Strangely, I've had a very similar experience lately. I never thought I liked Of Montreal even though I never really listened to them. I got most of their albums from a friend of mine and, just a few minutes in, I was kicking myself for not listening to them sooner. Truly great stuff. They're definitely one of the more interesting and better "indie-pop/rock" bands that have found popularity in the genre.
On topic: I'm listening to a mix of Mountain Goats, Mount Eerie, Iron and Wine, Songs: Ohia and a few others. At the moment the rather irritating song "Dance Music" by The Mountain Goats is on.