THESE FORUMS NOW CLOSED (read only)

Comic Discussion => QUESTIONABLE CONTENT => Topic started by: Kugai on 03 Nov 2013, 12:01

Title: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Kugai on 03 Nov 2013, 12:01
Have at ye!!!!!!
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: LookingIn on 03 Nov 2013, 12:51
Last week was just begging of a Pintsize inuendo, pun, and blatant dirty joke- and all in the same panel  :-D
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: GarandMarine on 03 Nov 2013, 13:12
I would pay MONEY to see a Marine in the comic. I'd pay even more money if she dated Marty, the sheer potential for lulz is astronomic!
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Barmymoo on 03 Nov 2013, 13:34
I'd assume that would depend on Jeph knowing some Marines well enough to be able to write them convincingly. I have no idea whether he does or not, but I personally wouldn't be able to write a character who was a Marine as I have only the faintest idea what it involves.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: GarandMarine on 03 Nov 2013, 14:31
Yeah no I figure if such a female character does pop up she'd be more generic military then something specific.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: RightInTheSquishyParts on 03 Nov 2013, 14:32
Perhaps Air Force...   :-P
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: pwhodges on 03 Nov 2013, 14:39
We've already had Lt. Potter, so I'd say Jeph's unlikely to do anything that similar.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: westrim on 03 Nov 2013, 14:41
Dale walks into Marigold in the shower, lip locks her, and asks her to join him in the Alliance. Then he steps in and the last panel is a closed curtain.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Tulpa on 03 Nov 2013, 14:51
No, there's a couple panels after that that you forgot. Every couple in towels sitting around eating cookies in different places. Every couple. Then the last panel is marten looking sad while eating a cookie.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: cesium133 on 03 Nov 2013, 14:52
Or Marten eating cookies while Pintsize shorts himself out eating raw cookie dough.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Tulpa on 03 Nov 2013, 15:15
I thought pintsize could eat food now.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: cesium133 on 03 Nov 2013, 15:18
I thought pintsize could eat food now.
Yeah, but he needs to use the bathroom shortly afterward (http://questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=212).
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Tulpa on 03 Nov 2013, 16:13
So it just destroys the couch. Doesn't hurt him.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Is it cold in here? on 03 Nov 2013, 17:09
Perhaps Air Force...   :-P

I've wondered. She must have some leave accrued. She's on OK terms with Hannelore. A visit is not impossible. Jeph would probably have more fun inventing a new character, though.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Zebediah on 03 Nov 2013, 17:25
It was pretty well established the first time around that Lt. Potter wasn't interested in Marten (http://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2154).

Yeah, I know, that could change. She could suddenly develop a fetish for skinny indie boys. But she probably won't.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Is it cold in here? on 03 Nov 2013, 17:55
Marten probably won't start working out either. But it might do him good if his roommate pushes him into it.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: FunkyTuba on 03 Nov 2013, 18:24
still think we're overdue for a Hanners debrief, with added squeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: GarandMarine on 03 Nov 2013, 19:22
I'm just saying Marten had a shot while they were in 0G. Even a skinny indy rock lad can bench a lady in null grav!
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: mustang6172 on 03 Nov 2013, 19:43
I haven't given up on a return of Padma.

I hope Emily changed that fruit everyday.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Rghfrgl on 03 Nov 2013, 19:55
Claire is a bad influence.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: GarandMarine on 03 Nov 2013, 19:58
Claire and Marten may have been spending a little too much time together.

If they do start dating they will immediately be That Couple.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: LookingIn on 03 Nov 2013, 20:10
Momo doesn't hold back her sarcasm...no wonder she and Marten are so great together at the library  :-D
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Method of Madness on 03 Nov 2013, 20:20
Marten, is that even a pun?
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Tova on 03 Nov 2013, 20:32
Marten, is that even a pun?

*cough* I've seen worse.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Method of Madness on 03 Nov 2013, 20:32
What Marten should have said was "that relationship sure didn't last berry long".
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: westrim on 03 Nov 2013, 20:43
If you break up with Emily due to weirdness, you didn't observe very much before entering the relationship.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Method of Madness on 03 Nov 2013, 20:45
Yeah, I can't imagine she wasn't weird before you started dating her.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: LookingIn on 03 Nov 2013, 20:46
If you break up with Emily due to weirdness, you didn't think very much before entering the relationship.

Can't really blame him for getting annoyed at the weirdness, fruit flies get annoying after a while
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Is it cold in here? on 03 Nov 2013, 20:59
Marten should just give up making puns (http://questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=316).
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Method of Madness on 03 Nov 2013, 21:00
But that was a good pun! I object more to his panel 4.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Near Lurker on 03 Nov 2013, 21:02
Lady Gaga?  The caliber of the titles may be dropping...
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Method of Madness on 03 Nov 2013, 21:11
Ha, I hadn't even noticed the title. Eh, it's applicable here.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Jazzmaster on 03 Nov 2013, 21:49
I think Marten missed mutual awkwardness.  Mutual.  Keyword.

Yes, he has managed to "kiss some ladies", but in Dora's case, she kissed him first.  She wasn't "awkward" about it at all.  As far as Padma goes, he sort of just stumbled into that.

Now, if both parties are awkward and sheepish, it's between a rock and a hard place.  I mean, who's going to initiate first, if both of them seem "afraid" of each other?

By the way, I hope this post doesn't cross the line for "shipping" - just commenting on the dialogue in today's comic.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Method of Madness on 03 Nov 2013, 21:59
You don't think Padma was awkward?
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Carl-E on 03 Nov 2013, 22:05
Padma was oblivious, it's not the same thing as awkward. 


Has a lot of the same results, though. 
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: FunkyTuba on 03 Nov 2013, 22:09
Marten doesn't know what a meta is for
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Arancaytar on 03 Nov 2013, 23:05
That one was Claire-worthy.

Though at least Claire doesn't try to explain; she just grins and stares at you until you get it.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: westrim on 03 Nov 2013, 23:06
Mutual awkwardness tends to lead to mutual lack of progress absent a significant outside modifier to at least one of their mental states. I'm told that alcohol is one of these modifiers.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Method of Madness on 03 Nov 2013, 23:10
Though at least Claire doesn't try to explain; she just grins and stares at you until you get it.
See, if Marten had done that with his Meta-Fayesical line, it would've been forgivable.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Carl-E on 04 Nov 2013, 00:31
Only if you're in a very forgiving mood. 
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Black Sword on 04 Nov 2013, 06:19
And the first zing of November goes to Momo!
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Zebediah on 04 Nov 2013, 07:00
If you break up with Emily due to weirdness, you didn't observe very much before entering the relationship.

Well, it's possible that the guy thought the weirdness would be fun and refreshing. Which it might be, for a while. But then he realized that the weirdness wasn't just a veneer but was actually the core of Emily's being.

At least this clarifies one thing about Emily. Until now I had competing theories. One was that she was romantically inexperienced, which is obviously the correct one. The other was that she was as promiscuous as Raven and simply didn't make any connection between emotional attachment and sex, and was obliviously leaving a trail of heartbroken young men in the wake of her numerous one-night stands.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: TheBiscuit on 04 Nov 2013, 09:38
Yes, he has managed to "kiss some ladies", but in Dora's case, she kissed him first.  She wasn't "awkward" about it at all.  As far as Padma goes, he sort of just stumbled into that.
It seems likely he had "kissed some ladies" before that too. I don't recall anything in the Dora arc (which admittedly I try to repress) about how it was his first time or anything.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Method of Madness on 04 Nov 2013, 11:27
Well he had a girlfriend in college. Also we know he lost his virginity in a tiny car.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Skewbrow on 04 Nov 2013, 11:34
Quote from: Sir Paul McCartney
I used to think anyone doing anything weird was weird. Now I know that it is the people that call others weird that are weird.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Method of Madness on 04 Nov 2013, 12:46
So by that logic, Sir Paul is calling himself weird as well.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Sidhekin on 04 Nov 2013, 13:01
I think he's saying he used to be weird.

/me used to say he was weird, but somewhere along the line kicked the bragging habit, so reserves that bit of info for special occasions.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Kugai on 04 Nov 2013, 13:05
And you are surprised by this how MoM?


And Marten looses the fruits of his verbal labours.   ;D
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Thrudd on 04 Nov 2013, 13:30
Her is a bit of a tanget or is that right field ... anyhow, what about MAY. Where is she at the moment?
The little furlough where she played the part of a virtual companion in a Beta test case, to work off her little misdeed may still be an ongoing concern.
Since she has been established as having bad impulse control, she may have volunteered for something even more risky / embarrassing / deeper hole to dig herself into.

My idea, due to amazing quantities of concentrated sugars, caffeine and fatigue, was maybe she gets to test out a new companion chases for Beta testing.
Something with a more "Human Feel" from the inside.
Think about if you will, totally cut off from the outside world except for on board sensory systems and a watchdog AI that only she can see.
And to top it off she is unable to communicate that she is an AI.
Mayhem, angst and shenanigans ensue.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Method of Madness on 04 Nov 2013, 13:39
I think he's saying he used to be weird.
He's calling other people weird for calling other people weird, therefore he is calling himself weird.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Kugai on 04 Nov 2013, 14:03
That's weird.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Method of Madness on 04 Nov 2013, 14:17
Maybe his point is we're all weird.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Zebediah on 04 Nov 2013, 14:36
Exactly. Everyone is weird in one way or another. So if you're not weird, that's really weird.  :psyduck:
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Method of Madness on 04 Nov 2013, 14:43
See, I don't agree with that. But if you're not weird, then you're probably just boring, which is much worse.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Barmymoo on 04 Nov 2013, 14:45
Argh, I'm stuck in a perpetual feedback loop!
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Method of Madness on 04 Nov 2013, 15:16
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: jwhouk on 04 Nov 2013, 16:10
Argh, I'm stuck in a perpetual feedback loop!

No, I think that was more up George's alley... (http://www.albinoblacksheep.com/flash/ifeelfine)
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Is it cold in here? on 04 Nov 2013, 17:05
If May is put to work as a tailor, now that would be mayhem.

