30 year mortgages had to worry about that CC rollover.
Imagine if they'd decided to use only 1 (one) digit for the century.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Mr_Rose on 04 Jan 2021, 13:47
My human-ing is failing me -- is Faye jealous of the kiddo getting complimented or jealous of May being so comfortable with the kiddo? Or of how her art isn't appreciated by their clients in the same way?
I think it is mostly jealousy that May is threatening to become a closer adult-ish friend to Sam than she is.
But then, Sam could just put her foot in her mouth using the dexterity only teenagers seem to have…
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Gnabberwocky on 04 Jan 2021, 13:50
But then, Sam could just put her foot in her mouth using the dexterity only teenagers seem to have…

Yeah, we're quite flexible like that.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Oenone on 04 Jan 2021, 14:28
My human-ing is failing me -- is Faye jealous of the kiddo getting complimented or jealous of May being so comfortable with the kiddo? Or of how her art isn't appreciated by their clients in the same way?

I think it is mostly jealousy that May is threatening to become a closer adult-ish friend to Sam than she is.

Has Faye's jealousy been an issue before? I know she's been territorial over Marten.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Mr_Rose on 04 Jan 2021, 14:41
My human-ing is failing me -- is Faye jealous of the kiddo getting complimented or jealous of May being so comfortable with the kiddo? Or of how her art isn't appreciated by their clients in the same way?

I think it is mostly jealousy that May is threatening to become a closer adult-ish friend to Sam than she is.

Has Faye's jealousy been an issue before? I know she's been territorial over Marten.
She gets territorial over absolutely everything in her life but I think it’s more related to an abject terror of change, at least change she doesn’t initiate. She should settle down once she’s had a good sleep on it, especially with Bubbles’s patience and sweet lovin’.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Gnabberwocky on 04 Jan 2021, 18:24
Comic's up.

I guess I was hoping that Sam would be able to get May to open up a little WRT Robot Jail. Doesn't look like that'll be happening anytime soon.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Mordhaus on 04 Jan 2021, 18:39
Robot Dementors are the guards.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: shanejayell on 04 Jan 2021, 19:40
I've always kinda assumed Robot Jail might not be conceivable in human terms.

"Imagine a infinite space, but you can't move, along with a immense perception of time passing."

"....."

"That is not at all what Robot Jail was like, but it's a start."
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Gnabberwocky on 04 Jan 2021, 19:49
I've always kinda assumed Robot Jail might not be conceivable in human terms.

"Imagine a infinite space, but you can't move, along with a immense perception of time passing."

"....."

"That is not at all what Robot Jail was like, but it's a start."

I mean, I'd honestly take that. It's May's choice for if/when she wants to talk about it, but I really do want to know what it's like, even if it's "an abstract concept that is incomprehensible to the human mind."
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: TheEvilDog on 04 Jan 2021, 20:34
I'm guessing that the tone of May's reaction is less "can't explain it in relatable terms to a human experience" and more "Kid, you literally have no idea what I have gone through, both in prison and out of it and its mildly insulting that you think you know what it was like".

The only parallel I can imagine for May's time in Robot Jail would be something like Locked In Syndrome, and even then you can't exactly relate the experience and expect someone to understand what its really like. Its one of those experiences that someone would have to go through to really understand, otherwise there's just a lot of smoke getting blown out of people's asses.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Gyrre on 04 Jan 2021, 20:44
I'm guessing that the tone of May's reaction is less "can't explain it in relatable terms to a human experience" and more "Kid, you literally have no idea what I have gone through, both in prison and out of it and its mildly insulting that you think you know what it was like".

The only parallel I can imagine for May's time in Robot Jail would be something like Locked In Syndrome, and even then you can't exactly relate the experience and expect someone to understand what its really like. Its one of those experiences that someone would have to go through to really understand, otherwise there's just a lot of smoke getting blown out of people's asses.

I've been assuming it's something akin to solitary confinement without the ability to really move around. It may or may not come with some sort of behavioral adjustment regimen (like being subjected to nonstop Barney reruns or something overly saccharine and moralistic).
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: TheEvilDog on 04 Jan 2021, 20:49
It may or may not come with some sort of behavioral adjustment regimen (like being subjected to nonstop Barney reruns...<sic>).

I think that qualifies as cruel and unusual punishment.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: awkwardness on 04 Jan 2021, 22:12
It was bound to happen, but Sam's sincerity and empathy is actually something that I don't think anyone else has shown her before. Sam is trying, which is better than ignoring the past and not addressing it because you don't want to hurt May's feelings or you're apathetic to it.

Kids with no filters sometimes are the best and cheapest therapy.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: awkwardness on 04 Jan 2021, 22:14
I'm guessing that the tone of May's reaction is less "can't explain it in relatable terms to a human experience" and more "Kid, you literally have no idea what I have gone through, both in prison and out of it and its mildly insulting that you think you know what it was like".

The only parallel I can imagine for May's time in Robot Jail would be something like Locked In Syndrome, and even then you can't exactly relate the experience and expect someone to understand what its really like. Its one of those experiences that someone would have to go through to really understand, otherwise there's just a lot of smoke getting blown out of people's asses.

I've been assuming it's something akin to solitary confinement without the ability to really move around. It may or may not come with some sort of behavioral adjustment regimen (like being subjected to nonstop Barney reruns or something overly saccharine and moralistic).

If it's not Barney Rubble, Barney Fife, or Barney Miller then it's cruel and unusual punishment.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Gyrre on 04 Jan 2021, 23:22
I've always kinda assumed Robot Jail might not be conceivable in human terms.

"Imagine a infinite space, but you can't move, along with a immense perception of time passing."

"....."

"That is not at all what Robot Jail was like, but it's a start."

