An Apology: This is NOT the WCDT for the week of February 23rd. You can find that here (https://forums.questionablecontent.net/index.php/topic,30500.0.html). It was going to be, but I got a bit carried away and turned some brief speculation about Marten and Claire into the mega-post you see below, so I decided to spin it off into its own discussion and let someone else do the Weekly instead. I kept the poll for funsies, though, so it'll stay up and open until it gets boring, and feel free to change your answer as the story progresses. And, of course, discuss! Add your own thoughts/tell me how wrong I am/whatever.
So, let's talk about Marten and Claire. They've been together for what now, a week? (In-comic, that is; for us it's been about five months) Gosh! In my first post (https://forums.questionablecontent.net/index.php/topic,30209.msg1274755.html#msg1274755) on these forums, I mentioned two possibilities for them as a couple: they could either hang out for a bit and go on a few dates before deciding to just stay friends (doubtful), which still meant that with Jeph's storytelling pace we were in for several months of squee material, or they could embark on a serious relationship that played out over several years worth of strips, if not longer. No middle ground! Twoo Wuv Fuwwevva or bust! And we appear to be taking the second route, but at a faster pace than I expected: I assumed we'd be in for several dates with innocent hand-holding and such before they progressed to cuddling and chaste sleepovers before any sexytimes happened, but Claire had other ideas (http://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2838), and both of them have now admitted to each other that they want to let this relationship work. So we're in it for the long haul! Years of strips to look forward to! I'm not necessarily talking wedding bells, mind you (although Tai and Veronica have probably started scheming together), but Claire and Marten certainly have the potential to be a long-term couple. Knock on wood, of course: something could happen to break them up sooner than expected, which is what I wanted to explore in this post. The last hundred strips were full of squee- and d'awww-worthy moments, but now that they seem to be settling down (well, maybe), there is plenty of room in the relationship for some conflict to emerge. With that in mind, there are several questions we need to answer:
(Note: I decided to put each part of this post under spoilers due to length)
1. Who is Marten?Our Protagonist needs no introduction, of course; we've known him since the comic started. One thing I will say about him, though, is that he's a pretty good dude, both in general and in how he interacts with Claire. AprilArcus explored this recently, in her post about Marten's evolution as an LGBT ally (https://forums.questionablecontent.net/index.php/topic,30492.0.html), and Jeph has only strengthened this with Marten's words and actions since comic 2800 (http://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2800). Marten treated Claire with nothing but respect after she came out to him, and continued to treat her as a friend when they worked together and hung out in the weeks that followed. Okay, so he doesn't laugh (http://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2367) at her jokes (http://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2772), leading me to worry about their long-term compatibility (C'mon, she's hilarious! Friggin' killjoy...), but I suppose we can't have everything. Still, Marten's a good (if humorless) guy, and if you weren't convinced enough before The Night of the Tipsy Headscritches, Marten made it quite clear the next morning when he assured Claire after asking her out that he was completely comfortable with her being transgender.
There was plenty of debate over this in the forums and elsewhere, wondering whether or not he was being sincere, what evidence did we really have that he was okay dating someone who was trans, what would happen if/when they eventually had sex, etc. My only thought on this, which I probably should have added to the discussion at some point, was: Would Marten have accepted Claire's mother's invitation to come over to breakfast and declare his intentions if he wasn't comfortable with Claire? He's a bit passive, sure, but he's not that passive. Claire gave him enough wiggle room to back away when she stopped the scritches the night before; if Marten had wanted to, the next time he saw her he could have pretended to have been a bit too drunk and (conveniently) unable to remember what happened that night, but hey, sorry if he said or did anything weird, and Claire could have pretended that nothing happened, and life could have gone on as normal, and no one would have gotten hurt (although Claire might have died a little inside, and Marten might have died a little on the outside after Faye got wind of it). Marten didn't have to pursue anything with Claire, but he did anyway--because he wanted to.
But questions remained, even as Jeph focused an unusual amount of time on their budding relationship. Other forum members have pointed out, and I agree, that the last hundred strips have been very Claire- and Marten-heavy, almost excessively so, which might have been less of an issue if there weren't other stories and characters being shuffled to the back of the line (Faye and Dora's problems especially). But I think there is a good reason for that: from their first conversation (http://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2808), to their first (very long) date (http://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2828), and their first night together (http://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2890) to their conversation the next day (http://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2899), Jeph has been making it clear to his readers that Claire's status as a transwoman does not matter to Marten and will not be a source of tension in their relationship. Whatever disagreements they have in the future, whatever (eep!) problems that might cause them to (don't say it!) break up (nooo!), Claire's status won't be the reason. Period. End of discussion. Now, with that said...
