THESE FORUMS NOW CLOSED (read only)
Comic Discussion => QUESTIONABLE CONTENT => Topic started by: Sooozie on 11 Aug 2008, 21:53
-
Is she four or what?! I really do love this comic but if Jeph doesn't move off of this childish storyline I may have to bail. I get that she has problems, I get that she had a bad childhood, but a "worry hat?" Why don't you have one of the characters get knocked up so there's a REAL child to feature? Sorry Jeph...it's just a little too weird.
-
I am striking you from my will.
-
Is she four or what?! I really do love this comic but if Jeph doesn't move off of this childish storyline I may have to bail. I get that she has problems, I get that she had a bad childhood, but a "worry hat?" Why don't you have one of the characters get knocked up so there's a REAL child to feature? Sorry Jeph...it's just a little too weird.
Don't let the door hit you in the ass on your way out.
-
yeah jeph, do another comic about penises or we're all going to leave. we don't come here for substance you know.
-
The hat probably worked because Marten was showing concern for her and it made her feel better temporarily, that she wasn't alone with her worries. The hat will serve as a reminder that there are people in her life now that care about her and she isn't just some strange lonely socially-awkward neat-freak girl any more, she is a neat-freak girl with friends that she can turn to when she has problems.
-
Also, why the fuck am I answering this thread seriously Jesus what is wrong with me AUGH.
-
I interpreted it as it stopped her from worrying becuase it distracted her.
Meow.
-
BAN HAT ENGAGE
-
This is not some shitty soap opera (down here it's "telenovela"), so I don't think having one of the characters get knocked up would solve all problems. I see no problems anyways. Hannelore happens to be my favorite character as well, just because of her un-typical-ness. If you want generic storylines, read a crappy romance novel.*
You say that Hannelore is acting childish and it's "a little too weird". What would any type of entertainment be if it were all stale and "normal" and if all characters were the same? "Hi." "Hi." "What's up?" "Not much. You?" "Not much. I'm going to play Halo. 'Night" "'Night".
*I'm not saying all romance novels are crappy, but that there are some/many.
-
This telenovela talk gives me an idea for a one-off strip complete with corny dialouge.
Scene: Marten & Faye's
Players: Marten, Dora, Pintsize
Pannel 1
Dora: Marten, I have dreadful news to tell you.
Marten: What is it my love?
Pannel 2
Dora: Marten, I am with child.
Marten: I'm going to be a father!
Dora: No Marten, it is not your child.
Pannel 3
Marten: (enraged) You whore! Who is this man that will father my ex-girlfrend's child?
Dora: It was... Pintsize.
Pannel 4
Marten: Pintsize? But how...
Pintsize: (inturrupts) That's right buddy! I QWERTYd that all night!
-
Oh god, thats so funny mustang. I would like to illustrate it.
Also, more on topic. I don't know what you know about psychology Sooozie, but simple objects like the worry hat can calm people down. Hannelore has a severe case of OCD and probably some other psychological problems. Marten showed he cared that she was worried. Yes it was childish, but just because she is a grown woman does not mean she cannot smile over something so simple.
When I was young my mother used to have "monster spray" that turned "monsters" into pennies. So whenever I'd get scared of "monsters" she'd go in the room, spray it and put several pennies on the ground. It was a neat little trick to calm me down.
Marten's worry hat is quite the same. It wasn't the idea of the worry hat that calmed her down, it was the fact that Marten cared. Also, about her crying over hitting her head on the cabinet. The woman had blood running down her face. I know a few grown men who would cry if they hit their head that hard.
Also, how many people on the forum were like "cool a worry hat!" Things like that can be ok even if you're an adult.
And frankly, if you're going to stop reading the comic because you think a few strips are stupid. . . then ok, bye. . . no one is going to try and stop you.
-
Many grown people rely on simple objects as talismans for psychological protection. Who among us has not had a "lucky" object at one point or another? I myself have a number of rituals and objects that I always carry out or have with me when I go out into the fields to carry out some "long distance landscaping".