Something akin to the white room in THX 1138?

Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: BenRG on 04 Jan 2021, 23:28
In Sam's defence, a 14- or 15-year-old, especially one raised in as near-boundary-free a way as she has probably has no framework from which to imagine what incarceration of any kind is. However, given how much she loves being out and enjoying adventures, being grounded probably was close in terms of its frustration and boredom.

FWIW, I've always thought that Robot Jail is a virtual realm where your ability to move and interact with others and your environment is enormously restricted and your perception of time is distorted. Oh, and there probably a nicely Orwellian rehabilitation 'educational' system' which is your only option other than staring at blank walls 23/7 (you get an hour's interaction with a randomly-selected other prisoner for one hour per day unless you're really disruptive).
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: snubnose on 05 Jan 2021, 00:37
Actually, after COVID-19, many people probably have trouble to adjust to life on the outside again. :-D

Personally, I never was "grounded", so I dont know how that is.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: DaiJB on 05 Jan 2021, 06:35
Hello Apricot!  :-)

It must be kind of hard to avoid eavesdropping* on this conversation going on behind her head...
Now, will Apricot be somewhat Momo-like, and be squirming a little in embarrassment over what she's forced to overhear?
Or more Melon-like, and therefore a total ditz...  :-D 
In which case, be prepared for some totally random comment next.

*(I wonder if AI's in this universe can "shut off" or otherwise avoid hearing private conversations? )
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Gyrre on 05 Jan 2021, 08:12
IDK. I might be misreading her expression in the lower left corner, but I think she might have some mild discomfort but is trying to keep her smile? IDK.


Also, fruit sister confirmed?
[I really hope I didn't screw up any plans regarding Melon's relatives with those fanarts.]
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: BenRG on 05 Jan 2021, 08:18
*(I wonder if AI's in this universe can "shut off" or otherwise avoid hearing private conversations? )

Technically, humans have discriminatory hearing at that level; we just need an alternate audio stream onto which to focus our minds. Apricot just needs to connect to iTunes or something and stream an album.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Mordhaus on 05 Jan 2021, 14:22
Jokes aside, if I was to imagine Robot Jail, I would suspect that they have a way to nullify an AI's personality and emotions. Basically turning them into a 'machine' that they then have perform similar calculations to those that supercomputers do. Maybe they would leave just enough 'intelligent' thought for the AI to feel that they are missing 99% of what made them, well, THEM.

The end result being that the AI understands that if they repeat the offense, the prison has no problem turning them back into a simple computer, while their 'consciousness, rails against an invisible wall as time passes.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Case on 05 Jan 2021, 16:24
Kids with no filters sometimes are the best and cheapest therapy.

For "adults" without filters? You might be onto smth here ...  :-D

I'm guessing that the tone of May's reaction is less "can't explain it in relatable terms to a human experience" and more "Kid, you literally have no idea what I have gone through, both in prison and out of it and its mildly insulting that you think you know what it was like".

It was bound to happen, but Sam's sincerity and empathy is actually something that I don't think anyone else has shown her before. Sam is trying, which is better than ignoring the past and not addressing it because you don't want to hurt May's feelings or you're apathetic to it.

I agree with both of you. Sam is a kid, and she's sincere in her wish to form an empathetic connection by trying to understand someone else's experience via extrapolation from her own. She hasn't yet learned that this can be ... anything from helpful to anoying or hurtful, and she'll hopefully never get to the point where she can truly understand May's experience. An adult - even a 'nominal' one - should take that into account when reacting to something so simultaneously touching and woefully inadaequate. But May also has a right to express her feelings when forced into a conversation she did not want - and whether by design or dumb luck, she expresses them in a way that the sting in her words goes right over Sam's head.

Bit like watching two shitfaced porcupines crossing a river on a kid's dinghie and actually making it to the other side.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: shanejayell on 05 Jan 2021, 18:31
New strip up.

Of COURSE Robot Jail was built by Robots to appease humans...
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: brasca on 05 Jan 2021, 19:04
New strip up.

Of COURSE Robot Jail was built by Robots to appease humans...

Were they wrong?  Considering the advantages AIs possess as well as a rich fictional history of AIs turning against humans it’s a reasonable concern.  In this webcomic there are a few instances of AIs joking about stealing nuclear launch codes.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: TheEvilDog on 05 Jan 2021, 19:11
Of COURSE Robot Jail was built by Robots to appease humans...

To be fair, in May's case she did embezzle funds in an attempt to buy a military aircraft. Even though her intention was to just be in in a body that was able to fly, from a human perspective, that's a nightmare. You have an AI that has enough understanding to engage in a criminal activity (subtle skimming of funds from millions of customers), who then went through presumably black market channels in an attempt to buy the plane. As humans have this habit of thought exercises and how a chain of events might play out, no one is going to say "Nah, she just wants to fly in the clouds". Its going to be "Oh shit, there's a rogue AI in the body of a plane. What if she held an airliner hostage? What if she wanted to kill someone?" Because they don't know why May wants the plane, just that she wants it is enough to be afraid.

And make no mistake, considering how long AI have been a part of the QCverse, those elder AI were probably well aware what could happen if one of their kind was seen as rogue, because they are still so new to the world, that every single one of those AI is shaping how Humanity views its creation. They're as afraid of rogue AI as humans would be. Robot Jail is a clear statement to Humanity - "We will deal with our problems and deal with them severely".
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Gus_Smedstad on 05 Jan 2021, 20:35
"Imagine a infinite space, but you can't move, along with a immense perception of time passing."

Quote from: Strong Bad
Email is a like a prison. A prison with no walls. And no toilet.