Marten had several previous girlfriends, which was the subject of an insecurity breakdown by Dora.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Kugai on 04 Nov 2013, 17:29
Argh, I'm stuck in a perpetual feedback loop!

At least it's not a temporal one.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Zebediah on 04 Nov 2013, 18:22
Please, no. This is not Voyager.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: cesium133 on 04 Nov 2013, 18:29
Argh, I'm stuck in a perpetual feedback loop!

At least it's not a temporal one.
"I've got you, babe"  :roll:
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: GarandMarine on 04 Nov 2013, 19:31
I sense the Fell Hand of Marten-mom at play in this 13th Birthday Party incident.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Carl-E on 04 Nov 2013, 20:23
I see her associates and friends. 


Especially the strippers. 
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: LookingIn on 04 Nov 2013, 20:29
I sense the Fell Hand of Marten-mom at play in this 13th Birthday Party incident.

Who wouldn't enjoy a rousing game of "spin the dildo"  :lol:
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: cesium133 on 04 Nov 2013, 20:32
It's unclear how many of those 27 were girls... (too tired to look up the comic, I'm sure someone else will)

Also, is the typeface in this comic different than usual?
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Spiritz on 04 Nov 2013, 20:42
It's unclear how many of those 27 were girls... (too tired to look up the comic, I'm sure someone else will)

Also, is the typeface in this comic different than usual?

Well, Marten had 5 girlfriends before Dora (or was it 4?).  Assuming 5+Dora & Padma, that would be 7.  That would be 20 other girls.  If those girls have any connection with Marten's mom, potentially 2/3 of them would actually be guys, leaving 6-7 girls.  In this case, Marten would have 13-14 girls to 13-14 guys.  Oh wait.. Steve counts.  14-15 guys.

I find trying to figure this out fascinating...  :psyduck:
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Near Lurker on 04 Nov 2013, 21:15
Emily did ask how many girls.  So presumably all twenty-seven girls were girls.  There may have also been an indeterminate, possibly three-figure number of guys.  (At least one, of course.)
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: J on 04 Nov 2013, 21:22
or at least girls, as far as he knows
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Method of Madness on 04 Nov 2013, 22:11
I'm honestly not sure how many girls I've kissed and it's nowhere near 27, so good memory, Marten.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: ZoeB on 05 Nov 2013, 02:18
I sense the Fell Hand of Marten-mom at play in this 13th Birthday Party incident.
That had never occurred to me. I'm not sure I want to go there.

OTOH you can go too far in the other direction. I'd never been kissed till after my 21st birthday party (incidentally, the second and last birthday party I've ever had).
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Toe on 05 Nov 2013, 02:37
Also, is the typeface in this comic different than usual?

Yep. Can't say I'm too fond of it.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: pwhodges on 05 Nov 2013, 03:39
Looks to me like the same font, but with the anti-aliasing done different.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: WAYF on 05 Nov 2013, 05:18
Yeah, I'm much closer to the Emily side of the spectrum than the Marten side in this case. :P
And by that I mean... well... exactly two.

Still, I guess I find Emily a little bit more relatable now.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Method of Madness on 05 Nov 2013, 06:00
Zoe, that's not terrible. I was 20.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: pwhodges on 05 Nov 2013, 06:06
Same here.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: hobo386 on 05 Nov 2013, 06:12
1)I get the feeling that Emily likes Marten (not saying it's gonna happen or trying to ship them) and this is her awkward way of showing she's interested.

2)It might just be perspective playing tricks on me, but it feels like Emily is getting taller (or is Marten getting shorter?) every time I see them.

3)I'm not really surprised by either number. Some people get a little sloppy while drunk, though in Marten's case it seems there was another reason, and in Emily's case I'd imagine the awkward+qurirky+super-tall scared off a lot of boys in high-school (and still does).
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Neko_Ali on 05 Nov 2013, 06:27
Ummm... I have to say, I am getting rather uncomfortable as to how many people are playing the 'how many of the girls that Marten has kissed are actually guys' questions here. Emily want to know how many girls Marten had kissed. Marten said they were girls. That means they were girls. If he meant different, he would have said different. If they were trans women, they were girls. If they were drag queens in drag at the time, still referred to as girls.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: ankhtahr on 05 Nov 2013, 06:35
Well. I'm more on the Emily side of the spectrum as well. But she's off by two.

yay me.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: GarandMarine on 05 Nov 2013, 06:47
You guys kinda make me feel like a man whore.... >.>;

I have kissed many pretty ladies on the mouth, and had... uh... 10-12 girlfriends... at least... stupid concussions.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Game and Watch Forever on 05 Nov 2013, 07:17
Ummm... I have to say, I am getting rather uncomfortable as to how many people are playing the 'how many of the girls that Marten has kissed are actually guys' questions here. Emily want to know how many girls Marten had kissed. Marten said they were girls. That means they were girls. If he meant different, he would have said different. If they were trans women, they were girls. If they were drag queens in drag at the time, still referred to as girls.

I have to agree. I mean, I suppose any of the individuals he kissed could have identified as something other than a woman and he may not have known, but I highly doubt that's even close to the meaning we're meant to walk away with. It also leaves room for saying someone was deliberately dishonest about their gender for the purpose of getting a kiss from a man and that is NOT an acceptable message, period.

EDIT: Just to be clear, I don't think anyone was actually thinking or intending that last bit of what I said. I was just giving a reason why I felt that line of conversation may not be something we want to continue.

Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Emperor Norton on 05 Nov 2013, 07:41
I feel kind of bad that I wouldn't even be able to answer the question. Closer to Marten's side though than Emily's.

Like, I should probably remember that shouldn't I? But I just start going through my female friends going "have I kissed her? I can't remember? Oh yeah, that one time at that one party... how about this one... uh... maybe?"
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: cesium133 on 05 Nov 2013, 08:17
Well, since we're all sharing... I'm definitely closer to Emily's side than Marten's. I had a girlfriend in high school that I kissed, and that's about it. To make it worse, we never actually kissed until after we had been dating for about six months. I was afraid to make the first move, and it turned out she wasn't really that interested...

edit -- I've been reading through the archives of Dumbing of Age recently, and just realized that Amber and Ethan are like a reversed-gender analogy to me and the girlfriend I had in high school.  :psyduck:
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Zebediah on 05 Nov 2013, 08:33
Hmm. I don't really know how many women I've kissed. Somewhere around Marten's number, but I can't give a precise count.

I can say with certainty how many women I've kissed in the last 10 years, because it's 1. As for how many times I've kissed her in those years... Hell, it's got to be well in excess of 10,000 by now.  :-D
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Is it cold in here? on 05 Nov 2013, 10:40
Ummm... I have to say, I am getting rather uncomfortable as to how many people are playing the 'how many of the girls that Marten has kissed are actually guys' questions here. Emily want to know how many girls Marten had kissed. Marten said they were girls. That means they were girls. If he meant different, he would have said different. If they were trans women, they were girls. If they were drag queens in drag at the time, still referred to as girls.

I have to agree. I mean, I suppose any of the individuals he kissed could have identified as something other than a woman and he may not have known, but I highly doubt that's even close to the meaning we're meant to walk away with. It also leaves room for saying someone was deliberately dishonest about their gender for the purpose of getting a kiss from a man and that is NOT an acceptable message, period.

EDIT: Just to be clear, I don't think anyone was actually thinking or intending that last bit of what I said. I was just giving a reason why I felt that line of conversation may not be something we want to continue.

That is a worthwhile reminder.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: KOK on 05 Nov 2013, 10:46

2)It might just be perspective playing tricks on me, but it feels like Emily is getting taller (or is Marten getting shorter?) every time I see them.
imagine the awkward+qurirky+super-tall scared off a lot of boys in high-school (and still does).

Emily's eyebrows are about level with the top of Marten's head in 2569, 2203 and 2207.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Game and Watch Forever on 05 Nov 2013, 11:35
That may be my new favorite way of measuring and comparing people's heights now...
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Nepiophage on 05 Nov 2013, 13:11
How many peoplw have noticed that "kissed" is spelt with three s's in the last panel?
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: ankhtahr on 05 Nov 2013, 13:34
I did. A few minutes ago, when I checked the size of Emily and Marten, because of the other posts.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: YourEvilExGirlfriend on 05 Nov 2013, 16:56
I'm kind of surprised that Marten bothered to keep track? 27 is a pretty high and specific number of different ladies to have kissed. I figured most people would lose count after the first ten or twelve unless  each of those kisses actually meant something.  After an x number of drunken/joke-y kisses, those kinds of things tend to bleed into one another.

Then again, maybe he kept a tally of it somewhere. Or he had a standing count of how many girls ended up smooching him on his thirteenth birthday.  :roll:





Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: GarandMarine on 05 Nov 2013, 17:07
Or it was a scaring experience with his dominatrix mother which got burned into his pre-teen brain.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Kugai on 05 Nov 2013, 17:30
Definitely sounds like it was an ..... interesting Birthday Party.

But with Veronica as a mother, whaddaya expect??!



Emily interested in Marten?  Hmmmmm

Interesting to say the least.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: GarandMarine on 05 Nov 2013, 18:08
I dunno if Emily's interested. I can see Jeph teasing it just to mess with the Marten x Claire fans though (the missus included from what I recall)
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: LookingIn on 05 Nov 2013, 18:16
I think she is being friendly with him, it's in line with the discussion and she seems to actually be interested for the sake of being interested rather than for romantic interests.

Unless I am off she so far has never really seemed to have any romantic interest in anyone in the group, she just seems to want to be friends...and given her awkwardness she probably doesn't have many if any friends.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: YourEvilExGirlfriend on 05 Nov 2013, 18:32
Yeah, I don't think Emily is interested in Marten either.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: celticgeek on 05 Nov 2013, 18:34
Yeah, but that's exactly what an evil exgirlfriend would say.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Neko_Ali on 05 Nov 2013, 18:35
Well Emily pretty much expressly doesn't have friends outside of the comic's circle of people. When she invited everyone to the lake party, she said as much. Marten asked when the rest of Emily's friends were coming... and the only one she invited were the people from the library and anyone they wanted to invite along.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: RightInTheSquishyParts on 05 Nov 2013, 19:57
NEVER

AGAIN.

Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: GarandMarine on 05 Nov 2013, 20:02
Dayum.

But yeah I'm with Emily on this one, once wearing heels was enough.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Near Lurker on 05 Nov 2013, 20:08
No earrings?  Isn't she worried they'll start to heal?
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: mustang6172 on 05 Nov 2013, 20:23
I had a similar experience to Emily’s, except in my case it was learning to ride a bike.

NEVER.  AGAIN.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Rghfrgl on 05 Nov 2013, 20:29
No earrings?  Isn't she worried they'll start to heal?

Probably just forgot to draw them. He'll probably edit them in if someone points it out.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: LookingIn on 05 Nov 2013, 21:40
Lost a bet once with my brother and his friend and had to wear his sister's three inch heels...ended up with a strained ankle.

Tried wearing a pair of mens dress shoes with raised heels, wound up slipping on the floor, ripped my pants, and nearly blew out the ligaments in my knee

Poor Claire is on the verge of being crushed by Emily- best to just agree with her and let things slide, Claire  :-D
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Indicible on 05 Nov 2013, 22:00
Dang, Claire looks fetching.
Emily is not weird, she is... Well... A bit weird, but not that much. I prefer her brand of adorable-weird over angst and worry (which are for some reason not considered weird) any time of the day.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: indiespy on 05 Nov 2013, 22:21
Emily isn't weird she is just honest enough to be who she really is.

Regarding the potential Marine. They can be written in a fashion similar to Lt. Porter. When not in uniform or off duty they are pretty laid back. Though for ease of writing she can be made similar to Faye in personality.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Sidhekin on 05 Nov 2013, 22:47
I laughed!

Hey, have we ever seen Emily this intense before?  The you-forgot-my-banana-smoothie incident comes to mind, but it really pales in the follow-through.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: VeraLapsa on 05 Nov 2013, 23:36
As a fellow trans woman I wish I was as short and cute as Claire is. I want that outfit so bad!
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Is it cold in here? on 05 Nov 2013, 23:55
Welcome, new person!
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Rghfrgl on 06 Nov 2013, 00:34
She is looking kind of adorable.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: snubnose on 06 Nov 2013, 01:47
If there is one thing I hate with a passion then its high heels.

They are evil destroyers of beautiful women feet.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: techkid on 06 Nov 2013, 02:55
I still find it weird that women wear high heels, myself. They look so damn uncomfortable!
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Border Reiver on 06 Nov 2013, 03:46
Emily isn't weird she is just honest enough to be who she really is.

Regarding the potential Marine. They can be written in a fashion similar to Lt. Porter. When not in uniform or off duty they are pretty laid back. Though for ease of writing she can be made similar to Faye in personality.

Unless SMiF has an ROTC program, the presence of a Marine would be unlikely, unless she's posted to Boston.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: NotAwesomeAnymore on 06 Nov 2013, 03:58
Techkid, they may look uncomfortable, but they make your calves look amazing.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: GarandMarine on 06 Nov 2013, 04:22
Emily isn't weird she is just honest enough to be who she really is.

Regarding the potential Marine. They can be written in a fashion similar to Lt. Porter. When not in uniform or off duty they are pretty laid back. Though for ease of writing she can be made similar to Faye in personality.

Unless SMiF has an ROTC program, the presence of a Marine would be unlikely, unless she's posted to Boston.

I'd bet you North Hampton has a recruiting office. Also our theoretical Marine/veteran could easily be attending SMiF on the Montgomery GI bill after getting out of the Marines.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Carl-E on 06 Nov 2013, 04:38
Claire has magic boots! 

Techkid, they may look uncomfortable, but they make your calves look amazing.

Not just the calves... the effect runs further up!    :-o :-D :roll:
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: GarandMarine on 06 Nov 2013, 04:43
This thread needs more ZZ top  :mrgreen:

Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: pwhodges on 06 Nov 2013, 04:52
Techkid, they may look uncomfortable, but they make your calves look amazing.

I have never seen the attraction of that supposed effect.  To my eyes high heels just look clumsy, and that's all.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Zebediah on 06 Nov 2013, 06:04
And in my opinion women's calves generally look pretty amazing all by themselves. No need to gild the lily, ladies.

Circling back to the comic: This is the most revealing outfit I can recall Claire wearing yet. Granted, it's not all that revealing, but she exposed less skin at the lake house.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: GarandMarine on 06 Nov 2013, 06:12
She's clearly feeling a lot more self confident. I wonder if the earrings had an impact with that?
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Skewbrow on 06 Nov 2013, 06:31
Techkid, they may look uncomfortable, but they make your calves look amazing.

I have never seen the attraction of that supposed effect.  To my eyes high heels just look clumsy, and that's all.

Seconded. When overdone that is. One of these days the high heel cliché will make me give up porn. Bare feet are ok, and toe-curling cotton socks just...
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Barmymoo on 06 Nov 2013, 06:41
When I wear high heels it is because I want to look taller. High heels are pretty good at achieving that effect.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Neko_Ali on 06 Nov 2013, 06:54
I have to say.. I really like Claire's boots in this comic. I like all of her outfit.. except I would not wear that top with at skirt. It seems to unbalanced to me, in color and 'weight'. It's a light, summery sort of top, and a heavier, fall sort of skirt/tights/boots combination. But that's really just my opinion. :)

In regards to heels... I actually like them. And I'm unusual in the fact that I've never had any real problem walking in them. The only ones I have had problem with are my pirate costume boots with the tall, thin heels and uneven surfaces.... However I almost never wear heels. Part of it is that at 5'10" I already loom over many women and some men, so adding another four inches just makes  me feel like I stand out even more than usual. As I put it.. Heels make me feel like a 'Trannysaurus Rex'. :) The other side to that of course is that I have very large feet (size 13), so just finding shoes in my size that I can afford can be difficult enough. Finding cute shoes that I like is even harder.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Zebediah on 06 Nov 2013, 07:30
She's clearly feeling a lot more self confident. I wonder if the earrings had an impact with that?

I'm thinking it's all part of the same arc. And I'd include the blue dress she wore at the wedding. Possibly even the frilly princess dress she tried on, even though I thought it was hideous - she clearly liked it. It's all part of her deciding she likes who she is and how she looks now.

I had a kind-of-similar revelation at about the same age as Claire, while I trying on a tux for a friend's wedding. I looked in a mirror and thought, "Goddamn! I look good in this!"
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: jwhouk on 06 Nov 2013, 07:53
By the bye: I think Jeph is using a new technique to make his word balloons. Not sure I care for the effect, as it detracts from the dialogue.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: KOK on 06 Nov 2013, 08:06
She's clearly feeling a lot more self confident. I wonder if the earrings had an impact with that?

I'm thinking it's all part of the same arc.

This is sort of 2539 in reverse. This time it is Claire who rushes in where Emily fears to thread.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Emperor Norton on 06 Nov 2013, 08:25
I think high heels are attractive, and women can wear them if they want, but I'd prefer people wear things that are comfortable if they are going to be on their feet all day. Basically, I'd rather someone save their feet and my ears about how much their feet hurt than look marginally better.

This might be also why I'm jeans/shorts, t-shirts, no shoes/vibrams in almost every day of my life. Fuck looking good for other people, I'm going to be COMFORTABLE.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Barmymoo on 06 Nov 2013, 10:05
For my placements, which can be between 9 and 14 hour shifts, I wear the most hideous but comfortable shoes. During the day I just wear comfortable waterproof shoes (Doc Martens at the moment). But for a special event, say for a dinner in a nice restaurant, I would maybe wear heels since I'd be sitting down a lot. It's about suiting the shoes to the occasion!
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Kugai on 06 Nov 2013, 11:07
Yaknow, give her a green jacket and she'd be the QC version of Daria.


But would that make Emily Jane?
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Rubick on 06 Nov 2013, 11:19
By the bye: I think Jeph is using a new technique to make his word balloons. Not sure I care for the effect, as it detracts from the dialogue.

I've noticed this. Maybe because it's new, but it looks really weird and a little unclear.

I've also noticed that Emily's hair is just really, really strange. It looks like a razor sharp edge.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Emperor Norton on 06 Nov 2013, 12:18
For my placements, which can be between 9 and 14 hour shifts, I wear the most hideous but comfortable shoes. During the day I just wear comfortable waterproof shoes (Doc Martens at the moment). But for a special event, say for a dinner in a nice restaurant, I would maybe wear heels since I'd be sitting down a lot. It's about suiting the shoes to the occasion!

Exactly. I always get exasperated if I'm going somewhere with someone and its obviously going to be an on your feet experience (like a zoo or something), and they start complaining to me about their feet hurting because they wore impractical shoes. I just want to yell that its their own fault but I refrain.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Barmymoo on 06 Nov 2013, 12:29
The statement that "there is no bad weather, only unsuitable clothing" applies equally to shoes.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: nosaJay19 on 06 Nov 2013, 13:51
Emily, you can't give up on trying new things! For instance, you've kept that ridiculous hairstyle all this time...
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Zebediah on 06 Nov 2013, 13:53
So you're saying she should get drunk and put on high heels? That doesn't sound like a good plan.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: LookingIn on 06 Nov 2013, 14:42
Emily isn't weird she is just honest enough to be who she really is.

Regarding the potential Marine. They can be written in a fashion similar to Lt. Porter. When not in uniform or off duty they are pretty laid back. Though for ease of writing she can be made similar to Faye in personality.

Unless SMiF has an ROTC program, the presence of a Marine would be unlikely, unless she's posted to Boston.