The presence of such objects/rituals is indicative of "magical" thinking, but at our hearts humans are still the primitive creatures, jumping at what might be the sounds of the wolf in the dark and clutching at that special rock or branch tht will keep us safe.
-
Is she four or what?! I really do love this comic but if Jeph doesn't move off of this childish storyline I may have to bail. I get that she has problems, I get that she had a bad childhood, but a "worry hat?" Why don't you have one of the characters get knocked up so there's a REAL child to feature? Sorry Jeph...it's just a little too weird.
Maybe you should shut it. And if you don't like where the comic is going, stop reading it. I mean, like, now-ish. Maybe you should just get knocked up to fill up your free time, no?
(not to be mean, but seriously. stop bitching)
-
Maybe if you read the original post properly instead of lashing out in a huff you'd realise that the poster said he loves the comic, but dislikes the current arc.
-
The thing I have never understood is "If you don't like it, stop reading it."
How would you know if you liked it if you stopped reading it I mean come on.
-
Is she four or what?! I really do love this comic but if Jeph doesn't move off of this childish storyline I may have to bail. I get that she has problems, I get that she had a bad childhood, but a "worry hat?" Why don't you have one of the characters get knocked up so there's a REAL child to feature? Sorry Jeph...it's just a little too weird.
Personally. I'm a big fan of Hanners.
She is basically the female version of one of my best friends.
All that's missing is a comic with Hannelore sleeping in a bath tub with some stuffed animals.. :lol:
-
Oh god Roxie, I love your avatar. =)
-
Is she four or what?! I really do love this comic but if Jeph doesn't move off of this childish storyline I may have to bail. I get that she has problems, I get that she had a bad childhood, but a "worry hat?" Why don't you have one of the characters get knocked up so there's a REAL child to feature? Sorry Jeph...it's just a little too weird.
Yeah, Jeph makes an alternate comic that cuts out all the childish stuff.
Hit Alt+F4 and it takes you directly to it
I highly recommend it :wink:
-
All that's missing is a comic with Hannelore sleeping in a bath tub with some stuffed animals.
Oh man, that would be awesome.
As for the purpose of this thread: ...I agree with everyone else for the most part.
-
This telenovela talk gives me an idea for a one-off strip complete with corny dialouge.
Scene: Marten & Faye's
Players: Marten, Dora, Pintsize
Pannel 1
Dora: Marten, I have dreadful news to tell you.
Marten: What is it my love?
Pannel 2
Dora: Marten, I am with child.
Marten: I'm going to be a father!
Dora: No Marten, it is not your child.
Pannel 3
Marten: (enraged) You whore! Who is this man that will father my ex-girlfrend's child?
Dora: It was... Pintsize.
Pannel 4
Marten: Pintsize? But how...
Pintsize: (inturrupts) That's right buddy! I QWERTYd that all night!
[img width= height=]http://i519.photobucket.com/albums/u359/Braydra/Untitled.jpg[/img]
I apologise for my poor attempt. =/
-
HellStorm gets I have nothing of value to add. cookies.
EDIT: The FUCK? I was trying to give the dude a coockie, you douche.
-
I think it adds something that it's a pre-60 Pintsize.
-
Sure it does! (http://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=5)
-
Yeah I kinda just clicked random until I came up with an image of Pintsize :-P
-
...but a "worry hat?"...it's just a little too weird.
The fact that she didn't grow up on the planet earth or that her father would mail her a robotic boyfriend is okay with you, but a relatively common style of coping method is "too weird?"
It seems you are the minority in your opinion here.
-
I think that it's been covered pretty comprehensively at this point.
-
Hrmm i've advoided using this forum for years, i've been reading the comic for a long time.
But something Hanners said in the last comic was very wrong.
Blood does not carry pathogens, it is sterile. Very clean (usually) when it is carrying pathogens that person is septic and in trouble!
-
well no, blood still contains pathogens, otherwise it would not need leukocytes.
