THESE FORUMS NOW CLOSED (read only)

Comic Discussion => QUESTIONABLE CONTENT => Topic started by: akronnick on 22 Mar 2009, 22:33

Title: WCT March 23-27
Post by: akronnick on 22 Mar 2009, 22:33
And we're back.

This is my first time for starting the WCT, be gentle.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: celticgeek on 22 Mar 2009, 22:37
Daft Punk Dreams???
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Spoom on 22 Mar 2009, 22:40
I was like, WTF is going on, until that last frame.

I wish my dreams had that much detail (but also weren't as disturbing).
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Kugai on 22 Mar 2009, 22:45
OK, now that we've had the ubiquitous 'Weird Dream' Comic .  .  .  .  .  .
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: raoullefere on 22 Mar 2009, 22:54
Man, this guest strip made me feel like I was sneaking a peek at a Warren magazine in the '70's (Wasn't old enough to buy horror mags). Well, except the Daft Punk CD. It'd have to be an 8-track of Pink Floyd.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Jeff7 on 22 Mar 2009, 23:15
Yes, I think (hope) we've all been there, where it's easier to say, "Nope, no memorable dream last night," than to detail the gore-fest that would likely have me put on some kind of terrorist watchlist, or deported to some place that condones torture just because it's a safer option than therapy.

 :-o
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: maddness on 22 Mar 2009, 23:24
I either don't remember my dreams or they're these huge cinematic productions. I'll tell people my disturbing dreams. I don't care how crazy or gory they are. My favorite recurring dream actually ends with me impaled through the chest and pinned to the ground, diagonal to the floor, while my side is overrun in an epic battle scene. By vampires!
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Lost Coastlines on 22 Mar 2009, 23:33
My favorite dream was the one where I achieved time travel by eating pita bread with bleach on it and stating when in time I wanted to be.  It also involved a trial with the Simpsons in it, and for some reason the identity of Spiderman as Peter Parker was very important to the case.

Then there's the one where I was killed by poisonous river dolphins who broke into my house and hopped around on their tail fins.

Oddly, I don't do drugs.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: akronnick on 22 Mar 2009, 23:37
I had a dream the other night were I was anally fisting my computer keyboard. (don't even ask how that could possibly work)

I stopped looking at porn for a few days after that.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: maddness on 22 Mar 2009, 23:38
When I was a kid I had this one where my father wanted to kill me, with a knife, and he had no face. I ran to my mother for help, but she was now also faceless and knife wielding. I don't remember how it ended, but before it was done everyone in the world was faceless and out to kill me and I was just running for my life.

I had a lot more nightmares as a child. Most of them involving someone or something trying to kill me. Paranoid much?
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Jeff7 on 23 Mar 2009, 00:05
I either don't remember my dreams or they're these huge cinematic productions. I'll tell people my disturbing dreams. I don't care how crazy or gory they are. My favorite recurring dream actually ends with me impaled through the chest and pinned to the ground, diagonal to the floor, while my side is overrun in an epic battle scene. By vampires!
See, my dreams rarely involve people. For a long time, it'd be stupid stuff, like a window opening, or a leaf falling, and that'd be it. Or bees chasing me.
Then after I started at the university, people started popping up in dreams, always trying to kill me.

Then there was a turn, when I'd turn and start killing my pursuers. The disturbing turn happened when I'd just start indiscriminately killing anyone else I'd come across. It got worse still when I started recognizing people, and began killing them, enjoying it in the process, then resurrecting them, and then rekilling them again in various manners.

I'm not at all a violent person in the waking world, but apparently my unconscious mind has some crazed, demonically unsatiated bloodlust.


That's the stuff where it's best not to talk about your dreams to friends.
"Yeah, so in my dream last night, I killed you several times, and tortured you, and in the dream, I liked it. Did you ever really think about how much blood there is in a human?"

Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: AnkhWL on 23 Mar 2009, 00:18
Is there a "plot" (using the term loosely here) to what I'm assuming is Hanner's dream? Or is it just random scenes mashed together? Does the girl (who looks like Faye, tbh) not believe the dark-haired man (who kind of reminds me of Martin) about a murder? And then he kills her for kissing the blonde-haired dude? Is that dude the same as the one who is holding the strange staff?

I have weird dreams anyways that make a hell of a lot less sense. I don't know why I'm trying to figure this out in the first place. Lol.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Soulsynger on 23 Mar 2009, 00:22
It's actually not THAT uncommon to dream about things you've read ...

Personally I don't dream ... but if I did, I'd really have a hard time picturing Hanners reading Büchner's "Woyzeck" ... Oo
It puzzles me, why an already mentally misplaced girl would read up on something like "inner-voice-assisted murder out of envy"...
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Mojo on 23 Mar 2009, 00:23
I only dream in movies.  Best one I ever had was when I dreamed a sequel to the Matrix (it was right after seeing the first movie).
Everyone I've described it to has told me it would have been better than what we actually got, but then that's not a tall order.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Zingoleb on 23 Mar 2009, 00:26
The following error or errors occurred while posting this message:
Warning - while you were reading 4 new replies have been posted. You may wish to review your post.

Holy chocochops.

I don't like to remember my dreams. I had a dream about furries last night. Everywhere. Trying to make me one.

And...I enjoyed it. What the hell? I'm still not sure if that was a nightmare or not.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Soulsynger on 23 Mar 2009, 00:28
Is there a "plot" (using the term loosely here) to what I'm assuming is Hanner's dream?

Its the comic's characters replacing those of Georg Büchner's "Woyzeck" (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Woyzeck), still maintaining the majority of it's plot.
(That is to say, Hanner's dream is about Marten (replacing Woyzeck) murdering Faye (replacing Marie), who cheated on him with Sven (repl. the Tambourmajor) ... )

Funny as hell, if you know about it :D
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: akronnick on 23 Mar 2009, 00:31
I only dream in movies.  Best one I ever had was when I dreamed a sequel to the Matrix (it was right after seeing the first movie).
Everyone I've described it to has told me it would have been better than what we actually got, but then that's not a tall order.