For a Marine, not likely except for recruiting post. For Air Force, it's not out of the question with Barnes and Westover Air Bases in Westfield and Chicope being within reasonable distance to Northampton
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Is it cold in here? on 06 Nov 2013, 15:31
Just to be mean to Marten, how about a Marine on leave visiting her family? It would be like Padma, with the inevitable move away.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: indiespy on 06 Nov 2013, 15:48
It COULD develop into a really good long distance relationship. Doesn't have to end when she leaves.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: GarandMarine on 06 Nov 2013, 16:16
Guys. Really. Marines do get out of the Corps and go to college! I promise we do! Well I didn't but that's besides the point!
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: indiespy on 06 Nov 2013, 16:18
Same for the Army. I left as a cook used my GI bill and became a PI with a business degree.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Mlle Germain on 06 Nov 2013, 16:25
Re: Shoes
I don't wear high heels very often, but I bought boots that are pretty similar to Claire's about two months ago. The heels and shafts are actually not that high. But they are really comfortable, since they support the foot well and are pretty broad in the front, so my feet don't get squashed wearing them. So at least boots with high heels do not have to be uncomfortable.
Still hard to wear them for an entire day standing up or walking around, though, since so much weight still lies on the front of the foot.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: RightInTheSquishyParts on 06 Nov 2013, 16:39
Just to be mean to Marten, how about a Marine on leave visiting her family? It would be like Padma, with the inevitable move away.

No mean would have it develop into a serious relationship then kill her in the line of duty.     
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: muon on 06 Nov 2013, 16:42
I have basically those boots in grey. I love them, but then again, I love most of my heels. I actually wear heels most days, although often they're not very high and are quite wide. I actually learned to walk in heels before I started transitioning the awesoming, when I was learning ballroom dance (in the latin dances, everyone wears heels). Then again, I never found it particularly difficult (stilettos, on the other hand—those are tricky).

Warning - while you were typing a new reply has been posted. You may wish to measure your heel height.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Zebediah on 06 Nov 2013, 16:46
Are we seriously now shipping Marten with an entirely hypothetical character?  :psyduck:
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: RyanW1019 on 06 Nov 2013, 16:53
Did I miss something about a new Marine character being added into the comic? As in, did Jeph mention it in a Tumblr dump or something? Or was this discussion all just inspired by the poll option?
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: GarandMarine on 06 Nov 2013, 17:06
Are we seriously now shipping Marten with an entirely hypothetical character?  :psyduck:

I believe that is exactly what's happening.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: DSL on 06 Nov 2013, 18:16
So ... would shipping with a hypothetical character fall afoul of the anti-shipping rules?

It's a hypothetical question, of course.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: jwhouk on 06 Nov 2013, 18:35
The statement that "there is no bad weather, only unsuitable clothing" applies equally to shoes.

The person who said that never had to deal with Wisconsin weather. 30 degree (17 C) temperature difference from morning to night.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: cesium133 on 06 Nov 2013, 19:02
The statement that "there is no bad weather, only unsuitable clothing" applies equally to shoes.

The person who said that never had to deal with Wisconsin weather. 30 degree (17 C) temperature difference from morning to night.
Or Oklahoma weather, unless tornado shelters count as "clothing."  :psyduck:
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Mr_Rose on 06 Nov 2013, 19:15
The statement that "there is no bad weather, only unsuitable clothing" applies equally to shoes.

The person who said that never had to deal with Wisconsin weather. 30 degree (17 C) temperature difference from morning to night.
Or Oklahoma weather, unless tornado shelters count as "clothing."  :psyduck:
No, but powered armour does.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Kugai on 06 Nov 2013, 19:32
You mean like these?


Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Is it cold in here? on 06 Nov 2013, 19:42
The Marine might be an artillery specialist.

It's not shipping if it's cannon.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: RightInTheSquishyParts on 06 Nov 2013, 20:45
I have seen the future and it is hlrugh.

....seems to be a glitch with the progression?
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: mustang6172 on 06 Nov 2013, 20:47
So that's how Claire dies... Emily hugs.

I guess we were supposed to expect that.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: LookingIn on 06 Nov 2013, 20:47
Accidental slip of the tongue saved by an impromptu hug of friendship!
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Rghfrgl on 06 Nov 2013, 20:48
 And we're back from the future, with hugs from friday.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Method of Madness on 06 Nov 2013, 20:56
Oops. I wonder if he'll post Thursday's tomorrow.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Is it cold in here? on 06 Nov 2013, 20:57
Claire, you must have figured out by now that Emily is not as predictable as Marten.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: cesium133 on 06 Nov 2013, 21:02
So, uh, if Jeph is going to build up a Dave Willis-like buffer, he might want to make sure he puts them up in the right order.  :roll:
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Yarin on 06 Nov 2013, 21:09
Might be a mislabel or maybe we missed a comic
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: hobo386 on 06 Nov 2013, 21:09
So that's how Claire dies... Emily hugs.

Nah, this is how Emily dies. (She chokes on a giant hairball while hugging Claire).
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Rghfrgl on 06 Nov 2013, 21:14
Might be a mislabel or maybe we missed a comic

It's not a mislabel, we're clearly missing the strip where Emily asks if Claire has kissed all the boys.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Yarin on 06 Nov 2013, 21:17
I didn't want to assume
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Method of Madness on 06 Nov 2013, 21:19
If you try to go back one there's a missing image, so it's more than an assumption.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: NotAwesomeAnymore on 06 Nov 2013, 21:35
There's no ways Emily is going to keep Claire's transness a secret.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Near Lurker on 06 Nov 2013, 21:47
I've got to admit... between Emily's general flightiness and the "...about Ms. Hubbert!" scene, I am concerned, but... she must realize this is serious... she is of her generation.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: ZoeB on 06 Nov 2013, 21:48
Poor Emily.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Near Lurker on 06 Nov 2013, 21:54
...oh!  I'd just figured we'd skipped the buildup to this as unimportant.  I had been wondering why now, both why at work and what caused her to decide she trusted her to this degree... I guess we're still due our answer.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: MightionNY on 06 Nov 2013, 22:10
The greatest mystery of this week is of course...

....what happened to 2571? :D  Dun dun DUNNN! :D
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: nosaJay19 on 06 Nov 2013, 22:23
Nah, this is how Emily dies. (She chokes on a giant hairball while hugging Claire).

Yeah, that'll happen...
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: HeavyP on 06 Nov 2013, 22:29
So, commentary on (what I suspect is) Friday's comic:

If this were anyone but Emily, I feel like this could potentially be an insulting reaction.  But Emily is....well, she's weird and quirky, but if you take her down to basics she's basically the avatar of Innocence.  Emily loves everyone, and while Claire seems to have a good handle on her transition and the people in her life, having someone just bear hug you and say in so many words that they love you and you're awesome...that seems like a good thing.  Emily is just impressing the HELL out of me with her reaction, and I feel like Claire basically won the lottery with the friendships she fell into - her work crew are the most accepting people EVER.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: KOK on 06 Nov 2013, 22:46
Emily, you can't give up on trying new things! For instance, you've kept that ridiculous hairstyle all this time...

How long has it been since the lake party? People are still dressed for summer.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Is it cold in here? on 06 Nov 2013, 22:53
Emily is not the person I would pick to keep a secret. Claire is a good judge of character, given that she chose Marten to confide in. Is Claire deciding to tell the world?
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: de_la_Nae on 06 Nov 2013, 23:15

The other side to that of course is that I have very large feet (size 13), so just finding shoes in my size that I can afford can be difficult enough. Finding cute shoes that I like is even harder.


Preach it!
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Barmymoo on 07 Nov 2013, 00:06
Accidental slip of the tongue saved by an impromptu hug of friendship!

What slip of the tongue? Fairly clearly, Claire has just finished explaining to Emily what being trans means.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Akima on 07 Nov 2013, 00:34
I have personal issues with high heels. I cannot help but see them as like another form of foot-binding (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Footbinding), but one that nowadays we inflict on ourselves. :psyduck:

It is difficult to judge today's strip (2572) without the lead-up strip. It seems as if Claire is just blurting out her background. And yes, as others have pointed out, Emily is a bit of a dice-roll.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Stanzara on 07 Nov 2013, 00:40
What happened to comic number 2571? The .png of it can't be found either (gives a 404) and I haven't read it yet!
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: pwhodges on 07 Nov 2013, 00:40
High heels as foot binding - yes, that's very much my feeling about them.

As for the missing strip; it's at least possible that Jeph decided there was a serious problem with it such that he chose not to go with it.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Stanzara on 07 Nov 2013, 00:53
Oh dear. Now I will never know what happened there.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: LookingIn on 07 Nov 2013, 00:59
Accidental slip of the tongue saved by an impromptu hug of friendship!

What slip of the tongue? Fairly clearly, Claire has just finished explaining to Emily what being trans means.

You will have to excuse me for going on what I can see and not what I couldn't see. I didn't see the setup to make that assumption, but I did see something that leads me to believe that she might not have meant to tell her or she was trying to tell her but was cut off by the hug
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: pwhodges on 07 Nov 2013, 01:00
Oh dear. Now I will never know what happened there.

Or he just made a mistake; I'm sure all will become clear in due course.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Near Lurker on 07 Nov 2013, 01:04
As for the missing strip; it's at least possible that Jeph decided there was a serious problem with it such that he chose not to go with it.

It's possible, but I think he'd have at least changed the title if he'd decided to skip a strip.  Also, I doubt he'd decide that; he's shown he's willing to update at eight in the morning, if need be, or just throw Yelling Bird in.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: KOK on 07 Nov 2013, 02:00
Accidental slip of the tongue saved by an impromptu hug of friendship!

What slip of the tongue? Fairly clearly, Claire has just finished explaining to Emily what being trans means.

You will have to excuse me for going on what I can see and not what I couldn't see. I didn't see the setup to make that assumption, but I did see something that leads me to believe that she might not have meant to tell her or she was trying to tell her but was cut off by the hug

I think it is quite obvious that she has already told her. What she says in panel three would be a very odd way to introduce the subject. I am not at all certain that the missing page shows her telling. It is not necessary to understand this one.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Schmee on 07 Nov 2013, 02:25
Yeah... I think in #2571 Emily asks Claire how many boys she's kissed/boyfriends she's had, and HIJINKS as Claire awkwardly avoids the topic, until in panel 4 she actually tells Emily she's trans. That seems to link well with 2570 and 2572, and helps to explain why we haven't seen it yet; I don't envy Jeph, it'd be incredibly hard to get right.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: GarandMarine on 07 Nov 2013, 02:34
Cute comic is cute, that is all.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: techkid on 07 Nov 2013, 03:36
Nothing in his twitter feed or his blog to say about the missing page. I have already read #2572, and while Emily might be a wildcard, I trust she will be respectable about the whole thing, but... I kind of want to unread it until I know what happens in #2571. I'm that sort of person. Jeph must be working overtime to make sure that it comes out right (chances are good that, to do it properly, 2572 might end up as 2573...)