-
This is important and will be covered in any first aid class. There are some all-too-common bloodborne pathogens like hepatitis, and some really scary ones like HIV. See http://www.pp.okstate.edu/ehs/modules/bbp/index.htm or other resources. Blood banks need to be really careful not to let anything infectious into their inventory: that's why they ask if you've had a cold or flu recently.
Now, avoiding your own blood is a little over the top... But blood is anything but sterile.
-
Blood is a sterile site, as is most of your inards. Your gastinotenstinal tract is not, you have normal flora, also your skin has normal flora.
White blood cells are in your blood at all times, and are transfered around the body to sites that need them... like a wound or infection, or a virus etc.
Blood pathogens such as hepatitis i didnt think about, so vriuses could be there... but when would hanners have gotten something like hepatatis or HIV?
Any bacteria or fungus in blood will and always will be bad.
-
You can get Hepatitis-A from eating poorly-prepared food. Assuming that Hanners doesn't prepare all of the food she eats (ie: she occasionally goes to a restaurant, especially when her mother is visiting), she could conceivably have Hep-A.
File this one under 'theoretically possible, but really, wtf?'
-
You're all making this way too complicated. Hanners has OCD, which means that she has fears of things that may not actually exist in reality, like germs (pathogens) in her blood. OCD is not a rational thing. You'll notice that none of the other characters seemed concerned when she said her blood had pathogens in it.
I'm sort of wondering where the cop storyline was going to go. I guess Dora scared him away?
-
Horray for hydrogen peroxide! :lol:
-
If you go back and reread what she said, it says, "Not blood. It's scary and it carries pathogens." She wasn't talking about her own blood specifically. It's just that she worries about blood in general. which is due to her OCD.
-
or it could just be that she doesn't like blood and that her OCD is only a secondary factor in it.
-
Worst person I ever knew around blood was a medic that used to be in my unit.
She used to throw up when she saw people bleeding badly. Made looking after the troops somewhat difficult when they got injured.
-
Oh man, talk about taking on the wrong job.
-
That's not too bad. What if there was a guy that took a job getting stung by bees and he's allergic to bees?
-
Oh man, talk about taking on the wrong job.
Being given the wrong job, more like. In the military, it's less "What job would you like?" and more "Here's a job. Like it." Although they do try to make sure the job is suited to your aptitudes and tastes.
-
Actually there is an aptitude test before you enroll - to help decide if you have the smarts/common sense to do the job you've signed up for. In the Cdn military, you choose three "trades" you're interested in (ranked from most desired to least) and if you fit the aptitude for them, then they will try to accomodate you by putting you where you want to go. Being a volunteer military means we would rather have people doing jobs they want to do, increases performance.
Back on topic Hanners isn't having an unusual reaction to blood or injury, even for someone without OCD. I'm still not sure why people where thinking that her reaction was over the top.
-
That's not too bad. What if there was a guy that took a job getting stung by bees and he's allergic to bees?
That would be a horrible idea. Whether he knew he was allergic or not. I mean, ouch. For real.
-
Ya, that's not really a job is it. Unless your some kinda wierd (and I mean really wierd) fetish prostitute.
-
come on, hanners is awesome! if jeph dropped her ocd storyline from the comic i would be disappointed
-
Yay, I finally have the oppurtunity to mention this! (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schmidt_Sting_Pain_Index)
-
Ya, that's not really a job is it. Unless your some kinda wierd (and I mean really wierd) fetish prostitute.
You never know. You could get hired by a beekeeper who wants his bees to get some excercise.
Flex the stinger, kind of thing.
-
I don't think Hannelore's reaction was unusual or over-the-top, though I do find it kind of odd for her character that she never learned how to clean blood, especially since she can clean vomit. I don't know much about OCD, but I'd think it would make her want to learn how to clean EVERYTHING. Did she just throw away any panties that got a blood stain on them from a period? I'd think she'd learn how to deal with blood somewhat given that she's a female. (I know that she's on birth control (http://questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=966), but as far as I know, there aren't any birth control pills that stop a period entirely.) Besides, she's dealt with blood (http://questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=959) before without having a major freak-out. (I know that a freak-out is justified in the latest case because there was a lot more blood and the injury was more severe, but she seemed freaked out at just the fact that there was blood also.)