2. What does Marten want? He's not really sure. Ultimately, he would like to have a career in music (http://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2214), but...when's the last time we saw Deathmøle practice? His last jam session with Hannelore and Amir, according to the most up-to-date timeline, (http://i.imgur.com/ou1bwaO.jpg) took place about a month ago in 2446 (http://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2446), shortly after the wedding. It's quite possible that the band has been practicing regularly since, of course; Jeph spent some time focusing on other characters between that evening and the present (Angus and Faye, Marigold and Dale, Dale and May, Veronica and Jim, etc.), so Deathmøle could be getting together several nights a week for all we know. More on that in a moment.
Meanwhile, several things have happened in Marten's life since he met Claire in 2203 (http://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2203):
-His dad got married (http://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2395),
-He bought a new guitar (http://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2418) and depleted his savings,
-He had an unsatisfying one-night stand (http://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2626) with Delilah,
-His mother started a whirlwind romance with Jim (http://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2705) and decided to move to Northampton,
-Emily kissed him! (http://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2736)
-He and Claire started dating (http://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2807), and
-His best friend/roommate lost her job (http://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2879) and nearly drank herself to death (http://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2881).
All of these have happened in just the last month (see timeline above). Taken one at a time, these little events might not mean much. Add them together, though, and they'll really start to add up. First his father remarries, then his mother starts a relationship--and in between, Dale and Marigold become a couple (http://questionablecontent.net./view.php?comic=2608), a development which causes Dora and Faye to mock Marten (http://questionablecontent.net./view.php?comic=2611) for his own love-less love life, which leads to Tai suggesting a random hook-up (http://questionablecontent.net./view.php?comic=2612), which leads to his one-night stand that Claire DOES NOT JUDGE HIM FOR HAVING (http://questionablecontent.net./view.php?comic=2653). That was only two weeks ago, remember--and only a week before Marten and Claire got together--which could lead an outside observer to wonder what this guy's deal is, anyway. Why Claire? Why now? As comfortable and happy as he is with her, could his decision to ask her out have, perhaps, been motivated by seeing all of his family and friends (including, then, Angus and Faye) in various stages of relationships when he hadn't met anyone since Padma? Factor in his panic and doubt (http://questionablecontent.net./view.php?comic=2767) over the Emily!smooch, only days before he asked out Claire, and one might really start to wonder. Why panic over one intern only to run to another, especially when he and Tai have been debating the ethics (http://questionablecontent.net./view.php?comic=2737) of dating their interns since Day One (http://questionablecontent.net./view.php?comic=2216)? Now, I'm not trying to say that Marten is only with Claire because she was the nearest available (and sanest) girl, because that would echo the problems he had with Dora (DEAR GOD NO), but it's surprising that no one in the comic has called him on it. And let's hope that Claire doesn't start to connect the dots.
I'm going to regret writing that last paragraph, aren't I?
NOW, WHERE WAS I? Oh, yes, back to the music front: Again, we're not sure how much Marten has been practicing with the band, but since he made a huge investment when he bought the new 8-string, we can only hope he intends to make it pay off. But another problem has arisen: Faye is now unemployed and her future uncertain, and rent is due at the end of the month. If Faye can't pull her shit together right away, Marten may need to pick up the slack. Where's the money going to come from? Will he keep working extra hours at the library, or start pushing the band to go live? Can he even make money with the band? Does he have a future at the library? Can he juggle both? Will this affect his relationship with a certain redhead, especially if he tries to choose between his current job and his dreams? And is he standing in the way of Claire achieving her own goals? He doesn't want to stay at the library forever, and Claire probably expects to get an actual paying job once her internship ends. But making a change sounds risky, and we know Marten is afraid of taking risks (http://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2708). Maybe he needs a little extra push. Which brings us to...
3. Who is Claire? Feel free to correct me on all this, but from what I've read about Claire, here on the forums and elsewhere, one reason she has become such a popular and groundbreaking character is because she is a transgender woman whose story in QC is not about her transitioning. When we meet her, she has already transitioned; the usual story of a trans person coming to terms with being transgender, learning more about their condition, coming out to friends and family, taking the first steps towards transitioning, and all the hurdles they encounter along the way--Claire has already been through that, and is now focused on her other goals in life, mainly education, career, and (now) a relationship. I have to applaud Jeph for doing that, and for making clear his intentions to present Claire as more than "the trans character." The problem is, we don't really know much about Claire, do we? Aside from her career dreams and her great sense of humor (no arguing!), we haven't really learned anything about her. And I would like that to change.
Mind you, I want to be clear that I AM NOT asking for a "The Talk"-style extended flashback into Claire's life, pre-transition. I fully respect Jeph's decision to keep Claire's past off-limits. However, there is plenty of room in Claire's current life to flesh out her character and personality. She lives in Northampton with her mother and brother; have they lived there a while, or did they recently move for college? We don't know. If the former, does she have any favorite haunts in the area that Marten and his friends don't know about? We don't know. Does she have other friends in the area? We don't know. What are her hobbies outside of work? We don't know. But I'm sure we would all like to find out, along with other things. She currently spends most of her time with Marten, but what about the rest of the cast? Once she comes out to Tai, will the two of them bond over LGBT issues? Will she keep trying to talk Faye into going to therapy for her alcohol problems, or perhaps help her in other ways? What about her growing friendship with Emily? Would Sam like a big sister? And if Hannelore decides to take another step in tackling her issues, wouldn't Claire make a better roommate than Marigold? All good questions, I think, and since Claire has been catapulted into the main cast, there is are plenty of opportunities to explore these and other questions. Let's do it!