Still, Claire is brave as hell to come forward to Emily like that! I can see the shapes of the sorts of nightmare precautions that you trans* folk have to face day to day, but... maybe a better world can start with simple gestures like this.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Sidhekin on 07 Nov 2013, 04:20
I have personal issues with high heels. I cannot help but see them as like another form of foot-binding (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Footbinding), but one that nowadays we inflict on ourselves. :psyduck:
Thank you.  I'm rather struggling with how to express how I see high heels, so it's nice of you to do it for me.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: DSL on 07 Nov 2013, 04:30
The Marine might be an artillery specialist.

It's not shipping if it's cannon.

Well, I'll respect that if it's your head cannon.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: RightInTheSquishyParts on 07 Nov 2013, 04:33
The Marine might be an artillery specialist.

It's not shipping if it's cannon.

Well, I'll respect that if it's your head cannon.

So this is the caliber of joke I can expect if I choose to continue posting here?   

...

...

...

 :roll:
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: DSL on 07 Nov 2013, 04:36
High heels used to be a guy thing, (http://thesocietypages.org/socimages/2013/02/05/from-manly-to-sexy-the-history-of-the-high-heel/) you know.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: snubnose on 07 Nov 2013, 04:37
What happened to comic number 2571? The .png of it can't be found either (gives a 404) and I haven't read it yet!
Me neither :(

http://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2571 -> nothing there for me !



I have personal issues with high heels. I cannot help but see them as like another form of foot-binding (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Footbinding), but one that nowadays we inflict on ourselves. :psyduck:
Thats even worse.

But yeah, highheels are evil !!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: aldonius on 07 Nov 2013, 04:40
Quote from: Jeph's Twitter (04:15 board time)
Apparently the comic isn’t loading. I’m on the road today so I won’t enable to fix it until later :(
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: snubnose on 07 Nov 2013, 04:41
Quote from: Jeph's Twitter (04:15 board time)
Apparently the comic isn’t loading. I’m on the road today so I won’t enable to fix it until later :(

THanks !
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: DSL on 07 Nov 2013, 04:43
The Marine might be an artillery specialist.

It's not shipping if it's cannon.

Well, I'll respect that if it's your head cannon.

So this is the caliber of joke I can expect if I choose to continue posting here?   
 :roll:

Sometimes it's just automatic, and the puns continue at a pretty good clip. But we don't want to bore you, or put you over a barrel as you take stock of the situation.

Absent seeing comic 2571 -- I'll jump on the bandwagon of ridiculously-unlikely-and-shortly-to-be-refuted speculation and wonder if Claire was about to tell Emily she's trans -- ferring to another college.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: kyomi on 07 Nov 2013, 05:00
I thought Claire was cute in heels. I love those boots :)  Curse me being tall with large feet -_-...

Comic 2571 is a mystery comic.. it is whatever you want it to be :3
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: aldonius on 07 Nov 2013, 05:32
Round two:
Quote from: Jeph's Twitter (5:25 board time)
Aaaaaa I uploaded the wrong comic and didn’t notice! I need an auto updater.

Quote
Once I find some wifi you guys are gettin two comics today I guess!
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Mlle Germain on 07 Nov 2013, 05:41
I didn't even notice that this was not supposed to be today's comic until I tried to go back to the previous one.
I just assumed Jeph was skipping the Emily asks Claire about number of boys kissed scene to go right to Claire's coming-out to Emily.
Also, I read Emily's reaction as admiring Claire for the brave pursuit of her real personality and didn't find it that weird - I guess Emily realises that Claire's was not an easy road to take and that she seems to be doing well at the moment.

Apparently, Jeph has just taken down the comic; was trying to reread it and it's gone. 

Edit: Took out surplus word.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: kyomi on 07 Nov 2013, 05:43
Apparently, Jeph has just taken down the comic; was trying to reread it and it's gone.

Still up :) http://questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2572 (http://questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2572)
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Mlle Germain on 07 Nov 2013, 05:45
Oh, you're right! Then you just can't get to it by clicking "next comic". If I try that, it tells me that I'm already at the last comic.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: jwhouk on 07 Nov 2013, 05:53
That was weird, but at least I got 2571 in a short period of time.

So. Emily's in on "The Secret".
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: JordanTH on 07 Nov 2013, 05:55
I'm actually having more trouble with reading today's comic than I am with tomorrow's. It's cut off halfway through the first panel and I don't know if it's just not loading right for me, or if the image is actually broken.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: pwhodges on 07 Nov 2013, 06:12
It's fine now; perhaps you just got there too soon.  And tomorrow's is now hidden from normal access.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Zebediah on 07 Nov 2013, 06:18
Well, since many of us have seen tomorrow's comic, I'll go ahead and comment on it: Emily may be weird and flighty and oblivious, but underneath it all she is a very good-hearted person. And that makes up for a lot.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: KOK on 07 Nov 2013, 06:21
So the coming out does happen between two pages.

Emily is good hearted, but is that enough? She will not out Claire out of malice, but she may not understand how important it is to keep the secret.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: GarandMarine on 07 Nov 2013, 07:26
Is it really that big of a secret to keep at this point though? Claire is clearly feeling more confident about herself just in general, I'm guessing young master Reed was the first person outside kinfolk and support groups that heard her secret, to which she recievied a very positive and supportive response. While Emily kinda suprised her, she told her without too much hesitation and Emily was very... enthusiastic in her response as well. (I kinda got the mental picture of a big golden retriever jumping on Claire in that last panel)
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Lazarus on 07 Nov 2013, 07:43
Yes, it is a very, very big secret. It does not matter how many people a trans person (or any LGBTQ+ person) is out to, or how "confident about themselves" you think they are. You do NOT out a trans person, not EVER. They may (and probably will, because HELL WORLD) face very real, very serious, often violent consequences as a result. 
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Method of Madness on 07 Nov 2013, 08:06
Claire will probably give Emily the same parameters that Marten has (only tell if someone asks directly) and I don't think Emily will betray that trust.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: hobo386 on 07 Nov 2013, 08:08
Yes, it is a very, very big secret. It does not matter how many people a trans person (or any LGBTQ+ person) is out to, or how "confident about themselves" you think they are. You do NOT out a trans person, not EVER. They may (and probably will, because HELL WORLD) face very real, very serious, often violent consequences as a result.

(click to show/hide)
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Method of Madness on 07 Nov 2013, 08:22
Global Moderator Comment You're new here, but please read this (http://forums.questionablecontent.net/index.php/topic,28457.0.html). All of it? Not necessarily, but if you start reading you may not be able to stop, it's very informative. At the very least, it will let you know why your post was not ok.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: RightInTheSquishyParts on 07 Nov 2013, 08:43
The Marine might be an artillery specialist.

It's not shipping if it's cannon.

Well, I'll respect that if it's your head cannon.

So this is the caliber of joke I can expect if I choose to continue posting here?   
 :roll:

Sometimes it's just automatic, and the puns continue at a pretty good clip. But we don't want to bore you, or put you over a barrel as you take stock of the situation.


Well as I rifle through the rules I'm sure you've breached one or more.   Perhaps we need a primer on basic punmanship, or put a cap on the number per thread.

(Ok I'm reaching with some of those but hey I was up all night with paperwork.   I'm in the Meltly Zone headed for the psychotic breakdown.   WOO )
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: DSL on 07 Nov 2013, 08:54
The only rule on pun control in this forum I'm aware of is, hit whatcha aim at. And the pun jar. There is always the pun jar.
(Locks and loads pun jar with spent round).
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Method of Madness on 07 Nov 2013, 08:58
(shoots the pun jar, then destroys the pun jar factory in Panjar with my head cannon)

There. Can we stop bringing up the pun jar every time someone makes a pun?
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Neko_Ali on 07 Nov 2013, 09:13
I rather worry about Emily knowing Claire is trans as well. Even being given the 'please don't go telling anyone' speech, I wouldn't trust her not to slip at some point. Not out of any kind of malice of course. Just the opposite really. Because she is happy for and proud of Claire. More than a few people have been outed in these exact circumstances by a well meaning, happy and supportive friend who is just so darn proud that they tell other people about their trans friend... Which is a huge faux paux of course, and downright dangerous. While I doubt anybody in the cast is going to turn on Claire, you never know who will overhear it. And in the end you can really never predict how people will take this kind of news, even if you know them well. When I came out to my group of friend just before I started presenting as female I was totally wrong in several cases of who would be supportive and who wouldn't...
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: GarandMarine on 07 Nov 2013, 09:21
Well the other thing to consider is how dark Jephizba would actually take the comic you know?
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: cesium133 on 07 Nov 2013, 09:22
(shoots the pun jar, then destroys the pun jar factory in Panjar with my head cannon)

There. Can we stop bringing up the pun jar every time someone makes a pun?
That poor squirrel.  :-(
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Hybris on 07 Nov 2013, 09:27
Emily is just too chaotic to be trusted with big stuff like Claire's trans issue. Is she evil? No but she is both wild and dumb enough to be dangerous to everyone.

I will admit though that as the character as grown I have grown to hate Emily just because she is so out there. I wonder what happened to the other grad student?
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: cesium133 on 07 Nov 2013, 09:30
Gabby? The humidity got her.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Mad Cat on 07 Nov 2013, 09:35
If Claire is smart, she'll take that as a "NO!!!!"
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: YourEvilExGirlfriend on 07 Nov 2013, 09:40
I was wondering about Gabby as well.

As for whether or not Emily can be trusted, for all her quirks, she doesn't strike me as the type to gossip. She seems more curious and interested in learning about other people than talking about them. She's in her own little world most of the time anyway. This is the girl that spends more time thinking of puns and banana smoothies and looking up facts in encyclopedias than outing anyone.

That, and Claire did say it was a secret. Presumably Emily knows what a secret is and how to keep it. I bet she'd be thrilled she was trusted this way and take special care. Emily is nothing if not enthusiastic in all she does.