Today's strip (http://questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=1210) is kind of over-the-top, though. I think Jeph is taking the Hanners-acts-like-freaked-out-child thing a little too far. She just had a major freak-out; let's move on.
-
I have to agree with the original post's basic point:
When did Hannelore become so gullible?
Ever since her pregnancy "scare" I've been wondering where and when she lost her common sense. Possibly the most interesting character has become nothing more than panic-induced comic relief.
-
There was definitely a character personality shift in our Hanners. When she was introduced in strip 515, she was a self-confident, young woman who had no problem with confronting a drunk guy in the women's room pissing in the sink in which her OCD was dictating that she wash her hands. The OCD kept getting supplemented with other behaviours. The making of the voodoo doll for Marten at 546 showed a less confident Hannelore. The bunnysuited cleaning at 556 showed a more profound OCD. And it just keeps snowballing. She's quit smoking, but she still has the multiple ear piercings, but since 1175, her hair's just obscured her ears.
I think the visit from her mother may have accelerated her self-infantilism. While I do think the current Hannelore who can't cope with a minor scalp laceration and who goes catatonic when informed of the reason she shouldn't play drums in a mid-thigh skirt is hyper cute, on the verge of being kawai, I'd like to see her make some breakthroughs in coping with her OCD with her therapist, like Faye is.
This is completely the pot calling the kettle soot-stained, being 35 going on 16 myself, but I just think that more mature young women who are capable of voluntarily acting responsibly immature are sexier than truly immature young women.
-
Without going into her general portrayal as of late: dust mites, book lice and book scorpions exist, why couldn't book spiders? The answer is because paper dust can't uphold THAT much of an ecosystem, but hey, someone afraid of all sorts of dirty things — like anything out in the public — could pretty plausibly buy the idea of book spiders, especially from a library authority. Bibliodons sound a bit too silly, I admit. :-P
We would also have to assume she's never been to a (major, public) library before, more than cursorily at least… just HOW sheltered is she?
-
Is she four or what?! I really do love this comic but if Jeph doesn't move off of this childish storyline I may have to bail. I get that she has problems, I get that she had a bad childhood, but a "worry hat?" Why don't you have one of the characters get knocked up so there's a REAL child to feature? Sorry Jeph...it's just a little too weird.
ANGRY READER IS ANGRY.
-
I have to agree with the original post's basic point:
When did Hannelore become so gullible?
Ever since her pregnancy "scare" I've been wondering where and when she lost her common sense. Possibly the most interesting character has become nothing more than panic-induced comic relief.
I was about to say, "Yeah, things have been going downhill since the pregnancy scare," but then I looked at all of the comics between then and the Worry Hat arc, and I like Hanners in most of them. (Especially the Mr. Clean one and the dream sequence arc.) I felt that some were kind of "eh," but that nothing was over-the-top; she doesn't especially seem to lack common sense in most of them. (Any more so than she ever did.)
I just haven't been enjoying the Worry Hat arc too much. There have been enough "Hanners worrying over nothing" strips already, so new strips with that theme feel worn out, and the whole thing seemed predictable. Hanners freaking out about blood to the point where she throws out anything with a bloodstain on it is over-the-top even for her character. And as someone pointed out in the WCT thread, Tai is pulling a Faye in that Faye tried to frighten new Coffee of Doom employees with stories about giant coffee spiders (and succeeded with Raven). Gullibility is one of Raven's characteristics, not Hanners's.
Maybe Jeph is morphing Hanners into Raven, since we never see Raven anymore.
I think the visit from her mother may have accelerated her self-infantilism. While I do think the current Hannelore who can't cope with a minor scalp laceration and who goes catatonic when informed of the reason she shouldn't play drums in a mid-thigh skirt is hyper cute, on the verge of being kawai, I'd like to see her make some breakthroughs in coping with her OCD with her therapist, like Faye is.
