To respond to a few things....
For starters, I'm not evilclosetmonkey. I am evilclosetmonkey's knit-obsessed girlfriend, who didn't feel like signing up but wanted to comment anyways.
Knitting in general is pretty easy. It becomes almost mindless once you've gotten the hang of it. Knittinghelp.com is the best site I've ever seen, and though I learned to knit from my grandmother I've relied very heavily on it to coach me through the advanced techniques. Just watch the videos over and over and try to follow along with your own needles and you'll get it pretty fast.
I agree with redglasscurls. Harry Potter scarves, while cute and all, are boring as hell to knit. Knit, knit, knit knit..... repeat until crosseyed.... WHOA CHANGE COLORS..... knit, knit, knit, knit, knit, knit, knit........ boring! However, if you're looking for something easy to start on, Harry Potter scarves are the way to go. Knit in the round on circular needles, and just change colors every so often. Easy peasy. I say go for it quietnow and make your own scarf.
Acrophobicpixie: Socks can be frustrating, but if you stick to four needles (I've always found the fifth needle to be unnecessary) and start simple you can get the hang of them pretty easily. If you keep having trouble with stitches falling off the needles you're probably a loose knitter, which isn't necessarily a bad thing. Try using wood needles. They give you more friction and keep your stitches on.
Mr.Joshua, you could not have picked an easier project to start with. The true Dr. Who scarf is just garter stitch. No purling, no knitting in the round. They take FOREVER to knit, but aside from that it's the perfect starting project. And I say screw a starter scarf. Just start it, and if it looks bad, keep pulling it out and starting over until you've got the hang of it. I figure you'd be fine after you've knit a couple inches of it. 12 feet of scarf affords plenty of room to figure out what you're doing.
I like talking about knitting way too much.