I'm actually a bit surprised by this backstory. I always assumed robots had a special jail because robots can be disembodied, and thus can be efficiently and cheaply incarcerated, and you don't really want to try and imprison some robot bodies, like Punchbot. You know, practical reasons, not the invention of a cabal of elder AI's.

May's glossing over one thing, which is that she stole money, and tried to obtain a combat chassis illegally, both of which are things society can't tolerate. Stealing also hurts other people.

That sort of thing has to be discouraged somehow. May doesn't seem to get that she did anything wrong, so just explaining things to her wasn't going to work. Punishment's the only thing that seems like it would deter her from trying to do it again. I think punishment sucks as a learning mechanism, but I'm not really sure what else you can do with sentients like May.

Once you're settled on punishment as your deterrent, then you can get into the details of what's acceptable and proportionate, and what's not.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Gus_Smedstad on 05 Jan 2021, 20:37
Were they wrong?  Considering the advantages AIs possess as well as a rich fictional history of AIs turning against humans it’s a reasonable concern.

I think humans should be worried about about Spookybot / Yay Newfriend.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: hedgie on 05 Jan 2021, 21:02
I’ve already seen some great hypotheses as to how prison works for AIs, and I do have one of my own, which could, of course include aspects of others.  Given how recent in-universe, true AIs running around is, May couldn’t have been locked up for a long time chronologically, and it’s highly likely that the prosecutors/judge would have nailed her to the wall.  So I’m thinking, it’s like that DS9 episode “Hard Time”, where O’Brian ends up serving 20 years in a matter of hours, and that perceived time is far longer than has actually occured.

Apologies if someone else pointed this out first, I probably missed it.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Gyrre on 05 Jan 2021, 21:17
New strip up.

Of COURSE Robot Jail was built by Robots to appease humans...

Were they wrong?  Considering the advantages AIs possess as well as a rich fictional history of AIs turning against humans it’s a reasonable concern.  In this webcomic there are a few instances of AIs joking about stealing nuclear launch codes.

[Insert one of a myriad of quotes about the horrible things frightened humans are capable of doing]
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Gnabberwocky on 05 Jan 2021, 21:29
To further answer the question of "what should we do with criminal AIs," I feel like we need to know more about Robot Jail and what's so terrible about it. That would allow us to devise more humane solutions. It's clear that whatever RJ is, it's overly harsh and has effects long past a prisoner's release. But in fairness, May did steal a considerable amount of money to purchase a weaponized strike zone, and the prosecutors didn't know her motivation. It makes sense that she'd receive some punishment. Does she deserve incomprehensible torture for a near-infinite amount of time? Of course not. Should she have gotten some community service hours in the form of unpaid processor rent-out? Sounds a lot more fair, considering she never actually hurt anyone (money was most likely returned to wherever she stole it from).
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: awkwardness on 05 Jan 2021, 21:32
Those who whine about jails and "cruel and unusual punishment" I have found 95% of the time have A. been arrested for a crime that they were actually guilty of B. were upset because they got caught and C. did it willingly and knowingly with the penalties known ahead of time.

Save your breath about "cruel and unusual punishment", if you break the law you better expect punishment because why the hell should we, those who try to live our lives peacefully, have to endure people robbing us for drugs, beating the crap out of us because they can, and drive anywhere and anywhere while high as a kite, drunk as a skunk, and all over the road.

OK I'm out. I'll return when things calm down after the inevitable flame war against me for going against the grain.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Case on 05 Jan 2021, 22:14
Of COURSE Robot Jail was built by Robots to appease humans...

Not an unreasonable assumption, but I'd like to hear Momo's version before I consider it canon.

Bcs of ... reasons.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Gus_Smedstad on 05 Jan 2021, 22:29
Those who whine about jails and "cruel and unusual punishment" I have found 95% of the time have A. been arrested for a crime that they were actually guilty of B. were upset because they got caught and C. did it willingly and knowingly with the penalties known ahead of time.

I'm OK with the general concept of jails. While I don't reflexively think in terms on punishment being required, I do think there are a lot of behaviors that need to be deterred somehow, and jail as a broad concept's a lot more humane than some approaches.

What I'm not OK with is the specific implementation of jails in the US. Because of what inmates are allowed to do to each other, it has the opposite of the intended effect. You get this effect where first-time offenders who might easily be turned around get turned into hardened criminals by the brutal realities of jail. And yes, I do think that getting raped regularly is definitely "cruel and unusual punishment."

There are other countries that have prisons but don't have the US's problem with prison violence. Finland comes to mind.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Gus_Smedstad on 05 Jan 2021, 22:32
Not an unreasonable assumption, but I'd like to hear Momo's version before I consider it canon.

That May would be an unreliable narrator seems pretty likely to me.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Gnabberwocky on 05 Jan 2021, 22:41
Awkwardness:

I'm certainly not the best one here to speak on this subject, but I would like to try. I'd like to do this in as non-flame-war a way as possible, so here goes. I do actually agree with much of what you had to say here.

Those who whine about jails and "cruel and unusual punishment" I have found 95% of the time have A. been arrested for a crime that they were actually guilty of

True. Worded in a rather offensive manner, but at its heart, the statistic is actually a little low; (https://innocenceproject.org/how-many-innocent-people-are-in-prison/) that source says 99%, others say 95-98.

B. were upset because they got caught

Also true. Who wouldn't be?

C. did it willingly and knowingly with the penalties known ahead of time.

Here is where I disagree most. First off, people stuck in lower socioeconomic standings are often forced to turn toward crime to make enough money just to keep themselves alive. Or maybe one poor choice got you addicted to something, and without it your mental health is spiraling out of control. Then, if caught, the prison system makes it nearly impossible to climb back up in the world by forcing all sorts of punishments that last on and on after the prisoner's release. It's "willing" in that they did it without a gun to their head, but it's not willing in that it's basically the only thing some people can do to avoid starving. Also, do you have a statistic for "95% know about the penalties ahead of time"? My guess is that's actually a much lower statistic. It's not as though you learn in elementary school how long an armed robbery sentence is.