I think the matrix sequels would have been HELLA better if the story from two and three had been combined in one movie.  If they had limited each fight/chase/"action" scene to about four minutes each they could have covered all the narrative ground in about 45 minutes.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: lisavilisa on 23 Mar 2009, 03:52
Is there a "plot" (using the term loosely here) to what I'm assuming is Hanner's dream?

Its the comic's characters replacing those of Georg Büchner's "Woyzeck" (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Woyzeck), still maintaining the majority of it's plot.
(That is to say, Hanner's dream is about Marten (replacing Woyzeck) murdering Faye (replacing Marie), who cheated on him with Sven (repl. the Tambourmajor) ... )

This explains why the comic  creeped me out.  I was disturbed for 2 days after watching that play, and then I think a homeless woman cursed my hometown to drown.  (it didn't).
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Knieps on 23 Mar 2009, 04:10
Woooot! One really awesome Büchner Adaption (screw you Herzog!).
Gave me a big chill the first time I read it, even without notifying that this is actually Woyceck. Second reading, at sixt panel, i was all like: "Hm, who's this guy, looks like a Tambourmajor, but what the hell is he doing in this.... OMFG Büchner!" hehe

GReetz Knieps
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Border Reiver on 23 Mar 2009, 04:54
It may be a wonderful tribute to an obscure story (for most most of us), but I was still going WTF...  And now to wait for our lord and master to give us something tomorrow.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Headwoünd on 23 Mar 2009, 05:17
It's actually not THAT uncommon to dream about things you've read ...

Personally I don't dream ... but if I did, I'd really have a hard time picturing Hanners reading Büchner's "Woyzeck" ... Oo
It puzzles me, why an already mentally misplaced girl would read up on something like "inner-voice-assisted murder out of envy"...

Maybe because she's too lazy to read Crime and Punishment.

Also curse you for beating me to it. Stupid forum was down. =)
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Soulsynger on 23 Mar 2009, 05:27
Maybe because she's too lazy to read Crime and Punishment.

Also curse you for beating me to it. Stupid forum was down. =)
Or maybe she just doesn't know enough Russian ... :D

*gags* I'm cursed! ... next one's yours... Aigh pwomish rrch... *gurgles, dies*
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Conco on 23 Mar 2009, 05:35
hooooly wow

that was an amazing guest strip
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: BeoPuppy on 23 Mar 2009, 06:41
I thought it thoroughly boring. I prefer the regular artist. Can't remember his name, right now.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Shok Xone Studios on 23 Mar 2009, 08:16
I had a dream once I was the new quarterback for the Green Bay Packers. My teammate - who happens to be Hugh Laurie - walks up to me before a play and says, "When you get the ball, throw it to my right." "Your right?" I say. "Yes, it's the only right I've got." So we're in position for the play (but instead of being on the field, we're gathered on the sidelines), and the player hiking me the ball is Mimi from the Drew Carey Show. I call "Hike!" and she half-heartedly dumps the ball on the ground. And then I woke up.

I'm told I need to stop eating Pop-Tarts before bed.

Dreams are fucking weird.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: YokoShippo on 23 Mar 2009, 08:24
Wow... That's really weird. I've also had a dream about being the QB for the Packers with Hugh Laurie on my team. Although I did fall asleep watching House... Actually come to think of it, half the cast of NCIS was on the opposing team.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Orbert on 23 Mar 2009, 10:07
I thought the art work was amazing.  I like seeing Marten, Faye and company all "realistic" looking.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: raoullefere on 23 Mar 2009, 10:15
As did I. It may not have read like it, but my earlier post was a compliment. Warren may have run some schlock stories on occasion, but the art usually took what was in the mainstream comics, held it up by its ear, and delivered repeated blows to the buttocks and scrotum.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Tormuse on 23 Mar 2009, 11:13
And as if today's comic wasn't confusing enough, my web browser stopped loading it part way through, right at the panel with the close-up of Marten's eyes and I thought that was the whole comic!  After struggling for a while to make heads or tails of it, I went to the forums to see if anyone could shed some light on the meaning of the comic and found myself wondering, "Why is everyone here talking about dreams?"  Then I figured it out.  :)
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Thaes on 23 Mar 2009, 11:38
...that was weird.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Shok Xone Studios on 23 Mar 2009, 12:10
Wow... That's really weird. I've also had a dream about being the QB for the Packers with Hugh Laurie on my team. Although I did fall asleep watching House... Actually come to think of it, half the cast of NCIS was on the opposing team.

That's just nuts. Was your Hugh Laurie talking in a British or American accent? (Mine was British)
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Mominator on 23 Mar 2009, 12:46
I thought the art work was amazing.  I like seeing Marten, Faye and company all "realistic" looking.

Yeah, I agree.  It really let me look at the characters to me in a new way.  Was the blond guy Sven?  Didn't look too much like him if it was supposed to be him.  Meh

Moar Jeph!
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: tomselleck69 on 23 Mar 2009, 13:05
Yes that is supposed to be Sven (or 19th century German Sven analogue). He was difficult to draw because the Drum Major is a big brawny guy while Sven is skinny and effeminate, so he came out a bit inconsistent.

MOST IMPORTANTLY though, he isn't blond. The panel where he is leaning against the table just didn't scan very well.

Also thanks, I'm glad many of you seem to like it
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Orbert on 23 Mar 2009, 13:26
I thought it was Sven right away, and I'd never seen or heard of Woyzeck before.  Something about the face looked like Sven; that, and the interraction (such as it is) with Faye.