Over all, though, I'm glad to see the characters setting a positive example of  acceptance when someone comes out to you. 

Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Method of Madness on 07 Nov 2013, 09:45
(shoots the pun jar, then destroys the pun jar factory in Panjar with my head cannon)

There. Can we stop bringing up the pun jar every time someone makes a pun?
That poor squirrel.  :-(
Well of course I evacuated the place first! The squirrel used the proceeds of the jar to buy a nice tree in the country.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Is it cold in here? on 07 Nov 2013, 10:00
Emily good-hearted? That would be news to Pintsize.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Game and Watch Forever on 07 Nov 2013, 10:05
As for whether or not Emily can be trusted, for all her quirks, she doesn't strike me as the type to gossip. She seems more curious and interested in learning about other people than talking about them. She's in her own little world most of the time anyway. This is the girl that spends more time thinking of puns and banana smoothies and looking up facts in encyclopedias than outing anyone.

That, and Claire did say it was a secret. Presumably Emily knows what a secret is and how to keep it. I bet she'd be thrilled she was trusted this way and take special care. Emily is nothing if not enthusiastic in all she does.

Agreed. Not to mention, Emily REALLY seems to think highly of Claire, even before she came out to her. After the ear piercing incident, I think she'll be really careful not to do something that could harm a friend she really admires. After several communication mishaps, I think this is the time where she'll pass with flying colors, since it's also the time where it matters most.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Is it cold in here? on 07 Nov 2013, 10:21
Given Claire's track record it's possible she's a better judge of character than we are.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Barmymoo on 07 Nov 2013, 10:28
I suspect that at some point in the future, Claire will say to Emily "thanks for not outing me [in x situation which just occurred where other people might have been tempted to]" and Emily will say "well you asked me not to! Why would I tell people something you didn't want them to know?" and genuinely not have a clue why someone would do that.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: KOK on 07 Nov 2013, 10:36
Emily good-hearted? That would be news to Pintsize.

Good point. She also completely disregarded Momo's "Stop it!" back on the color change page.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Storel on 07 Nov 2013, 10:57
Emily good-hearted? That would be news to Pintsize.

Good point. She also completely disregarded Momo's "Stop it!" back on the color change page.

Good-hearted toward humans, but not so much toward robots AnthroPCs?

I don't see her being like that in any antagonistic way, though; more like she just can't help thinking of them as toys instead of people. She did spend all her time in her AI 101 course looking at cat GIFs (http://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2284), after all, so she's lacking all the basic info about why they're considered people and what behavior toward them is considered rude or not rude.

Edit: By the time I checked the comic this morning, the site was correctly displaying #2571 with no hint of 2572. So it was rather odd to come here and find you all discussing a comic I hadn't seen and couldn't see. It was also pretty amusing to see you all speculating about Jeph's deeper motivations for skipping a comic, since at that point it was obviously just a simple goof, and especially amusing since he's made that exact same goof on multiple occasions in the past. :laugh:
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: kyomi on 07 Nov 2013, 12:10
You can still see #2572, you just have to manually increment it :)

I would of been tempted to disregard the "Stop it!" too.. because that is completely addicting.. pushing a button and having things change color. Also, I am amused by little things >.>;
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Storel on 07 Nov 2013, 12:15
You can still see #2572, you just have to manually increment it :)

Yeah, I figured that out later, after posting that comment...

I would of been tempted to disregard the "Stop it!" too.. because that is completely addicting.. pushing a button and having things change color. Also, I am amused by little things >.>;

True, but I expect that Momo's tone got more upset with each "Stop it!" -- I know mine would, anyway...
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Kugai on 07 Nov 2013, 12:20
Oh dear.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Thrudd on 07 Nov 2013, 12:39
Oh dear.
A dear, a Female Dear.

Ray, a guy that delivers Pizza

Fee is what I pay due to copyright monkeys

So why are we even singing this as a song?

Laaaa Laaaaa Lah Lah Laa Laa

Tea I take with Lemon and Honey

Duh'Oh   :psyduck:
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: LookingIn on 07 Nov 2013, 12:44
That was weird, but at least I got 2571 in a short period of time.

So. Emily's in on "The Secret".

With the proper setup now she is definately in on it, and even bigger she is OK with it and is showing signs of being a true friend

Let's just hope she isn't prone to blurting out secrets to people by accident though...
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Kugai on 07 Nov 2013, 13:25
I think Thrudd's been taken over by Emily.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: RightInTheSquishyParts on 07 Nov 2013, 15:02
I think Thrudd's been taken over by Emily.

This happen often?  I mean this place is nice and all but I draw the line at possessions.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: jwhouk on 07 Nov 2013, 15:09
(shoots the pun jar, then destroys the pun jar factory in Panjar with my head cannon)

There. Can we stop bringing up the pun jar every time someone makes a pun?

Besides, all the cool kids use PunPal(tm), the fastest way to pay for punning.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Method of Madness on 07 Nov 2013, 15:10
No. Puns are free...after 10 puns using your pun(ch) card.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Perfectly Reasonable on 07 Nov 2013, 17:21
Smart pretty people get ALL THE HUGS. So Emily hugs Claire before she can even finish saying the word 'transcendental'. That's somebody's head canon and I will respect that.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Loki on 07 Nov 2013, 18:21
(shoots the pun jar, then destroys the pun jar factory in Panjar with my head cannon)

There. Can we stop bringing up the pun jar every time someone makes a pun?
That poor squirrel.  :-(
Well of course I evacuated the place first! The squirrel used the proceeds of the jar to buy a nice tree in the country.

Someone remind me to update my sig in the morning.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Method of Madness on 07 Nov 2013, 18:22
Just change "In" to "Formerly in".
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: GarandMarine on 07 Nov 2013, 18:56
For the record, I was not suggesting that Emily would or should "out" Claire, I was suggesting that the secret is becoming less of a big deal on Claire's terms, so she's coming out herself.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: LookingIn on 07 Nov 2013, 19:36
Anyone else pleased with Emily's stoic look in panels 1-3? She is listening intently and given her reaction, she must really take what Claire is telling her seriously.

I don't believe she will out her, not from the look and the reaction. I think the secret is safe, and Emily made her first real friend  8-)
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Truec on 07 Nov 2013, 22:25
I don't believe she will out her, not from the look and the reaction. I think the secret is safe, and Emily made her first real friend  8-)

So Marten has become a complete non-entity at this point?
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Is it cold in here? on 07 Nov 2013, 22:36
No, he's a manatee entity.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: de_la_Nae on 07 Nov 2013, 23:08
Okay, so it looks like some of you are talking about this, and that's good, but I'll weigh in just the same.

*You* shouldn't go around telling people about your friend/lover/stranger/etc.'s trans/cis/whatever status because...well, we live in a reality where too much bullshit gets done over it. The 20th looms closer and closer after all if you really want a reminder.

That said, not to trivialize stuff, but it strikes me that the point where you can start referring to it as The Secret... maybe I'm not articulating this very well, but it seems like it's distinctly possible to take that a little too far the other way. There's not as much difference as I'd like between hiding yourself so that they don't find out you're different, and hiding yourself so that they don't find out you're different in another direction, if you get my meaning.

Though maybe that's the rambling of a bitter woman who won't get to easily 'pass' for a long time, if ever. Can't deny that colors my viewpoint.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: snubnose on 08 Nov 2013, 00:25
Oooh so we got the comic for today yesterday and now we have the comic for yesterday today but I could have gotten it yesterday ?

Well, happy weekend I guess.

[...] That's somebody's head canon and I will respect that.
That sounds like a great sig.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Rghfrgl on 08 Nov 2013, 00:28
So Marten has become a complete non-entity at this point?

You need to keep a low profile when you're secretly a beetle.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Shjade on 08 Nov 2013, 01:03
Because this is the way my brain works, I propose the Worst Way This Could End:

After an appropriately dramatic moment witnessed by Emily involving Claire and Character X, Character Y enters and asks what's happened, to which Emily responds by not only outing Claire, but doing so via pun.

Claire's breach of the peas, avenged.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Loki on 08 Nov 2013, 01:18
Just change "In" to "Formerly in".
You talk like I have more than five symbols left to spare. What madness is this?
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: cesariojpn on 08 Nov 2013, 02:14
I don't believe she will out her, not from the look and the reaction. I think the secret is safe, and Emily made her first real friend  8-)

So Marten has become a complete non-entity at this point?

Meh, fuck 'em.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Near Lurker on 08 Nov 2013, 02:26
It happens to all main characters after long enough in an ongoing series...

I am wondering about the fact that Emily said "people" to Claire, "boys" of herself, and "girls" to Marten.  I'm wondering whether Claire said something off-camera suggesting she was bi (like Dora in yesteryear; cf. "luckyyyy..."), or whether Emily just didn't want to assume.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Truec on 08 Nov 2013, 03:16
So Marten has become a complete non-entity at this point?

You need to keep a low profile when you're secretly a beetle.
Marten is George Harrison?  So much suddenly makes sense!
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: maxh on 08 Nov 2013, 06:30
Emily wears a Claire now.


Claires are cool.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: cesium133 on 08 Nov 2013, 06:35
I don't believe she will out her, not from the look and the reaction. I think the secret is safe, and Emily made her first real friend  8-)

So Marten has become a complete non-entity at this point?

Meh, fuck 'em.
That's your jommmf! (http://questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2054)
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: GarandMarine on 08 Nov 2013, 07:10
Cesium thank you for reminding me that blushy face Hanners is one of the cutest things ever
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Tormuse on 08 Nov 2013, 07:34
I rather worry about Emily knowing Claire is trans as well. Even being given the 'please don't go telling anyone' speech, I wouldn't trust her not to slip at some point. Not out of any kind of malice of course. Just the opposite really. Because she is happy for and proud of Claire. More than a few people have been outed in these exact circumstances by a well meaning, happy and supportive friend who is just so darn proud that they tell other people about their trans friend... Which is a huge faux paux of course, and downright dangerous. While I doubt anybody in the cast is going to turn on Claire, you never know who will overhear it. And in the end you can really never predict how people will take this kind of news, even if you know them well. When I came out to my group of friend just before I started presenting as female I was totally wrong in several cases of who would be supportive and who wouldn't...