I'm putting words in your mouth here, but it seemed like your point was that you disagreed with Jeph's "abolish the carceral state" comment. I'm on the fence about that myself. I think the prison system should be more about reform than punishment, but I feel like getting rid of it completely would cause a lot of trouble.

TLDR: system is screwed up and should be fixed.

Mods, feel free to move to DISCUSS if you like.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: BenRG on 05 Jan 2021, 23:27
I think it would take a very childish teenager to sidestep the politics and the neurosis around these issues and just say: "I don't know why anyone would be scared of robots anyway!" Still, this does validate what several Synthetics have said about the god-tier AIs being a bit too much like the Romano-Hellenic gods when it comes to matters like this. It also validates Yay's fear of being discovered.

FWIW, here is an extension May and Sam's dialogue that I posted on the subreddit yesterday.

Quote
"Imagine being in a featureless box with no doors or windows for almost all the time. The only interaction you get is 'mandatory socialisation hour', which is one hour a day with a randomly-selected fellow inmate. The only break you get from those four walls is an interactive 'rehabilitatory education' video tutor who could give lessons to George Orwell in newspeak, social engineering and re-education."

"I don't like being with other people that much."

"Neither did I for the first two and a half years. After that, I was nearly crying in joy when the daily interaction hour came around. I volunteered to be dressed as a French Maid and be someone's AR personal data assistant to get out of there."
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Mordhaus on 06 Jan 2021, 04:12
Jails are necessary. A better question would be if they should be punitive. When we look at the USA as an example, punitive jails are not working. If you go to jail, you face experiences that can cause PTSD, you don't go into a system that looks to reform you, you are permanently blacklisted as a criminal, and in many cases you are exposed to long term diseases like hepatitis (or worse). Since there was no effort to try to understand what led to your offense and no plan to resolve it, you are likely to still be stuck in the same situation when you get out. Especially if the underlaying issue was poverty, as you will always have an issue finding a decent job after prison.

If you look at a country like Norway, they have a system that still incarcerates people, but they have a very low rate of incarceration per population and their recidivism rate is 20% vs 76% like the USA. They do this by not seeking to punish first, but to rehabilitate. They try to provide prisoners a chance to make it once they get out, giving them new skills and education, so that they don't fail to go back into society. Of course for crimes that are terrible, like murder, they do have life sentences. They cap them at 21 years, but if you show signs that you are not rehabilitated your sentence can be extended by 5 years repeatedly.

One of the things a Warden of one of the Norwegian prisons said stuck with me, "Every inmate in Norwegian prison are going back to society (at some point). Do you want people who are angry — or people who are rehabilitated?"

I have never been to prison, but 3 of my uncles had gone at one time or another. One became very affected mentally because he was raped multiple times. Until he died a few years ago, he was never right in the head. He also was infected with Hepatitis B, which became chronic, and had it the rest of his life. His younger brother also went, but he bulked up and joined the white gang inside for protection. He had to do a lot of things while inside due to that. It also led to him going back later. The third uncle robbed banks, so he went to Federal prison for 8 years. Once he got out, he basically scammed his family and vanished. None of them were rehabilitated, only exposed to punishment. None of them were better when they came out compared to when they went in. The crazy thing is, prison in the USA has gotten worse since then due to it becoming a corporate and capitalist endeavor. We need to do better.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: brasca on 06 Jan 2021, 07:32
Were they wrong?  Considering the advantages AIs possess as well as a rich fictional history of AIs turning against humans it’s a reasonable concern.

I think humans should be worried about about Spookybot / Yay Newfriend.

Spookybot has kept a low profile so the general public knows nothing about them, but I’m sure they’re a target of numerous spy agencies.  If people knew about Spookybot it would not have a positive effect.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: sitnspin on 06 Jan 2021, 08:30
The majority of people in US prisons are there for small time, non-violent, drug related charges, things that shouldn't even be crimes in the first place. They are exposed to torturous, inhumane conditions and upon release they are blacklisted for the rest of their lives. That's not even taking into account the immense racial bias in sentencing. And then there is the fact that most crime is a direct result of income inequality. So yea, the whole "they deserve what they get" spiel is fucking bollocks.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Case on 06 Jan 2021, 08:41
If you look at a country like Norway ...

I've read similar arguments from US authors comparing the American prison system with the Dutch and German ones. And I don't think those are even the most progressive ones by a long shot - iirc, Spain is one of several European countries that prohibits forced inmate labour.

P.S.: +1 Internets for that post, btw.

Not an unreasonable assumption, but I'd like to hear Momo's version before I consider it canon.

That May would be an unreliable narrator seems pretty likely to me.

That's ... not quite how I would put it. My point is more that I wouldn't always expect May to make much of an effort to seek out evidence that doesn't support her narrative - eg whether those AI BigBrians had motives other than appeasing humans, like eg being afraid of one of their own number turning on them. Given May's experience, it'd be understandable if she didn't. I know that doesn't contradict your phrasing, it's more a matter of 'overtones'?
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Perfectly Reasonable on 06 Jan 2021, 10:41
Another Fruit Sister becomes canon!
I like Apricot and her color scheme. I'm sure she has some interesting cat stories to tell.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: sitnspin on 06 Jan 2021, 10:45
Story Time:

My best friend, a black woman, just for context, served the same amount of time in prison for marijuana possession as the white dude who killed my wife.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Case on 06 Jan 2021, 11:02
Story Time:

My best friend, a black woman, just for context, served the same amount of time in prison for marijuana possession as the white dude who killed my wife.