I think my favorite panel is the last one, where they're hanging out in the apartment, Marten's hand on Dora's leg.  Very natural looking.

But... since I'm not familiar with Woyzeck, who is the guy with the mustache?  His conversation with Marten apparently upsets Marten quite a bit.  I'm guessing that he's the one who tells Marten about Faye "cheating" with Sven.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Hammy on 23 Mar 2009, 13:31
This comic made me happy because I didn't know Lucid TV was still updating. It had gone quiet for a long time, so I stopped checking. But it's going again! Hurray!

Anyone who hasn't read the comic before should give it a go. It is hilarious!
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Soulsynger on 23 Mar 2009, 14:52
But... since I'm not familiar with Woyzeck, who is the guy with the mustache?  His conversation with Marten apparently upsets Marten quite a bit.  I'm guessing that he's the one who tells Marten about Faye "cheating" with Sven.

In the play, Woyzeck is subject to a weird doctor's (or professor's) experiments in order to make some money. The doc sets him on a strict bean diet, disregarding all danger to health and psyche. Thus, Woyzeck hears voices in his head throughout the story and tries to explain his ideas of the "second nature" (the world behind the world, which he believes to be real as he sees it) to the doctor.

The panels show one of those occasions where Woyzeck (Marten) is called to the doctor and examined. In the screenplay, this is one of numerous scenes where Woyzecks obvious inner turmoils and confusions are ignored by the other characters, upsetting him and driving him deeper and deeper down a psychotic breakdown spiral.

The more you look at it, the better the strip gets :D
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: col on 23 Mar 2009, 14:56
Faye is SO hot in that guest strip.

Just thought I should say that.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Orbert on 23 Mar 2009, 15:32
But... since I'm not familiar with Woyzeck, who is the guy with the mustache?  His conversation with Marten apparently upsets Marten quite a bit.  I'm guessing that he's the one who tells Marten about Faye "cheating" with Sven.

In the play, Woyzeck is subject to a weird doctor's (or professor's) experiments in order to make some money. The doc sets him on a strict bean diet, disregarding all danger to health and psyche. Thus, Woyzeck hears voices in his head throughout the story and tries to explain his ideas of the "second nature" (the world behind the world, which he believes to be real as he sees it) to the doctor.

The panels show one of those occasions where Woyzeck (Marten) is called to the doctor and examined. In the screenplay, this is one of numerous scenes where Woyzecks obvious inner turmoils and confusions are ignored by the other characters, upsetting him and driving him deeper and deeper down a psychotic breakdown spiral.

The more you look at it, the better the strip gets :D

That some deep shit there.  Thanks!
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Headwoünd on 23 Mar 2009, 16:08
Yes that is supposed to be Sven (or 19th century German Sven analogue). He was difficult to draw because the Drum Major is a big brawny guy while Sven is skinny and effeminate, so he came out a bit inconsistent.

MOST IMPORTANTLY though, he isn't blond. The panel where he is leaning against the table just didn't scan very well.

Also thanks, I'm glad many of you seem to like it

It rawk'd \o/

Next time do The Sandman (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Der_Sandmann) - just as fucked up and a chance to include Pintsize. :3
Although I wonder if Hannelore would ever sleep again after reading even the first chapter of that thing.

Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: pwhodges on 23 Mar 2009, 16:34
Also thanks, I'm glad many of you seem to like it

And another - good stuff!
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: PHeller on 23 Mar 2009, 16:40
bahaha,

As soon as I type "woy" into Google, it immediately reads my mind...

"I stab you...wait...did I stab you with my Sex Pistol's cd? Lemme look....AH-HA, no, it was Daft Punk! Be damned Daft Punk!"
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: St.Clair on 23 Mar 2009, 17:47
"One More Time!"
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: brandon_ha on 23 Mar 2009, 18:16
Pintsize totally deserved that.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: raoullefere on 23 Mar 2009, 18:19
I think I prefer the original. Who'd've thought Wins could have managed that with his teeny appendages, though?

Truly, rage is an amazing thing.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: akronnick on 23 Mar 2009, 18:41
You would think Winslow would know by now not to take Pintsize's advice vis-a-vis romance.

Final results for monday's poll:

Hangus: 6 votes (10.9%)
Tai-Bird: 3 votes (5.5%)
Svawk: 5 votes (9.1%)
Startern: 5 votes (9.1%)
Fadora: 20 votes (36.4%)
Pint-tits : 16 votes (29.1)

new poll up soon.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Mojo on 23 Mar 2009, 19:33
You know, I don't blame Pintsize, she looks Japanese.  She might very well have liked sushi...
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: plumbob78 on 23 Mar 2009, 19:38
Yeah. That tentacle is tako. For eating...
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: akronnick on 23 Mar 2009, 19:42
Maybe she doesn't have the capability to consume foodstuffs and she's kinda sore about it.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: D on 23 Mar 2009, 20:01
Jeph should have added the alternate as a fifth panel, that would have made it better. This could have been longer-than-usual comics week.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: cory54321 on 23 Mar 2009, 20:15
TENTACLE RAPE!

*cough*
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Mojo on 23 Mar 2009, 20:45
Maybe she doesn't have the capability to consume foodstuffs and she's kinda sore about it.

Something tells me it's Pintsize that's sore. about. it.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Jeff7 on 23 Mar 2009, 21:01
Yes, we've strayed deep into LOLWUT territory with this comic.


TENTACLE RAPE!

*cough*
More precisely, "Tentacoo wape!"
;) :-o

Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: namatad on 23 Mar 2009, 21:29
uncle ghastly would be ever so proud of you
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: RefD on 23 Mar 2009, 21:47
uncle ghastly would be ever so proud of you


i miss that comic.

what's he up to these days?
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: maddness on 23 Mar 2009, 22:05
Boo for Winslow falling for Pintsize's stuff. YAY for Winslow sticking it to Pintsize, literally, in the end, no pun intended.