Pretty much this.  I really wonder what Claire said to Emily to impress upon her that it's a secret.

Also, hi Neko_Ali!  I didn't realize you were on here!  :)
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Azumas_Revenge on 08 Nov 2013, 07:38
Emily's understanding of tact is only matched by her extreme lack of being a weirdo (That sounded much better in my head).
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Barmymoo on 08 Nov 2013, 07:48
You can be straight and still have kissed people of the same gender as you - a lot of my schoolfriends did so, at parties and as dares.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Neko_Ali on 08 Nov 2013, 07:53
I am wondering about the fact that Emily said "people" to Claire, "boys" of herself, and "girls" to Marten.  I'm wondering whether Claire said something off-camera suggesting she was bi (like Dora in yesteryear; cf. "luckyyyy..."), or whether Emily just didn't want to assume.

Well, I mean it seems fair enough. Obviously Emily knows her own sexual orientation, and Marten has only dated or talked about dating girls in the past, so fair bet Emily would think he was straight. But Claire has never really talked much about who she's dated because she hasn't dated anyone. Or about who she finds attractive. So it would be unfair to guess what her sexuality is. I mean look at the group of friends here. They've got all kinds of sexual orientation covered.

Hi Tor. Yeah, I joined here after Claire came out, 'cause I wanted to talk about it. And they's good people here. The Khaos forums seem to have pretty much died down, at least as of months ago.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Rghfrgl on 08 Nov 2013, 09:40
I am wondering about the fact that Emily said "people" to Claire, "boys" of herself, and "girls" to Marten.

That caught my attention at first too, but when I thought about it I think it was just worded that way for the sake of the reader. If Emily says boys the reader will automatically ask 'what about girls?' Which makes the point, that she's inexperienced, unclear.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: LookingIn on 08 Nov 2013, 14:24
I don't believe she will out her, not from the look and the reaction. I think the secret is safe, and Emily made her first real friend  8-)

So Marten has become a complete non-entity at this point?

I think Marten has shown he isn't going to out her even by accident. Emily on the other hand is of the airheaded mind to make the faux pas but her reaction gives me a strong feeling that she will try her hardest to keep the secret.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Method of Madness on 08 Nov 2013, 14:30
I think they meant isn't Marten Emily's friend?
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: LookingIn on 08 Nov 2013, 14:43
I think they meant isn't Marten Emily's friend?

Is he really? He is friendly with her, but is he really a friend?
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Method of Madness on 08 Nov 2013, 14:54
What's the difference?
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: GarandMarine on 08 Nov 2013, 14:56
I'd say Marten and Emily are friends at this point... he might be closer with Claire but I'm not sure what you're driving at
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Kugai on 08 Nov 2013, 14:58
You can be friendly to someone you know and/or someone who is friends with people you know/friends you know without actually being friends with them.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Method of Madness on 08 Nov 2013, 15:01
...can you? As far as I'm concerned, there has to be a reason for someone to not be my friend. If I get along with someone and spend time with them, in what scenario are we not friends?
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Mlle Germain on 08 Nov 2013, 15:15
I always thought "friend" refers to someone that you have a deeper relationship with than just hanging out sometimes and finding nice when talking to them. More like knowing them well, having them alongside you for important things in your life, trusting them to support you in difficult situations and also trusting them with more information than a simple acquaintance - discussing your emotions and what goes on inside you with them.
I need to have a reason for thinking that someone will never become my friend, but I usually wouldn't call people I work with, even people I've hung out with a few times, "friends" directly; even if I find them really nice and hope that our relationship will eventually develop to friendship when I get to know them better.
So somehow, the word "friend" has for me always been reserved for a longer, deeper kind of relationship. I hope that makes sense. But then, English isn't my first language, so that my be part of the reason.

I'm not sure if I would call Emily and Marten friends yet. Apart from the lake party, where there were many other people around, limiting their personal contact, they don't seem to have had any meetings outside work. Acquaintances who get along quite well and might become friends sometime, sure.  Unlike Claire - she and Marten have had several quite private, close experiences together, so I'd definitely call them friends.

Anyway, probably not that important, but I think that is what the original post was aiming at.

Edit: Fixed typo
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Game and Watch Forever on 08 Nov 2013, 16:05
I think they meant isn't Marten Emily's friend?

Both Marten (http://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2242) and Emily (http://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2249) have confirmed friendship status... although one of the parties may have done it unwittingly.  :lol:
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: mustang6172 on 08 Nov 2013, 18:51
I'd say Marten and Emily are friends at this point...

No, Marten is Emily's superior.

(http://static2.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20130501083529/q__/questionablecontent/images/8/8b/Claire_gotcha_face.png)
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: GarandMarine on 08 Nov 2013, 19:05
You can show yourself out.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: LookingIn on 08 Nov 2013, 19:17
You can be friendly to someone you know and/or someone who is friends with people you know/friends you know without actually being friends with them.

You read my mind perfectly, that was exactly what I was thinking. Marten is friendly with her, but may not be friends with her yet...
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Is it cold in here? on 08 Nov 2013, 22:22
I'm not sure if I would call Emily and Marten friends yet. Apart from the lake party, where there were many other people around, limiting their personal contact, they don't seem to have had any meetings outside work.

I can think of one. She visited Marten's apartment once. Of course that still doesn't make them friends. Assaulting Pintsize was not friendly.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Tormuse on 09 Nov 2013, 02:36
Hi Tor. Yeah, I joined here after Claire came out, 'cause I wanted to talk about it. And they's good people here. The Khaos forums seem to have pretty much died down, at least as of months ago.

Yeah, the loss of the Khaos forums was kind of sad, but I hear there are plans to start them anew in the near(ish?) future.

Smart pretty people get ALL THE HUGS. So Emily hugs Claire before she can even finish saying the word 'transcendental'. That's somebody's head canon and I will respect that.

Naw, she was clearly going to say transformer!  Inspired by Clinton's robot hand, she just had to go one step further.  :P
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: jwhouk on 09 Nov 2013, 02:54
Emily considers herself Marten's friend (quote: "WE'RE Friends." (http://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2249)) And it appears that the feeling is mutual, from Marten's comment about, "Oh lord, we've adopted another one." (http://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2298)
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Rghfrgl on 09 Nov 2013, 09:53
Naw, she was clearly going to say transformer!

So it's really Claire who's secretly a Volkswagen Beetle.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: anahata on 09 Nov 2013, 13:49
You can be friendly to someone you know and/or someone who is friends with people you know/friends you know without actually being friends with them.

Yup. In this case Marten and the interns know each other only through work. I'm friendly with the people I work with, but I'd only also call any of them "my friends" if I chose to spend time with them outside of work. (and that trip to the CoD doesn't count, because they were going from the library).

I was going to say that only makes Marten and Claire friends, after the wedding trip, but I'd forgotten about Emily's house party which I suppose makes them all at least semi-friends.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Kugai on 09 Nov 2013, 14:51
 So, what crazyness can we expect from the gang this week?

Dale and Marigold lip lock by Friday ...... 33 (15.5%)
Dale walks in on Marigold in the shower by Friday ...... 16 (7.5%)
Dale lures Marigold to the Alliance side (They have Cookies) ...... 10 (4.7%)
Dora finally admits the secret ingrediant to CoD Coffee - Spiders ...... 20 (9.4%)
Tai proposes to Dora ...... 10 (4.7%)
Dora proposes to Tai ...... 3 (1.4%)
Angus proposes to Faye - and she accepts at his Hospital bedside ...... 17 (8%)
Marten meets a new Girlfriend - and she's a Marine ...... 23 (10.8%)
Pintsize ...... 40 (18.8%)
Waffles with Spathe Ham ...... 19 (8.9%)
Purple Monkey Dishwasher ...... 22 (10.3%)



I wonder if anyone is surprised by that.  Voting is locked and the Poll is closed.

If anyone wants to make a Thread/Poll for next week, they're welcome to it - otherwise I'll do one myself tomorrow evening.

(added text of the poll question for posterity ~Loki)
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Mlle Germain on 09 Nov 2013, 15:00
I can think of one. She visited Marten's apartment once. Of course that still doesn't make them friends. Assaulting Pintsize was not friendly.

Huh, I totally forgot about that!

Emily considers herself Marten's friend


Yeah, although that was said in a rather flippant manner. And I'm not saying they don't like each other or anything - I think they do (in a purely platonic way), it's just that they don't know each other superwell (yet). Claire and Marten know each other way better and have spent way more time together.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Carl-E on 09 Nov 2013, 15:43
Naw, she was clearly going to say transformer!

So it's really Claire who's secretly a Volkswagen Beetle.

I love this more than you can possibly imagine. 

Unlike most transformers that fold into a vehicle, she unfolds from human form into a 1965 red convertible bug with a tan tonneau. 

(http://farm5.staticflickr.com/4107/5047542902_a4444cdd79_o.jpg)

Somehow, that car just screams Claire to me! 
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Mr_Rose on 09 Nov 2013, 15:47
I think it's the red hair?
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Neko_Ali on 09 Nov 2013, 16:05
And both are adorably cute.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Barmymoo on 09 Nov 2013, 16:13
I definitely consider people friends who I don't see outside the context of where we met - university classes, the shop I work in, the running club. Surely friendship is more about an attitude and a relationship than the details of when, where and how often you meet?
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Carl-E on 09 Nov 2013, 16:16
I think it's the red hair?

And the eyes / glasses. 
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: de_la_Nae on 09 Nov 2013, 22:22
I assumed friendship was at least partially measured by how much you could rely on them in the shit, and how much they could rely on you.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: maxh on 10 Nov 2013, 00:42
A good friend helps you move; a great friend helps you move bodies.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Loki on 10 Nov 2013, 01:28
A German expression for "they are a great friend" is "you could go steal horses with them".
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: KOK on 10 Nov 2013, 01:48

No, Marten is Emily's superior.


Marten is a lowly unskilled helper at the library. Claire is on the career track to become a librarian. Her status is way higher than his.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: jwhouk on 10 Nov 2013, 03:30
Marten is a lowly unskilled helper at the library. Claire is on the career track to become a librarian. Her status is way higher than his.