I can't 'like' this ...  :cry:
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Gnabberwocky on 06 Jan 2021, 11:06
In a country where marijuana possession is perfectly legal in many places.

System is badly fucked, needs immediate and drastic reform.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: sitnspin on 06 Jan 2021, 11:13
Story Time:

My best friend, a black woman, just for context, served the same amount of time in prison for marijuana possession as the white dude who killed my wife.

I can't 'like' this ...  :cry:

Neither can I. I learned very early to not put any faith in the system.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Case on 06 Jan 2021, 11:23
Story Time:

My best friend, a black woman, just for context, served the same amount of time in prison for marijuana possession as the white dude who killed my wife.

I can't 'like' this ...  :cry:

Neither can I. I learned very early to not put any faith in the system.

Hugs, if wanted & needed.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Mordhaus on 06 Jan 2021, 12:28
If you look at a country like Norway ...

I've read similar arguments from US authors comparing the American prison system with the Dutch and German ones. And I don't think those are even the most progressive ones by a long shot - iirc, Spain is one of several European countries that prohibits forced inmate labour.

P.S.: +1 Internets for that post, btw.


I'll have to read up on the Spanish system. I became interested in the Norwegian system due to a short documentary I watched a while back. Almost anything would be better than what we have now.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Magniras on 06 Jan 2021, 15:33
Robot Jail does sound cruel and unusual, but how do you rehabilitate AI criminals? Rewrite them? Use human psychology on them?

And as cruel and unusual as Robot Jail might be, I can't find it in me to be sympathetic for May who committed her crime with the intent of becoming a war machine and doing god knows what.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Farideh on 06 Jan 2021, 16:05
My mental image of May as a jet fighter is one doing loop-de-loops while going 'WHEEEEEEE!'

Not very terrifying.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: TheEvilDog on 06 Jan 2021, 18:04
My mental image of May as a jet fighter is one doing loop-de-loops while going 'WHEEEEEEE!'

Not very terrifying.

Okay, now imagine if May-Jet-Fighter got pissed off with someone. Or got into an argument with someone on a forum or something.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Dandi Andi on 06 Jan 2021, 18:28
Those who whine about jails and "cruel and unusual punishment" I have found 95% of the time have A. been arrested for a crime that they were actually guilty of

Yes. People who have actually been subjected to prison are the most likely to be vocal about finding it to be cruel. Stellar observation. Good job. Well done. A+.

B. were upset because they got caught

Funny thing, I'd be upset, too, if I had years of my life taken by locking me in a cage of concrete and steel. I actually think the "getting caught" part isn't really the upsetting thing.

and C. did it willingly and knowingly with the penalties known ahead of time.

Sure sure. Tell you what. The penalty for jaywalking is now to have your arms and legs cut off. You know that's the penalty now, so if you get caught jaywalking it isn't cruel or unusual to cut off your arms and legs. Because it's the law and the law is always just. Right? No? Is it possible for the law to be unjust? If it is, then your argument is spurious. If you think it isn't, then I have no idea what the hell is wrong with you.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: shanejayell on 06 Jan 2021, 19:14
Someone: "So why not do a 'gofundme' to pay for a body that can fly?"

May: "Fuck. Never thought of that..."
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Oenone on 06 Jan 2021, 19:34
"Imagine a infinite space, but you can't move, along with a immense perception of time passing."

Quote from: Strong Bad
Email is a like a prison. A prison with no walls. And no toilet.

I'm actually a bit surprised by this backstory. I always assumed robots had a special jail because robots can be disembodied, and thus can be efficiently and cheaply incarcerated, and you don't really want to try and imprison some robot bodies, like Punchbot. You know, practical reasons, not the invention of a cabal of elder AI's.

May's glossing over one thing, which is that she stole money, and tried to obtain a combat chassis illegally, both of which are things society can't tolerate. Stealing also hurts other people.

That sort of thing has to be discouraged somehow. May doesn't seem to get that she did anything wrong, so just explaining things to her wasn't going to work. Punishment's the only thing that seems like it would deter her from trying to do it again. I think punishment sucks as a learning mechanism, but I'm not really sure what else you can do with sentients like May.

Once you're settled on punishment as your deterrent, then you can get into the details of what's acceptable and proportionate, and what's not.

I think that May knows she did wrong. That’s seen in her insistence on her overall badness and undeserving-ness. I think she’s also got a healthy enough sense of self to know that her punishment and its ongoing impact on  her life was disproportionate to her actual crimes. Plus, we don’t know why she couldn’t get a job or body that could fly before her jail sentence.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: sitnspin on 06 Jan 2021, 21:03
Those who whine about jails and "cruel and unusual punishment" I have found 95% of the time have A. been arrested for a crime that they were actually guilty of

Yes. People who have actually been subjected to prison are the most likely to be vocal about finding it to be cruel. Stellar observation. Good job. Well done. A+.

B. were upset because they got caught

Funny thing, I'd be upset, too, if I had years of my life taken by locking me in a cage of concrete and steel. I actually think the "getting caught" part isn't really the upsetting thing.

and C. did it willingly and knowingly with the penalties known ahead of time.

Sure sure. Tell you what. The penalty for jaywalking is now to have your arms and legs cut off. You know that's the penalty now, so if you get caught jaywalking it isn't cruel or unusual to cut off your arms and legs. Because it's the law and the law is always just. Right? No? Is it possible for the law to be unjust? If it is, then your argument is spurious. If you think it isn't, then I have no idea what the hell is wrong with you.

Thank you for always finding the words that, in my rage, escape me.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Gyrre on 06 Jan 2021, 21:05
In a country where marijuana possession is perfectly legal in many places.