You would think that Winslow would know better though.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Kugai on 23 Mar 2009, 22:06
Pintsize deserved that.  

And probably enjoyed it.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: TwistedRemedy on 23 Mar 2009, 22:49
Just noticed Faye deleted Sven from her Twitter.

ALSO.
Glad to see that little pink haired... thing again. =]
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: akronnick on 23 Mar 2009, 22:54
Yes, it's probably Splitsville for Svaye, which is good because it clears the way for Fangus.
/ducks behind keyboard.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: ysth on 23 Mar 2009, 23:18
literally, in the end, no pun intended.
You are breaking the rules.  No pun intended.

Glad to see that little pink haired... thing again. =]
When did we see her before?  Does she have a name or existence in some non-QC reality?
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Is it cold in here? on 23 Mar 2009, 23:47
She's a Sony AnthroPC (http://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=1298)
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: bhtooefr on 24 Mar 2009, 00:12
Would've worked better if it was an eel.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: 0kamisama on 24 Mar 2009, 00:58
I always enjoy strips featuring Sony Anthro PC, but does she have a name?

She's so かわいい! お持ち帰り~~!And to everyone who got that reference, おめでとうございます!
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: soniku64 on 24 Mar 2009, 02:38
The following error or errors occurred while posting this message:
Warning - while you were reading 4 new replies have been posted. You may wish to review your post.

Holy chocochops.

I don't like to remember my dreams. I had a dream about furries last night. Everywhere. Trying to make me one.

And...I enjoyed it. What the hell? I'm still not sure if that was a nightmare or not.


Heh heh...



Come to our side Zing....


As for the dream thing. I had ones as kids where I was chased by like Anime Vampires. I also have ones where I take different forms like for example. I would be  a person going on some trip and some kind of School at the same time and like with in the dream I change into like the dog of the person I was. I am always in a RV when I have it and there is a TINY TINY Bathroom in the front (AS IN small for like a gerbil) and I would put my head in the little Theater like door way
THAN I get ported into a new fully ferbished Bathroom big enough for me I cant rember much past that in that dream. Also y dreams sometimes REPEAT then slefs like I would keep doing the bigging of the dream at a certain point. There is also one Dream I have sometimes where I would like be I girl I THINK I never checked :P I just asume I am a girl. But I am slowly changeing into a dog. It isnt as weird now considering I embraced my furry self. But it is still freaky considering I change into a labradore that can talk and no one freaks out badly (As in KILL IT IT IS DISGUSTING). Also Psi snuk into my dreams one way or another. As I can use telekenetics.

I dont do drugs for all who care.

Also I beleve Pintsize desered it and thnik he set it up so that happend because he likes it :P

PS: Psi is real psipog.net (http://psipog.net) I just dont have the skill to do what I do in my dream
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Thaes on 24 Mar 2009, 03:00
So, it turned out to be one of those days where you go "aww" over an Anthro-PC smiling adorably because he has a tentacle inside him. Figures...
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: WhyNot on 24 Mar 2009, 03:31
Maybe little HD just took it the wrong way and the tentacle was meant as a different type of weapon/fetish in addition to the eels that she can shoot from her no-no spot?

*roflself* I actually used "no-no spot" *rofl* I crack me up in my attempts not to be offensive :)


Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Soulsynger on 24 Mar 2009, 04:12
Am I the only one who gets the impression that Pintsize is not entirely disliking his situation?

His mimic shows more of a "Hm... come to think about it."- and "This actually isn't all that bad."-like reaction ... Oo

People, we have our first ANALTHRO-PC!!!!!!!  :-o

(And I am SO okay with being offensive here... "sticking it" to WhyNot is worth it :D)
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Mallli_kite on 24 Mar 2009, 05:57
Mr. Jacques is a very twisted man.  It's a very good thing.

Yeah, I agree with whomever suggested it above -- adding the end to the alternative strip to the main one for 5 panels would have been...sweet.

I must now go wipe the morning beverage off my laptop screen.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: WhyNot on 24 Mar 2009, 06:33
Am I the only one who gets the impression that Pintsize is not entirely disliking his situation?

His mimic shows more of a "Hm... come to think about it."- and "This actually isn't all that bad."-like reaction ... Oo

People, we have our first ANALTHRO-PC!!!!!!!  :-o

(And I am SO okay with being offensive here... "sticking it" to WhyNot is worth it :D)

Analthroat PC?  Oh, you said Analthro..not analthroat.  My bad...."Randall!!! You never go ass to mouth!!!!" or, to keep it all QC-like...."Raven!!!! You never go ass to mouth!"
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: josiah on 24 Mar 2009, 08:19
Its the comic's characters replacing those of Georg Büchner's "Woyzeck" (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Woyzeck), still maintaining the majority of it's plot.
(That is to say, Hanner's dream is about Marten (replacing Woyzeck) murdering Faye (replacing Marie), who cheated on him with Sven (repl. the Tambourmajor) ... )

And here I was thinking of Alban Berg's Wozzeck (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wozzeck) (Based on Büchner's play), but that'd be because I've studied the opera. When Marten is in the lake, I can hear him, in sprechstimme (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sprechstimme), crying out, "Das Wasser ist Blut!"

Marten and Faye don't have a child, so we're lucky: about the most gutwrenching part of the opera (and possibly also the play) is the ending:

Quote
Next morning, children are playing in the sunshine. The news spreads that Marie's body has been found, and they all run off to see, except for Marie's little boy, who after an oblivious moment, follows after the others.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: josiah on 24 Mar 2009, 08:27
Its the comic's characters replacing those of Georg Büchner's "Woyzeck" (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Woyzeck), still maintaining the majority of it's plot.
(That is to say, Hanner's dream is about Marten (replacing Woyzeck) murdering Faye (replacing Marie), who cheated on him with Sven (repl. the Tambourmajor) ... )

And here I was thinking of Alban Berg's Wozzeck (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wozzeck) (Based on Büchner's play), but that'd be because I've studied the opera. When Marten is in the lake, I can hear him, in sprechstimme (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sprechstimme), crying out, "Das Wasser ist Blut!"