But there is one thing I do hope Jeph addresses, and that's because Claire brought it up herself in 2900 (http://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2900): she has never been in a relationship before and doesn't know what she's doing, and, since she still has fears and anxieties and bad days, she is afraid of what might happen if Marten sees how vulnerable she can be. Please stop me if I'm out of bounds here, but I say LET IT HAPPEN. Let's see Claire on a bad day. I'm not saying I want to see Claire at her worst; I'm saying I want to see her dealing with her issues and working to become overcome them. And I want Marten to be there for it. He's already been witness to one anxiety attack (http://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2432); I don't think he's going to be scared off, and I don't think it's going to hurt either of them. Claire's insecurities don't have to drive a wedge between them and be relationship-ending the way Dora's were; in fact, there is plenty of potential for their relationship to grow instead, get stronger, and bring them closer together. Claire made a damn good choice, making a friend in Marten; and she got damn lucky, snagging him as a boyfriend, too. There are worse people out there to date.
But before you think I'm trying to paint Marten as Claire's knight in shining armor, riding in to save her from the dragons, we need to consider:
4. What does Claire want? Claire wants to be a librarian. She's has some very good reasons (http://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2208) for wanting that, and she considers libraries to be serious business (http://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2869). So she really picked a bad place to do her internship, because her two immediate superiors at Smif Library are directionless and risk-averse Marten, and Tai.
At some point, I think Marten and Claire (and, perhaps, Tai) need to continue the conversation they were having (http://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2786) the day before they started going out. She's the only one in the group who actually wants to be a librarian; how does she feel about working under two people who aren't as passionate about the work as she is? Forget Marten for a moment, he at least seems to be looking ahead to the future (even if he's made little effort to achieve his goals)--what about Tai, who...doesn't? I love the girl, but her attitude towards the library is beginning to clash (http://questionablecontent.net./view.php?comic=2871) with Claire's. And hey, it's not like Tai cares about her job that much. She would rather be writing erotica for a living (making her goals as realistic as Marten's), and Marten is only coasting along until the band picks up. What happens if Claire decides that she could do a better job? What if one of the librarians see she has potential? Is there room in the library for three four employees (remember Momo? I didn't!), or is Marten (or Tai) expendable? After all, this is what Claire is studying to do; the other two are just there. But for how long?
So, what next?
There is a lot to consider about Marten and Claire, separately and as a couple, and a lot of potential for the both of them to grow as characters. So with that in mind, here's a short summary of what I would like to see happen next:
LITERALLY ANYTHING ELSE.
Fact is, we got to see a lot of Marten and Claire these last hundred strips. That's not a complaint! I was genuinely happy that they got together and started a relationship, and I like that Jeph decided to spend some time solidly establishing them as a couple. And when we last left them in 2901 (http://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2901), they seemed to be settling down into their roles quite comfortably. Good for them! Have fun, you crazy kids. As mentioned above, there are plenty of challenges ahead for both of them, as individuals and as a couple, but there is no pressing need to explore them all right now. Jeph recently stated in a now-locked thread about the future of QC (https://forums.questionablecontent.net/index.php/topic,30403.msg1297057.html#msg1297057) that he has "no plans to end QC anytime soon." That's a rather vaguely-worded answer, but I hope that means we can continue to enjoy the Adventures of Marten Reed & His Merry Band of Friends for many years to come--with plenty of time devoted to Marten and Claire and their budding relationship.
But for the near future, I really hope Jeph moves them to the background for a bit to focus on the rest of the cast. Faye needs therapy and a new job, Dora has doubts about her actions and needs a new employee, and I miss Hannelore, Momo, May, Dale, Marigold, Tai, and hell, even Sven. So it wouldn't hurt if the relationship got put on the back-burner for a bit to give their friends some panel-time. As with the other couples past and present, we can assume that no news is good news, and let them have some privacy while Faye and the others get their shit together. Then, in between some of the other storylines Jeph is currently juggling, we can explore Claire's background a bit, flesh out her character, talk about her ambitions, work on her and Marten's future, and so on. But we have years to work on that, so what's the rush? I know I'm going to stick around for the ride.
Aaaand those are my thoughts on what the future has in store for the S. S. Claireten. tl;dr: Anything can happen. What are your thoughts? Let's discuss!
[Edited to fix minor typos and factual errors, change the thread title, and to expand on some thoughts.]