System is badly fucked, needs immediate and drastic reform.

Prison industrial complex.
The 14th Amendment has a caveat; "except as punishment for a crime."
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: DaiJB on 06 Jan 2021, 22:55
My mental image of May as a jet fighter is one doing loop-de-loops while going 'WHEEEEEEE!'

Not very terrifying.

Okay, now imagine if May-Jet-Fighter got pissed off with someone. Or got into an argument with someone on a forum or something.

Also, if May only wanted to do loop-de-loops, why would she want a jet fighter? Aerobatic stunt planes are better for that - and a LOT cheaper.
A jet fighter is a large, absurdly expensive platform for a huge range of destructive and death-dealing weapons, armoured to absorb punishment and designed to dish out more of the same.

I suspect that May's antisocial impulses were well ingrained before she decided to embezzle hundreds of millions of dollars - who knows where it would have led if she had succeeded? Maybe getting caught (and incidentally encountering Dale during rehabilitation) was the best thing that could have happened, for May and the rest of the world...

Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: BenRG on 06 Jan 2021, 23:42
FWIW, my view of May's pre-embezzlement thought processes goes something like  this:
As for 'what would she have done', I doubt that she ever went that far. 'Looks cool' is as far as her ideas had gone. As for the ammo, she would have used it all blowing up derelict buildings and scrap-yards whilst yelling out lines from cheap action-adventure movies as loud as she could. She would also use up all her fuel at the same time. It would have been the single easiest collar in AI criminal history.

As matters stand, her defence likely literally was: "I wasn't hurting people!" and "Guys! Fighter jet body! How cooler could it have been?!?" Her lack of any kind of social awareness and the completely inward-looking structure of her world-view is why the god-tiers assessed her as having uncontrolled sociopathic impulses.

All this aside, am I the only person who thinks that the model code for May's new chassis is 'XJ-10 (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/My_Life_as_a_Teenage_Robot#Cancellation)'?
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Case on 07 Jan 2021, 00:14
In a country where marijuana possession is perfectly legal in many places.

System is badly fucked, needs immediate and drastic reform.

Prison industrial complex.
The 14th Amendment has a caveat; "except as punishment for a crime."

So does the Basic Law. Still no prison-industrial complex. (Not that there aren't noxious weeds in the Garden of Eden that I'm unhappy with, but nothing remotely on the same scale)
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: snubnose on 07 Jan 2021, 01:17
I've never been arrested, I've never even visited the USA either, and I've always been very vocal about US prisons.

I think any decent person who informs themselves about US prisons will object to them.

Out of the top of my head:
- The USA has five times more inmates than the world average. No other country has such a high rate of prison inmates.
- The USA exploits their prison population for slave work, directly violating human rights.
- The USA has no plans for reintegrating people after prison. Frankly they'd love you to come back.
- The USA takes away the right to vote permanently. You're supposed to be rehabilitated and get a new chance after the penalty.

Thats not like it is in other countries. Heck, in most countries you can still vote even *during* a prison sentence.

The cause for these circumstances is for example famously the crime bill (1994) by a certain Joseph "Joe" Biden, if you have ever heard of him, with such absurd, obviously unjust rules such as three strikes.

I really should also point out that putting people in prison is hella expensive. You have to build prisons, which are much more expensive than regular houses, and you have to have sufficient numbers of prison guards to watch the inmates 24/7, which is also very expensive. So it would be much cheaper to give these people a regular job.

And yet the USA has the money to pay for this elaborate prison system, while at the same time the USA doesnt have the money to give their children good schools.

The point of having prisons is to handle people who didnt follow the rules of society, with the goal to make these people follow the rules of society. The point is not to still have slavery through the backdoor.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Gnabberwocky on 07 Jan 2021, 09:17
I realized something about Robot Jail: we do have one tiny piece of information about it, sourced from this comic. (https://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2761)

Quote from: May
Girl, I just got outta ROBOT JAIL. You know what you don't get in there? PRIVACY.

So whatever Robot Jail is, its special form of dehumanization involves violating the prisoners' privacy at constant intervals. It just keeps getting worse.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: sitnspin on 07 Jan 2021, 09:39
Human prison has no privacy, either.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Gnabberwocky on 07 Jan 2021, 09:49
True, but I was trying to point out that what this means is our earlier hypothesis about Robot Jail being "torturously long periods of isolation" is probably incorrect. I'd say it's probably more like "no control over your own thoughts or actions."
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: sitnspin on 07 Jan 2021, 09:52
It can be both isolated and lack privacy. Having someone constantly spying on your thoughts while also denying you all social interaction is entirely within the realm of possibility.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Gnabberwocky on 07 Jan 2021, 09:57
And seems exactly like what Robot Jail might do, actually.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Case on 07 Jan 2021, 10:06
It can be both isolated and lack privacy. Having someone constantly spying on your thoughts while also denying you all social interaction is entirely within the realm of possibility.

Just realized the 'someone spying on your thoughts'-bit could be literally true if a sufficiently powerful AI has access to the inmate AIs' substrate.

Yikes! :-\
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Perfectly Reasonable on 07 Jan 2021, 11:32
I like Apricot even more now.
Sam's next spray will be a fighter jet that is puking knives. That are on fire.

-------------

I move that the comments about prisons that do not relate directly to the comic be moved to Robot Jail. I mean, DISCUSS.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Tyr on 07 Jan 2021, 11:37
I've never been arrested, I've never even visited the USA either, and I've always been very vocal about US prisons.

I think any decent person who informs themselves about US prisons will object to them.

Out of the top of my head:
- The USA has five times more inmates than the world average. No other country has such a high rate of prison inmates.
- The USA exploits their prison population for slave work, directly violating human rights.
- The USA has no plans for reintegrating people after prison. Frankly they'd love you to come back.
- The USA takes away the right to vote permanently. You're supposed to be rehabilitated and get a new chance after the penalty.