Marten and Faye don't have a child, so we're lucky: about the most gutwrenching part of the opera (and possibly also the play) is the ending:

Quote
Next morning, children are playing in the sunshine. The news spreads that Marie's body has been found, and they all run off to see, except for Marie's little boy, who after an oblivious moment, follows after the others.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: TheReaper on 24 Mar 2009, 12:18
Rule 34: Somewhere, in the deep, dark, dank, alliterative recesses of the internet, someone who is into little robots and tentacles is wanking to this comic.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Leeksoup on 24 Mar 2009, 13:39
Maybe little HD just took it the wrong way and the tentacle was meant as a different type of weapon/fetish in addition to the eels that she can shoot from her no-no spot?

*roflself* I actually used "no-no spot" *rofl* I crack me up in my attempts not to be offensive :)




I'm horrible. Everyone else was wondering "a tentacle? wtf?", while I immediately figured Pintsize wanted Sony to demonstrate her... talent.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: imenonelse on 24 Mar 2009, 13:50
Rule 34: Somewhere, in the deep, dark, dank, alliterative recesses of the internet, someone who is into little robots and tentacles is wanking to this comic.


haha. sad, but sick, but true.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: akronnick on 24 Mar 2009, 13:59

We Really need to know more about the ChibiPC, She needs a name and I want to know more about her owner.

Even the linux anthro PC with the neckbeard had a name, even though he preferred not to use it.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: caelae on 24 Mar 2009, 16:17
I always enjoy strips featuring Sony Anthro PC, but does she have a name?

She's so かわいい! お持ち帰り~~!And to everyone who got that reference, おめでとうございます!

Er... she's so cute, I want to take her home?
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: The Joker on 24 Mar 2009, 18:41
Er... she's so cute, I want to take her home?

NOT LIKE THAT PEOPLE

(I got your back caelae)
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Kgummy on 24 Mar 2009, 19:23
For some reason, I think chibiPC actually would have liked to have kept the gift...
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Manix on 24 Mar 2009, 20:10
Rule 34: Somewhere, in the deep, dark, dank, alliterative recesses of the internet, someone who is into little robots and tentacles is wanking to this comic.


STOP JUDGING MEEEEEEE!!!!!!!
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: raoullefere on 24 Mar 2009, 20:38
*Sigh* if we could only find the other one… Just think...

"Psychologically, this is fascinating. Doesn't it make everyone want to lock them in separate rooms and do experiments on them?…Just me, then."
Riley, Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Season V "The Replacement."
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: celticgeek on 24 Mar 2009, 20:56
Of course, Hanners would have an "Untrustworthy Animals" list.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Darke on 24 Mar 2009, 20:59
Hanners' list had me laughing more than anything that's been in QC for years. Brilliant comic.

Although the crosses are totally cheating on her t-shirt. That's just plain unfair.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: TheHappyBerry on 24 Mar 2009, 21:12
I would just like to thank Hannelore for helping to point out that elephants are evil.  Someday they will all get angry, possibly drunk, and trample us all.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: akronnick on 24 Mar 2009, 21:20
Tuesday's Poll Results:

Pint-size should be _____ for this.

congratulated    - 13 (15.9%)
flogged    - 9 (11%)
scolded    - 5 (6.1%)
locked in teh refridgerator    - 10 (12.2%)
duck taped to the wall    - 28 (34.1%)
Fadora    - 17


I just have to say to the 15.9% of you people who voted for "congratulated": You sick Fucks!
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: NeverQuiteGoth on 24 Mar 2009, 21:33
Why aren't Tapirs on the list?
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: akronnick on 24 Mar 2009, 21:53
They're on Page 2.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Kugai on 24 Mar 2009, 21:57
And why arn't Meerkats on there as well??!
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: maddness on 24 Mar 2009, 22:05
Snails win hands down! They are dirty FREAKS!! Evidence: Green Porno: Snails (http://www.sundancechannel.com/greenporno/#/watch-snail)

P.S. Isabella Rosellini should also be on the list.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: debaser on 25 Mar 2009, 00:16
The facial expressions are very good. And I'm liking the varied angles.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: coru on 25 Mar 2009, 00:28
My favorite thing about this comic?  The fact that it has already been referenced on the Great Auks wikipedia page.

And I vote she add 'anything encased in a shell' to her list.  Clams, lobsters...etc....you can't trust things that carry their homes with them.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: maddness on 25 Mar 2009, 00:37
That means turtles make the list. Really they should already be on there. Carry their homes, live a long time and hide their junk in their tail.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: MamiyaOtaru on 25 Mar 2009, 01:20
I can only assume you've seen this (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zDiR7UxI8Ow) then
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: ecstaticjoy on 25 Mar 2009, 01:47
Tentacle porn! Wow, QC has actually been living up to it's name recently.

I like Hanners new shirt.

Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: epitomynut on 25 Mar 2009, 03:42
Am I the only one who gets the impression that Pintsize is not entirely disliking his situation?

His mimic shows more of a "Hm... come to think about it."- and "This actually isn't all that bad."-like reaction ... Oo

People, we have our first ANALTHRO-PC!!!!!!!  :-o

(And I am SO okay with being offensive here... "sticking it" to WhyNot is worth it :D)

Analthroat PC?  Oh, you said Analthro..not analthroat.  My bad...."Randall!!! You never go ass to mouth!!!!" or, to keep it all QC-like...."Raven!!!! You never go ass to mouth!"