She has made some breakthroughs in coping with her OCD. She's made friends and spends time with them instead of spending all of her time cleaning. In one strip, Marten asked her to have dinner with him and some others, and at first she answered, "No, I have to clean." Then she changed her mind because she remembered that her therapist told her that she shouldn't let her OCD get in the way of her socializing.
-
And then she went up in front of a big crowd and sang at open mic night.
-
Tai forgot to mention the Vashta Nerada.
Yeah, but how do we know that the books came from a forest where the Vashta Nerada lived?
-
<img src="http://img153.imageshack.us/img153/6435/aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaawl9.jpg>
-
OR THE MORE SERIOUS APPROACH
[img width= height=]http://img246.imageshack.us/img246/3720/heygirlpy4.jpg[/img]
SORRY GUYS ITS JUST SO ADDICTIVE
[CAPS LOX]
-
oh sweet lord that was hilarious.
-
Maybe you should shut it. And if you don't like where the comic is going, stop reading it. I mean, like, now-ish. Maybe you should just get knocked up to fill up your free time, no?
(not to be mean, but seriously. stop bitching)
This is a forum. Discussions happen here. Discussions are not always fawning adulation and praise--sometimes they involve criticism, complaint, and yes, bitching.
Bitching at someone about bitching is hypocritical in the extreme.
Unless you are a mod, telling someone to shut up in a discussion forum is antithetical to the purpose of both discussions and forums.
-
Maybe you should shut it. And if you don't like where the comic is going, stop reading it. I mean, like, now-ish. Maybe you should just get knocked up to fill up your free time, no?
(not to be mean, but seriously. stop bitching)
This is a forum. Discussions happen here. Discussions are not always fawning adulation and praise--sometimes they involve criticism, complaint, and yes, bitching.
Bitching at someone about bitching is hypocritical in the extreme.
Unless you are a mod, telling someone to shut up in a discussion forum is antithetical to the purpose of both discussions and forums.
Ok, I understand. And I apologize. And that was also one of my first posts. And I was already told to watch the tone.
And as far as I can see, you're bitching at me about bitching about bitching. And if you aren't, I don't understand the point of you attempting to reprimand for something that was resolved. Or did you just not read a couple posts later?
Also, I am pretty sure I am not the only person in the forum who isn't a mod and has told someone to shut up. But I digress, I am sorry for doing so. And I haven't done so since. I apologize for using the word "and" way too much, everyone.
-
I know. It's pretty bad. Sorry about that. I get defensive sometimes.
-
This is a forum. Discussions happen here. Discussions are not always fawning adulation and praise--sometimes they involve criticism, complaint, and yes, bitching.
Bitching at someone about bitching is hypocritical in the extreme.
Unless you are a mod, telling someone to shut up in a discussion forum is antithetical to the purpose of both discussions and forums.
Ok, I understand. And I apologize. And that was also one of my first posts. And I was already told to watch the tone.
That's good. But the post, though quoting you, was not for you solely. Both the complaining about complaining and the "love it or be silent" demands are chronic here. Every once in a while, people need to be reminded about the purpose of forums, and your post happened to be the trigger point this time.
And as far as I can see, you're bitching at me about bitching about bitching. And if you aren't, I don't understand the point of you attempting to reprimand for something that was resolved. Or did you just not read a couple posts later?
There's a difference between complaining and explaining, both in tone and function. The former ascribes negative value to an action, and the latter describes the action's consequence. And as I have said, this is not merely about you, and I apologize if I have allowed you to come to that conclusion.
-
Apology accepted. Seeing as how it was a direct quote from me, and there was no one else quoted I came to the conclusion that I was being punished for a mistake that I made. Which is fine. I agree with you, and again, I'm sorry. I wasn't trying to be mean, but the whole point of this thread (in the very beginning) was to basically trash Hanners. And I was just trying to go to the opposite extreme of what was first said. My bad.
Ok, fight's over, shower up!
-
I know. It's pretty bad. Sorry about that. I get defensive sometimes.
Relax, I'm just joking! I was just being silly. Honest. You are okay.
