It's a little harsh to call everyone morons who haven't found this album and given it a spin....
I have to ask: exactly how much of 'Canadian indie' have you listened to/explored? Handsome Furs are hot shit right now, in certain circles, but (here it comes guys) Spencer Krug, in my opinion, is a hell of a lot better. And other bands are better than Krug. You should dig a little deeper, maybe.
Re: the album--I downloaded the leak of Plague Park a few months back and got bored of it quickly; to my ears, most of it is watered down Wolf Parade and what's left is not quite as good as that. A certain energy is missing on most of the album; listlessly going through some neat electronic sounds is not really that entertaining after a couple of listens. 'Cannot Get It Started' is good song in and of itself, and I like 'Handsome Furs Hate This City' but two good songs do not a make a great album. I won't say it's bad, but I will say it is pretty dull.
I wanted to like this, because for the longest time I tended to like the Boeckner Wolf Parade songs more...but Sunset Rubdown is great enough, and this, boring enough, to slowly change my mind. Krug's voice is also easier to take large doses of; less whiny.
As a parting note...the cover art of Plague Park tickles me, regardless of the music. For whatever reason, I like it a lot.