Blue
NMH. (I just don't think Doolittle as stand alone album can hold up to ITAOTS, pixies as a whole, yeah sure, but album to album, no.)
Mountain Goats (Fuck you SGT Peppers)
Husker Du
Slint
Yeller
It Takes A Nation
Ok Computer
Blue train
Born to Run (Oh man this fight made me twitch. That's what I love about this thread, that you start comparing things you would have never thought to compare before)
Green
Joy Division
Mogwai ( As much as Neil's the man, there are better Neil albums)
Highway 61
Abbey Road (I'm a bad person. I like Stage Names more than BSB)
Flesh
BSS
Surfer Rosa (mwahafuckyoubowiehaha)
Pet Sounds (It's fucking Pet Sounds. Even if I had come to this album cold I would love it dearly)
London Calling (I don't actually like either of these options all that much, but it's the better of two blehs)
Damn you all for not voting for Lonesome Crowded West.