I know, its cool. I have the flu and I am a little delirious today. So I have been taking things personally. Ha. Oh man, I need to not have a fever.
Usually I'm so sarcastic and today I can't even pick up on sarcasm.
Thanks for letting me know that I'm alright, yo.
-
For the person who asked if there is birth control that stops your period completely: why yes, yes there is. (a) Lots of women take one of the major brand mixed pills and skip the sugar pills so no bleeding. Also, many women (like me!) get no period on the progesterone-only pill. Wooooo.
Plus yeah, I'm over the ditzy-cute Hanners stuff. I did find the worry hat cute though. *shrug* Cause you all needed to know my opinion :lol:
-
Jeph is right (twitter comment). Definitely the best Hannelore look-alike ever.
www.tinyurl.com/6h63w3
-
Here's one that does.
http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3282/2761367278_60deeceb99.jpg?v=0
-
No, bunnyThor, you've misunderstood everything. This is not a discussion forum, it's a forum dedicated to the art of performing textual fellatio of Jeph Jacques.
LESS TYPING ABOUT THE FORUM
MORE TYPING ABOUT HOW PRETTY I AM
(I am so pretty)
-
No, bunnyThor, you've misunderstood everything. This is not a discussion forum, it's a forum dedicated to the art of performing textual fellatio of Jeph Jacques.
LESS TYPING ABOUT THE FORUM
MORE TYPING ABOUT HOW PRETTY I AM
(I am so pretty)
Were I unwed I would take you in a [wo]manly fashion.
..
Because you're pretty.
-
No, bunnyThor, you've misunderstood everything. This is not a discussion forum, it's a forum dedicated to the art of performing textual fellatio of Jeph Jacques.
LESS TYPING ABOUT THE FORUM
MORE TYPING ABOUT HOW PRETTY I AM
(I am so pretty)
You got a real purdy mouth.
-
LESS TYPING ABOUT THE FORUM
MORE TYPING ABOUT HOW PRETTY I AM
(I am so pretty)
Were I unwed I would take you in a [wo]manly fashion.
Because you're pretty.
And witty.
-
LESS TYPING ABOUT THE FORUM
MORE TYPING ABOUT HOW PRETTY I AM
(I am so pretty)
Were I unwed I would take you in a [wo]manly fashion.
Because you're pretty.
And witty.
And Bright
Plus Your bird tats are the hottest thing ever
-
No, bunnyThor, you've misunderstood everything. This is not a discussion forum, it's a forum dedicated to the art of performing textual fellatio of Jeph Jacques.
LESS TYPING ABOUT THE FORUM
MORE TYPING ABOUT HOW PRETTY I AM
(I am so pretty)
Pretty or petty, I get the two confused at times.
-
Tai forgot to mention the Vashta Nerada.
/me smiles. I just watched that one yesterday!
-
Tai forgot to mention the Vashta Nerada.
/me smiles. I just watched that one yesterday!
It's pretty awesome.
After that one, I refused to go to the library for ages =[
-
Oh wow, I didn't realize that a "/ me" was going to work. This forum just got cooler. Also, yeah. . . I slept with my lights on last night.
-
I also was scared like hell after the statues one 'Don't Blink' or something. I went to Dublin the next day. Do you have any idea how many statues there are in Dublin? D:
-
Lol that would scare the hell outta me :[
I refuse to have any form of statue in any part of my house unless it is a gnome or something similar. Because you spell gnome funny, so it can't be a bad thing =]
-
/me smiles. I just watched that one yesterday!
Oh man, how do we turn that shit off?
-
My dog can't see our lawn gnome without snarling and barking-- I'm afraid its one of THEM.
Scary :[ But tbh what would a garden gnowe do? I don't imagine they could run very fast
-
They don't need to run; they ride plastic flamingos.
-
I once had a plastic heron next to a pond. It was as naff as hell, but it actually stopped the real heron coming to take the fish, which nothing else had managed to do.
-
Our old next door neighbour told us when we came home after a huge road trip that she had watched in total amazement a heron coming and eating half of our koi carp -.-'