This may or may not be a poll topic.  :angel:
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: ZoeB on 10 Nov 2013, 04:44
Well, at least Emily isn't taller than most women, underdeveloped in the chest department, aspergic, socially withdrawn, and with a mysterious past, as are many Trans and Intersex gals her age.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Sidhekin on 10 Nov 2013, 05:44
... did you mean "Claire", or am I missing your point completely?
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Barmymoo on 10 Nov 2013, 05:47
I think you're missing her point.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: GarandMarine on 10 Nov 2013, 06:03
I think I might be too.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Sidhekin on 10 Nov 2013, 07:49
Rereading it ... best I can come up with is the (interpretation dependent) implication that Emily is one of the "many Trans and Intersex gals".

... in which case I'll applaud both Jeph and ZoeB!

/me ponders ...
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: GarandMarine on 10 Nov 2013, 08:08
....*face palm* well that was right in front of me!

Be interesting if it's true!
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Barmymoo on 10 Nov 2013, 08:20
Or perhaps the implication is "let's not make assumptions based on people's physical appearance".
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Sidhekin on 10 Nov 2013, 09:26
Rereading again ...

Nope, don't see that.  Did you mean "inference" rather than "implication", perhaps?

... then again, English is not my native language; I might still be missing something.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Barmymoo on 10 Nov 2013, 09:33
The way I understand it, "to imply" is what the speaker does. "To infer" is what the hearer/reader does. What you infer may not be what I intended to imply.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Sidhekin on 10 Nov 2013, 09:42
So, what inference are you implying I made?
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Barmymoo on 10 Nov 2013, 09:46
I dunno! This conversation has confused me! I thought that Zoe was pointing out that many of the features commonly associated with intersex and trans women apply to Emily, although it is Claire who is known to be trans. Your response suggested you thought she'd typed the wrong name by mistake, which wasn't what I had understood her to mean (I thought she was making a sort-of joke, although obviously it has quite a serious side to it).
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Sidhekin on 10 Nov 2013, 09:57
Your response suggested you thought she'd typed the wrong name by mistake [...]
Ah, okay.  But see, if I had thought that (as opposed to "not ruled that out"), I would not have asked.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Zebediah on 10 Nov 2013, 10:43
Besides, Emily isn't that underdeveloped in the chest department; they're not double-Ds but they're definitely there. And her past isn't so much mysterious as just unknown to us - what we do know about it is ordinary enough.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Barmymoo on 10 Nov 2013, 12:19
Ah, I see - what is going on here is that I inferred something which you were not implying! ;)
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Shjade on 11 Nov 2013, 00:03
...can you? As far as I'm concerned, there has to be a reason for someone to not be my friend. If I get along with someone and spend time with them, in what scenario are we not friends?

In the scenario in which you call me up at 2 am because your car broke down and you need a ride. Man, we might get along, but you're still just a guy I know from the coffee shop. I'm going back to sleep.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Akima on 11 Nov 2013, 01:27
Speaking as a fellow North-East Asian, Emily does not seem undeveloped to me at all.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Carl-E on 11 Nov 2013, 04:42
...except maybe as a character. 

Clueless and zany is fun(ny), but a little unsatisfying...
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Is it cold in here? on 11 Nov 2013, 11:46
We're beginning to see more to her, though.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Storel on 12 Nov 2013, 12:18
I always thought "friend" refers to someone that you have a deeper relationship with than just hanging out sometimes and finding nice when talking to them. More like knowing them well, having them alongside you for important things in your life, trusting them to support you in difficult situations and also trusting them with more information than a simple acquaintance - discussing your emotions and what goes on inside you with them.

That's what I would call a good friend, not just a friend. Perhaps some of the confusion here is that some people are using "friend" and "good friend" to mean what others would call "acquaintance" and "friend".

Naw, she was clearly going to say transformer!

So it's really Claire who's secretly a Volkswagen Beetle.

Well played!  :-D


No, Marten is Emily's superior.


Marten is a lowly unskilled helper at the library. Claire is on the career track to become a librarian. Her status is way higher than his.

No, Marten is paid staff, while Claire is an unpaid intern. At the moment, his status is definitely higher than hers, although she's on track to surpass him eventually.

Well, at least Emily isn't taller than most women, underdeveloped in the chest department, aspergic, socially withdrawn, and with a mysterious past, as are many Trans and Intersex gals her age.

Now, I took this as a gentle suggestion from Zoe that perhaps Emily is Trans or Intersex too and we just haven't found out yet. Because Emily is all those things, pretty much, which would make Zoe's statement that she isn't those things either sarcasm or irony, I'm not sure which. If that's actually what she was implying, anyway; if not, then maybe it was just... humor?

Speaking as a fellow North-East Asian, Emily does not seem undeveloped to me at all.

Good point.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Barmymoo on 13 Nov 2013, 05:19
Wait hang on, do we know that the interns are unpaid? If so, shame on Smif! They are working a full time job, they should be being PAID for it.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: DSL on 13 Nov 2013, 06:01
Wait hang on, do we know that the interns are unpaid? If so, shame on Smif! They are working a full time job, they should be being PAID for it.

Yeah, what does Smif think it is, a major media publication?
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: GarandMarine on 13 Nov 2013, 11:55
Interns at a school library can be paid in course credit I think.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Barmymoo on 13 Nov 2013, 12:01
... are you serious? Instead of money, they give you free grades?
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Method of Madness on 13 Nov 2013, 12:08
Well it counts as credit towards graduation (and on-the-job training is definitely educational), so it's basically working for scholarship money.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: KOK on 13 Nov 2013, 12:09
If the internship is a requirement for your degree, that may be incentive enough, without any pay needed.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Zebediah on 13 Nov 2013, 12:35
These days a lot of companies won't hire someone straight out of college unless they've done multiple unpaid internships. Big change from when I was in school - I was able to work the whole time I was in college and get out with no student loan debt. Now you still have to work, but for free, and pile up huge amounts of debt while you're doing it. Unless you have rich parents, of course.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Method of Madness on 13 Nov 2013, 12:36
Having rich parents also means it's more likely that they have an in at a big company, so you can get a fairly high-paying job after you graduate! :psyduck:
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Barmymoo on 13 Nov 2013, 12:37
I suppose it makes sense for a company to prefer to hire people who have already demonstrated that they're prepared to work hard for no pay.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Method of Madness on 13 Nov 2013, 12:40
What a terrible mindset we've accepted as a society :psyduck:
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: cesium133 on 13 Nov 2013, 12:50
Don't know how it works for sure, but I would think if they're grad students in library science, this would be part of their graduate assistantship, in which case they would be getting paid for it (not particularly well, but it's a lot better than nothing).
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Neko_Ali on 13 Nov 2013, 13:10
I had that basically my last semester of university. Instead of teaching us anything in class, we were expected to find an internship for the last three months. They would not help us find one. It wasn't working with the school, which was a tiny technical college anyway. So basically, we were supposed to pay the school for the privilege of finding our own unpaid jobs. If you didn't they gave you an unsupervised project as a grade that basically amounted to busy work.

Yeaaaah... I didn't have a lot of respect for my university. And this was after the semester on computers where I paid then to become a sort of teacher's assistant. I already knew all of the (very basic) computer instruction they were teaching us, so half the class would turn to me for help instead of the teacher....
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: pwhodges on 13 Nov 2013, 14:53
people who have already demonstrated that they're prepared to work hard for no pay.

There's a word for that: slaves.  No two ways about it, modern society (in Britain as well as America) is reintroducing slavery under the guise of helping people (work experience is good, right?).

Except that responsible slave owners fed and housed their slaves, and these modern slaves don't even get that.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: DSL on 13 Nov 2013, 16:55
people who have already demonstrated that they're prepared to work hard for no pay.

There's a word for that: slaves.  No two ways about it, modern society (in Britain as well as America) is reintroducing slavery under the guise of helping people (work experience is good, right?).

Except that responsible slave owners fed and housed their slaves, and these modern slaves don't even get that.

In the freelance world, it's called "exposure." As in, you can die of it.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Carl-E on 14 Nov 2013, 11:53
Tempting to laught loudly at that. 


Through chattering teeth, of course. 
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: DSL on 14 Nov 2013, 15:15
It's sorta funny the first few dozen times you get the offer.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: ZoeB on 17 Nov 2013, 06:42
Well, at least Emily isn't taller than most women, underdeveloped in the chest department, aspergic, socially withdrawn, and with a mysterious past, as are many Trans and Intersex gals her age.

Now, I took this as a gentle suggestion from Zoe that perhaps Emily is Trans or Intersex too and we just haven't found out yet. Because Emily is all those things, pretty much, which would make Zoe's statement that she isn't those things either sarcasm or irony, I'm not sure which. If that's actually what she was implying, anyway; if not, then maybe it was just... humor?

I was being deliberately ambiguous. I will remain so. Let's just say that there were multiple valid interpretations of what I said, and I may have meant all of them. Is Emily TS or IS? Does it matter? Would it matter if we never knew whether she was or was not? Is it just that women differ, be they standard factory model or customised after delivery? What does our interpretation of what I wrote tell us about ourselves? What does it say about me?

I love the ambiguity in language. It allows you to express several mutually contradictory ideas at the same time, all of which may be useful communication. The few times I commit poetry, I make use of such properties, heterodyning meaning.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: jwhouk on 17 Nov 2013, 07:03
Now I'm pretty sure she's not a Heterodyne (http://www.girlgeniusonline.com/comic.php). I mean, yeah, she has the cowlick, but with a surname of Azuma? Unless one of Bill and Barry's great grandparents did some touring of Asia, I don't think she's related to Agatha.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: ZoeB on 18 Nov 2013, 05:36
Unless one of Bill and Barry's great grandparents did some touring of Asia, I don't think she's related to Agatha.
I thought someone would get the reference.
Title: Re: WCDT: 2568-2572 (4 November - 8 November 2013) Weekly Comic Discussion Thread
Post by: Thrudd on 19 Nov 2013, 06:46
Trilobite ice-cream for everybody  :-D