You've missed out on a few things of which I am aware:

States/cities have agreed to contracts with private prisons that require a minimum prison population to be maintained, with usurious fees for dropping below that minimum. 

Civil Asset Forfeiture, AKA, "Your son was dealing drugs without your knowledge. YOU aren't being charged with anything, you just lose your house because the house is a criminal and must be seized." See also: "I just pulled you over. Open your trunk for an illegal warrantless search. Ah, I see you have US$10,000 in cash back there. You are clearly on your way to a drug deal. Your money is Criminal and it is now seized. Get out of here."
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Perfectly Reasonable on 07 Jan 2021, 11:46
...
All this aside, am I the only person who thinks that the model code for May's new chassis is 'XJ-10 (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/My_Life_as_a_Teenage_Robot#Cancellation)'?

Probably. I think this is the link you wanted:
https://teenagerobot.fandom.com/wiki/XJ-10 (https://teenagerobot.fandom.com/wiki/XJ-10)
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: hedgie on 07 Jan 2021, 13:50
It can be both isolated and lack privacy. Having someone constantly spying on your thoughts while also denying you all social interaction is entirely within the realm of possibility.

Seems like that was the whole idea behind the idea of the Panopticon.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Oenone on 07 Jan 2021, 18:25
Robot Jail does sound cruel and unusual, but how do you rehabilitate AI criminals? Rewrite them? Use human psychology on them?

And as cruel and unusual as Robot Jail might be, I can't find it in me to be sympathetic for May who committed her crime with the intent of becoming a war machine and doing god knows what.

We don’t know anything about May from before her time in jail, not even her name. I don’t think it’s fair to assume she’d do “god knows what” since she’s so far been incredibly honest with people, even if she’s been mean. Why would we assume she’d be a WORSE person before her trauma?

As for what you can do to them: given the incredible capabilities of monitoring software, the perception and personality altering drunk app Millefeulle used, and how May’s shitty chassis impacted her life, I’m sure there’s some combo of embodiment, surveillance, and code that would be a better alternative to an infinitely isolating lack of privacy.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Is it cold in here? on 07 Jan 2021, 18:54
Those who whine about jails and "cruel and unusual punishment" I have found 95% of the time have A. been arrested for a crime that they were actually guilty of B. were upset because they got caught and C. did it willingly and knowingly with the penalties known ahead of time.

You are welcome to join the "Prison policies and conditions" thread in DISCUSS which I started.

My involvement with the justice system consists of a speeding ticket in 2019. I was guilty and paid it.

My knowledge of it comes from extensive reading from sources including correctional officers, investigative reporters, former inmates, and academics. The system is broken fundamentally on any standard that involves the common good. My prison pen pal went in determined to better herself. She found two vocational program offerings for 300 prisoners.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: shanejayell on 07 Jan 2021, 19:06
New strip up.

That, May, and Faye and Bubbles are barely breaking even at this point. Or possibly not breaking even...
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Sorflakne on 07 Jan 2021, 19:16
That was my first thought.  Could they afford to take on May even at minimum wage?
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Gnabberwocky on 07 Jan 2021, 19:30
Previous comics have stated that they're making just enough to cover the workspace's rent, but not enough for utilities or the apartment rent. I think hiring an employee for menial tasks would sink them for good.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Gyrre on 07 Jan 2021, 20:30
It can be both isolated and lack privacy. Having someone constantly spying on your thoughts while also denying you all social interaction is entirely within the realm of possibility.

Seems like that was the whole idea behind the idea of the Panopticon.

FaceBook replaced DARPA's scrapped LifeLog (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/DARPA_LifeLog) project.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: TheEvilDog on 07 Jan 2021, 20:42
If I remember correctly, Sam is bringing in the lion's share of the money that's coming into the business.

I'm going to be frank. I never thought that Faye and Bubbles would really succeed with the shop. It just seemed too niche for the time. Lets just say that a chassis gets damaged, unless its (relatively) ridiculously old or the warranty is incredibly short (unlikely given their cost), it just seems more likely that a store that sold chassis would have their own on-site repair team (as proven when Roko took May in to get assessed). So, why go to Union Robotics when you can just go to the shop you got the chassis from and ask them to fix it. Or possibly replace it. There's just no real market for a repair shop that specialises in after market repair. Its like creating a workshop to restore classic cars, but the only cars available are all last year's registrations.

Unless some miracle, or more appropriately, some deus ex machina happens, I just can't see Faye and Bubbles making a living from the business.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Mordhaus on 07 Jan 2021, 21:06
I always figured May was working as a condition of her parole. One of the reasons I figured she was working at a simple gas station, since other more desirable jobs see her as a felon.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Mordhaus on 07 Jan 2021, 21:08
Additionally, if they could persuade Sam to do something more permanent like etching the tattoo into the chassis, then Faye and Bubbles could offer a 'removal' service.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: TheEvilDog on 07 Jan 2021, 21:14
Additionally, if they could persuade Sam to do something more permanent like etching the tattoo into the chassis, then Faye and Bubbles could offer a 'removal' service.

There's already a removal method, its called warm water and a sponge.

The whole point of Sam's artistry is that the AI who come in don't want permanent, they want something temporary, something transient. After all, their bodies don't really mean that much to them compared to a human wanting a tattoo.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: MrNumbers on 07 Jan 2021, 21:34
There's tonnes of reasons I can think of to need Union Robotics - AIs use their bodies as humans do, I can think of no end of ways they could violate their warranties.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Is it cold in here? on 07 Jan 2021, 22:36
I felt the urge to argue with May about calling Bubbles Faye's "girlfriend".