Of course Raven doesn't go ass to mouth-she doesn't like anal sex.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Thaes on 25 Mar 2009, 04:22
From now on, I will always call alpacas "smaller, more concealable llamas".

It's a rather popular topic, after all.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: raoullefere on 25 Mar 2009, 04:32
Isabella Rosellini should also be on the list.
*Sigh* How many times do I have to say this: Isabella Rossellini is not an animal! She simply gets along with them really, really well. And makes the occasional freaky movie.

The animals that should be at the top of Hanners' list are Nessie and her cousins Champ, Ogo-Pogo, et al. These fiendishly clever creatures have actually managed to convince the world that they don't even exist, never have existed, and that anyone who does believe in them is a raving loonie, all while frolicing about in broad daylight. Even the Auk hasn't managed that.

I'm telling you, keep believing it's all hooey, and we'll all rue the day, come the Nessie Revolution.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: pwhodges on 25 Mar 2009, 04:35
And the Yeti.  Don't forget the Yeti.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: akronnick on 25 Mar 2009, 04:43
Or Bigfoot, that motherfucker STILL freaks me out.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Shaolin on 25 Mar 2009, 06:39
No need to mention that Hanner's list is hilarious.
I wanted to say, that Hanner's shirt is awesome. Poor o gets cornered.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: maddness on 25 Mar 2009, 06:41
And the other host of cryptos.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Border Reiver on 25 Mar 2009, 08:28
I would add anything hermaphrodic - if the critter can't make up its mind as to gender then how can you trust it to make up its mind on the more important stuff. 
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: MrMonk on 25 Mar 2009, 10:46
I'm surprised that octopodes weren't already on her list.

They're smart, fast and strong.
They can squeeze into tiny spaces.
Their eyes don't have blind spots.
They look like those slavering space creatures from the Simpsons.
Some have frightening sex organs. 
Some may be capable of abstract thought.

And why are they kept in separate tanks?  Obviously to keep them from making plans!
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Mallli_kite on 25 Mar 2009, 11:37
Ooh yea, no octopi!  There was some documentary/show on one of the Discovery channels a few years ago that speculated (with pretty good CGI animation) that octopi are in line to take over after the primates, or could have risen to become the dominant species had certain conditions changed.  They could have become air breathing, tree swinging KINGS of the UNIVERSE. 

Also, Jeph did the shoulder/hip ratio thing with Marten again so that -- EVEN WHILE HOLDING A TENTACLE -- I thought "wow, Marten's hot".  I try to keep tentacles out of my world as much as possible.  I'm still suffering from exposure to a particular anime of tentacle porn many years ago.  NO TENTAKLEES!

Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: akronnick on 25 Mar 2009, 20:34
Well I for one welcome our new Eight-legged Overlords
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: altered_carbon on 25 Mar 2009, 22:16
Wow, that's the first time I've really felt the indie in this comic in a while...Damn that's a forced hipster conversation if I've never heard one.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: maddness on 25 Mar 2009, 22:40
I'm guessing Jeph's comment had something to do with cold medication.

In other news POSSUMS!!
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Kugai on 25 Mar 2009, 23:36
Well, if she does it in the forest. at least no-one will have to clean up the blood

Possums make good socks.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: akronnick on 25 Mar 2009, 23:52
Wednesdays Poll Results:

     Other animals that can't be trusted:
Ground Hogs    - 7 (13.5%)
Snails    - 8 (15.4%)
Zebras    - 4 (7.7%)
Toasters    - 6 (11.5%)
very small rocks    - 17 (32.7%)
Fadora    - 10 (19.2%)

I see we have quite a few Python fans here.

As for today's comic, can it be that Faye is beginning to actually tolerate Angus' presence?
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Sebastian on 26 Mar 2009, 01:32
Well I for one welcome our new Eight-legged Overlords

Actually those are spiders, octopi are are more eight-armed.

Or you could go with eight-limbed, just to stay on the safe side.  :-D
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: rudyhenkel on 26 Mar 2009, 01:47
Well I for one welcome our new Eight-legged Overlords

Actually those are spiders, octopi are are more eight-armed.

Or you could go with eight-limbed, just to stay on the safe side.  :-D

They have, effectively, two legs and six arms:

http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/environment/article4517779.ece


In other news, Angus is really growing on me.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Soulsynger on 26 Mar 2009, 02:59
Nr. 1368 (http://questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=1368) ...

Holy three holies! Are they flirting?!?!?!  :-o
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Border Reiver on 26 Mar 2009, 04:49
Possibly, or it could just be a conversation.  In any event, it was a nice comicwith not disturbing mental images.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Mallli_kite on 26 Mar 2009, 05:37
Possibly, or it could just be a conversation.  In any event, it was a nice comicwith not disturbing mental images.

Ugly sweater strangling and possum gnawing don't disturb you?


Um...
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: moogoob on 26 Mar 2009, 05:48
Blood Party: the newest single by Dethklok?
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Border Reiver on 26 Mar 2009, 07:35
Possibly, or it could just be a conversation.  In any event, it was a nice comicwith not disturbing mental images.


Ugly sweater strangling and possum gnawing don't disturb you?


Um...

Not nearly as much as the Manga prediliction for big eyed school girl/women, short skirts and tentacles going into places where they just should not be going. 
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: sitnspin on 26 Mar 2009, 09:24
Considering my fetish leanings, I think a Blood Party would be awesome
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Tago Mago on 26 Mar 2009, 09:44
Wow, that's the first time I've really felt the indie in this comic in a while...Damn that's a forced hipster conversation if I've never heard one.
True. Not knowing what's on one's T-shirt but looking down and discovering it to be really cool must be the epitome of indie.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Mallli_kite on 26 Mar 2009, 10:42

Not nearly as much as the Manga prediliction for big eyed school girl/women, short skirts and tentacles going into places where they just should not be going. 

You have a point.  Still...ugly sweaters....gah!
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: UTAlan on 26 Mar 2009, 12:04
Considering my fetish leanings, I think a Blood Party would be awesome

That's...disturbing.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: championofkhorne on 26 Mar 2009, 12:22
Blood Party is a bad Superbad reference
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: imonfire on 26 Mar 2009, 13:42
ooo Faye used a contraction, we all know that's like fourplay for her.  It's so going to happen.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: championofkhorne on 26 Mar 2009, 13:51
either that or she is drunk
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: syshonblast on 26 Mar 2009, 14:42
either that or she's talking LIKE SHE NORMALLY SPEAKS NOW GET YOUR HEAD OUT OF THE ARCHIVES thanks...:D
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Milesb on 26 Mar 2009, 18:07
she's enjoying speaking to a guy who hasnt hurt her, isnt out of bounds due to her own rules and/or tastes or circumstances.

woo. doesnt mean she's gonna jump his bones. we'll need an actual plot arc to justify that one I think.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: moshimoshi_haihai on 26 Mar 2009, 19:20
I'm assuming that because he was a lost character and came back conveniently after a breakup was enough to at least start wondering...
or...hoping, anyway.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Is it cold in here? on 26 Mar 2009, 20:21
If Angus and Faye only end up being Just Friends, it will still be good for her. She has too narrow a social circle.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: akronnick on 26 Mar 2009, 21:02
Thursday's Poll Results:

Fangus?!?!?!?!
HOORAY!!!!!1!!!!11!    - 4 (8.2%)
I can see it.    - 19 (38.8%)
Meh.    - 9 (18.4%)
Not gonna happen.    - 4 (8.2%)
OH HELL NO, Over my dead body.    - 3 (6.1%)
Fadora    - 10 (20.4%)

Denied!!!!

Or was he.

Was he really about to ask Faye out, or was she just hoping he'd ask her out.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Shadic on 26 Mar 2009, 21:05
I actually voted Hooray right before it ended.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: akronnick on 26 Mar 2009, 21:14
Do I need to amend the totals or is 4 the correct total?

(I'm not actually going to change anything, you'll just have to live with the fact that your vote was meaningless, pretend like you live in Florida)
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: bhtooefr on 26 Mar 2009, 21:22
You forgot to reset the totals.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: akronnick on 26 Mar 2009, 21:24
Thank you, totals reset, please re-vote.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: maddness on 26 Mar 2009, 21:40
I think that the nice human moment they were having prior to the misunderstanding made her feel like maybe she gave him the wrong idea so, instead of slamming him as she has in the past, she tried to head him off in an kind, honest manner. I also think that she has grown some and so isn't as quick to stomp all over him just because she finds him attractive.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: akronnick on 26 Mar 2009, 21:45
... instead of slamming him as she has in the past, she tried to head him off in an kind, honest manner.

For Faye that would be an improvemant.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: cory54321 on 26 Mar 2009, 21:51
All I have to say about this comic is...

D'AWWWWWWW.  :laugh:
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: altered_carbon on 26 Mar 2009, 21:59
I officially board the Fangus ship after this one.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: raoullefere on 26 Mar 2009, 22:45
Housemate, from offpanel: "Hmmmm...Angus never asks for a second cup at home!"

Any other geezers on here who survived the seventies remember that line (and assorted variations)? Damned if I can remember the brand of coffee it plugged.

So Faye's actually having, and apparently enjoying, a conversation with Angus, since time slipped away from her. Makes you go, well, you know.

ooo Faye used a contraction, we all know that's like fourplay for her.  It's so going to happen.
I don't think that's true, but I do think it's a brilliant line.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: celticgeek on 26 Mar 2009, 22:53
Folgers Coffee.

Discussion (http://www.treppenwitz.com/2004/09/funny_he_never_.html)

They also did a number on this in Airplane.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: akronnick on 26 Mar 2009, 23:08
We've secretly replaced Faye's regular biting sarcasm and Angus's normal masochism with wit, charm, and pleasant conversation, let's see if they notice...
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Lulaloli on 27 Mar 2009, 00:00
What the hell is up with Angus's arm in the last panel? His hand, wrist, and 3/4 of his forearm have been replaced with a coffee cup.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Soulsynger on 27 Mar 2009, 00:51
What the hell is up with Angus's arm in the last panel? His hand, wrist, and 3/4 of his forearm have been replaced with a coffee cup.
Actually, his forearm IS a coffee mug. It expands when full of coffee and contracts when getting empty. It's like a coffee-controlled crane-like extension of his desire for Faye and her beans ... of coffee Oo


@Faye:
Hah! I love a good trainwreck... especially Faye's since they are so damn out of character in some way :D
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: ecstaticjoy on 27 Mar 2009, 03:23
yeah!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I love it! :laugh: :laugh: :laugh:
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: raoullefere on 27 Mar 2009, 03:48
Soulsynger, ah. I don't know how to put this, but, okay: the only way Faye's going to get better is to get out of character. As for Angus being out of character, break-ups do sometimes show one where they went wrong.

Thanks, Celticgeek. I'd forgotten about that wretch Olsen, pusher for the old Columbian Cartel (caffeine instead of cocaine, and they lived in the U.S.) being in on things. I do remember the take-off on Airplane!, though: still perhaps the greatest film ever made. It helped form my rather bizarre sense of humor, paving the way for my Terry Pratchett mania. Mr. P owes ZAZ (Bros. Zucker + Mr. Abrahams) a debt, too, methinks.

And don't call me 'Shirly.'

Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Heranje on 27 Mar 2009, 05:23
I'm beginning to like the Faye-Angus dynamic, and I definitely could see them together, but I doubt it will happen right away - it's too soon after the whole Sven debacle. Like Faye said, she doesn't want a relationship just now.