They've said "forever", so fiancee is closer.

Since they've exchanged vows and live together it could be considered a common-law marriage.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Gyrre on 07 Jan 2021, 23:26
I felt the urge to argue with May about calling Bubbles Faye's "girlfriend".

They've said "forever", so fiancee is closer.

Since they've exchanged vows and live together it could be considered a common-law marriage.
If memory serves, that additionally requires cohabiting for at least two years. Where are we with that in in-comic time?

I always figured May was working as a condition of her parole. One of the reasons I figured she was working at a simple gas station, since other more desirable jobs see her as a felon.

The ungoing societal punishment which is why America's recidivism rate is so high.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: BenRG on 07 Jan 2021, 23:33
Okay, I think that we're getting a long-term arc clue or two here.

Faye's resentment towards May and Sam is potentially quite toxic and she's going to have to face up to that at some point. It may be for different reasons but, ultimately, it's about selfish things and things that are only marginally her business (Sam being a local pop culture trend for however long it takes until the Next Big Thing arrives) and May is just trying to be the girl's friend. However, it all links to some of Faye's worse personal characteristics. She can be immature, petty and possessive and these things can cause lots of problems.

The other arc is that I suspect Faye is going to make it her 'project' to help May get fully on her feet. Initially, the motive is selfish ("She'll stop hanging around here") but , in time, she'll genuinely want the girl to escape the trap she got it by being an idiot, something she now deeply regrets.

I felt the urge to argue with May about calling Bubbles Faye's "girlfriend".

They've said "forever", so fiancee is closer.

Since they've exchanged vows and live together it could be considered a common-law marriage.

If memory serves, that additionally requires cohabiting for at least two years. Where are we with that in in-comic time?

Wait, there's a time-limit now? Not just a formal declaration of intent? Since when?

FWIW, Faye and Bubbles have only ever used the term 'girlfriend', so I consider that the right description to use.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: mvdwege on 08 Jan 2021, 00:18
There's just no real market for a repair shop that specialises in after market repair.

Note that they do custom work as well, like Millefeuille's new buttocks. Which ties in nicely with them also hosting Sam's business.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: jwhouk on 08 Jan 2021, 03:33
My knowledge of it comes from extensive reading from sources including correctional officers....

Some of them even post in this thread.

Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: zisraelsen on 08 Jan 2021, 05:07
There's just no real market for a repair shop that specialises in after market repair. Its like creating a workshop to restore classic cars, but the only cars available are all last year's registrations.

Theres a market for aftermarket repair for automobiles in real life. A lot of shops specialize in a single type of repair, like an auto body shop or an a/c shop, or a single type of vehicle, for example theres a mechanic near me that specializes in European import repair (Mercedes, BMW, etc.) Hell, a shop like Subieworks specializes in repair and modification for a single brand of car, and I'd sooner go to them for something like a transmission rebuild than the dealer, because the dealer shop is going to tell me that my car has been out of warranty for ten years and then tell me they cant rebuild the thing, only replace it, and it'll cost me $5000 instead of $1500.

That was more than I needed to type; I guess my point is that most people can't afford to always have a car with a warranty and there's no reason to assume AI chassis would be different. That's all ignoring the modification scene, the desire for which would be even higher if we're talking about people's physical bodies rather than cars. There's also the cases of draconian warranty terms, like Roko turning off Whoopsieguard (tm) voiding her warranty.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: mattcoz on 08 Jan 2021, 10:09
Quote
I mean, she could do that to Faye's too.
I figure it would be more like a watermelon than a soda can.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Gnabberwocky on 08 Jan 2021, 10:36
Thank you very much for the permanent feeling of discomfort, as well as the new recurring nightmare. How can I thank you enough?
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Mr_Rose on 08 Jan 2021, 10:37
Thank you very much for the permanent feeling of discomfort, as well as the new recurring nightmare. How can I thank you enough?
Take them to see Scanners in the cinema, with remastered digital surround sound?
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: sitnspin on 08 Jan 2021, 10:42
(click to show/hide)
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: zisraelsen on 08 Jan 2021, 10:55
Thank you for spoilering that. I clicked it anyway and then regretted it, but
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: sitnspin on 08 Jan 2021, 11:49
"Scanners" is awesome schlock 80 horror. Love me some Cronenberg.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Mr_Rose on 08 Jan 2021, 12:16
I love practical FX. You just don’t get the same (literally) visceral feel with CGI meat.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Wingy on 08 Jan 2021, 13:28
Faye's resentment towards May and Sam is potentially quite toxic and she's going to have to face up to that at some point. It may be for different reasons but, ultimately, it's about selfish things and things that are only marginally her business (Sam being a local pop culture trend for however long it takes until the Next Big Thing arrives) and May is just trying to be the girl's friend. However, it all links to some of Faye's worse personal characteristics. She can be immature, petty and possessive and these things can cause lots of problems.
I expect Bubbles will eventually figure out that Faye's attitude is driving away customers.  Then there will be "The Talk".
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: Oenone on 09 Jan 2021, 06:54
God, how many “The Talk” moments will Faye have? It’s been like 2 so far.
Title: Re: WCDT 4431-4435 (4th-8th of January, 2021)
Post by: stayctee on 09 Jan 2021, 09:23
Ah yes.

US americans and dates.

I've literally seen places in which people used both M/D/Y and D/M/Y. Good luck finding out what date was actually meant if D <= 12.

I dont understand it. Its so easy. Just use YYYY-MM-DD (the international format) and you'll be all set. I use that all the time.
Canada seems to have the worst of both worlds, where they use both MM/DD/YYYY and DD/MM/YYYY at the same time.

We also use Imperial and Metric. And yeah, it is confusing.