Though of course, the Lord Jeph works in mysterious ways.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Border Reiver on 27 Mar 2009, 05:35
Rauolefrere you are so wrong - there are two movies tied for the honour of greatest movie of all time, and Airlplane! isn't one of them.  The Blues Brothers, and The Dirty Dozen
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Blayze on 27 Mar 2009, 06:07
The Blues Brothers is no more a candidate for the greatest movie of all time than I am for the position of Pope.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Milesb on 27 Mar 2009, 06:22
are we going to have a historical recreation of the pope wars in here?

All hail discordia!

(on topic..)

Faye is cute, but i'd be a bit put off if they develop in a relationship too quickly - most of the relationships in QC have had a reasonable-ish amount of foreshadowing. Their previous verbal sparring was rather impersonal i'd say, so I'm not really thinking it'd count as character development between the two...
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Hitch-Hiker on 27 Mar 2009, 08:41
Housemate, from offpanel: "Hmmmm...Angus never asks for a second cup at home!"

Any other geezers on here who survived the seventies remember that line (and assorted variations)? Damned if I can remember the brand of coffee it plugged.

So Faye's actually having, and apparently enjoying, a conversation with Angus, since time slipped away from her. Makes you go, well, you know.

ooo Faye used a contraction, we all know that's like fourplay for her.  It's so going to happen.
I don't think that's true, but I do think it's a brilliant line.


Excellent Airplane reference.
I enjoyed todays comic very much. Nice to see Faye not reacting violently, although that was always funny  :lol:
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Shadic on 27 Mar 2009, 11:29
(I'm not actually going to change anything, you'll just have to live with the fact that your vote was meaningless, pretend like you live in Florida)

But I actually voted correctly! And besides, we all know Florida fucks up everything and is only full of old people.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: The Joker on 27 Mar 2009, 14:17
Rauolefrere you are so wrong - there are two movies tied for the honour of greatest movie of all time, and Airlplane! isn't one of them.  The Blues Brothers, and The Dirty Dozen

I say Airplane! and the Dark Knight.

jk (sorta)
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Is it cold in here? on 27 Mar 2009, 15:33
most of the relationships in QC have had a reasonable-ish amount of foreshadowing. Their previous verbal sparring was rather impersonal i'd say, so I'm not really thinking it'd count as character development between the two...
It's debatable, but there are some things that might count as foreshadowing.

Faye calls Angus "hot" in 808, and in 1144 Angus is the first person Faye thinks of when Hannelore mentions "other boys".
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Milesb on 27 Mar 2009, 15:48
true dat, he is her only potential love interest within the confines of the current characters..
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Kugai on 27 Mar 2009, 22:50
Rauolefrere you are so wrong - there are two movies tied for the honour of greatest movie of all time, and Airlplane! isn't one of them.  The Blues Brothers, and The Dirty Dozen

I say Airplane! and the Dark Knight.

jk (sorta)

Surely you can't be serious?


Nice save there Faye.  I think that Angus is actually growing on her.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: akronnick on 28 Mar 2009, 05:38
He is Surely, and don't call him Sirius, err...or something
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Kugai on 28 Mar 2009, 16:06
He is Surely, and don't call him Sirius, err...or something

I think the line you're looking for is

"I am serious, and don't call me Shirley!"
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: MamiyaOtaru on 28 Mar 2009, 16:53
I'm surprised that octopodes weren't already on her list.

I'm late, but 'grats on using the correct plural.  The non-obviousness of it (octopi is wrong, period) is why I encourage people to just stick to the standard English plural formation and say "octopuses".  If you don't speak Latin or Greek, don't pretend you do.  Just go with the flow and speak English.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: pwhodges on 28 Mar 2009, 17:21
I follow Fowler, who as long ago as the 1920s wrote, in Modern English Usage:

Quote
the only acceptable plural in English is octopuses

and went on to say that [as we know] octopi is misconceived and octopodes pedantic.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: akronnick on 28 Mar 2009, 18:57
I think the line you're looking for is

"I am serious, and don't call me Shirley!"

That's the one!
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Headwoünd on 29 Mar 2009, 05:19
I follow Fowler, who as long ago as the 1920s wrote, in Modern English Usage:

Quote
the only acceptable plural in English is octopuses

and went on to say that [as we know] octopi is misconceived and octopodes pedantic.

1920? Languages are always moving, changing, influencing each other and being "violated" until a violation is common enough to pass as the "correct" use of the language. Not a single person on the whole planet is speaking "the correct English of 1920" any more. Screw Fowler. :D

Couldn't care less if anyone said octopuses, octopodes or octopi. In each case I know that someone refers to more than one octopus. I prefer octopussies anyways.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: pwhodges on 29 Mar 2009, 07:14
The point is not that we should speak as in 1920, but that anyone suggesting octopodes as the plural these days is already nearly a century behind the changes in the language which are, as you say, inevitable.

Change happens all the time, of course, but in language there is also the opposing tension that any change which reduces mutual understanding between communities using ostensibly the same language is not so good, and so should perhaps be moderated somewhat.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Mallli_kite on 29 Mar 2009, 11:59
Octopi is good enough for Websters.

http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/octopus

Usually that's good enough.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: pwhodges on 29 Mar 2009, 12:31
Remember, dictionaries do not primarily suggest usage, they report it.
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Monkey Says Yes on 29 Mar 2009, 21:16
Ha!  Descriptive, not prescriptive.  I always love the Nero Wolfe mysteries when Wolfe rips out pages from the latest dictionary and tosses them in the fire, deriding the editors as fools.

So when do Angus and Sven get together to kvetch about Faye?
Title: Re: WCT March 23-27
Post by: Rocketman on 29 Mar 2009, 22:42
I would read Jimbo's book.