Alright, I don't normally post in General Discussion (or very much at all, really) but this thread caught my eye, and I felt the need to point a few things out.
(Emphasis in quotes added by me)
Raven is way more interesting and fun than Penelope. All we know about Penelope is that she reads books. She doesn't really have any discernible personality to speak of.
I would rather see more of Sven/Faye than Pen/Wil. I don't know as I like Wil enough to have a whole storyline about him.
Until this point, Penelope didn't get very much air-time in the comic. Wil, like-wise, is a
new character. Let's put it in perspective: Raven's first appearance was in, what, comic 46? Then had 2 or 3 appearances before appearing as a regular character in
279.
It took
many comics for us to learn about her particular quirks.
I, sadly, was not around at the start of QC, so I don't know what the initial reaction to her was.
My point here is to give Wil and Penelope a chance. This date is probably going to be used by Jeph to develop their characters more fully.
In two years, they may become the most popular characters in the series; you just don't know.
In all honesty, I like Raven as a character, but I also think we need a character like Penolope. Without her, every single character would have some quirk. There'd be no baseline for the quirkiness of others.
I see Pen's occasional rants as a quirk. I agree with the other posters: Marten is the baseline for normality. (His parents have quirks, but those quirks do not reflect onto him.)
I think everyone has a different idea of who the "main characters" are. Personally, I see it as Faye and Marten. Then there are the secondary characters: Dora, Sven, Raven, Hanners, Pintsize, and Steve. Then the tertiary characters: Amir, Nat, Jimbo, Meena, David, Roomba, Tai, Angus, Veronica, Amanda, Faye's mom, Winslow, and Mieville. (Penpen and Wil are hovering on the verge of becoming secondary.)
One last thing:
What a lot of people fail to take into account is...how slow is it going to be progressing when you read all of the comics as a first-time reader? Do you really want Jeph to rush a particular scenario because it seems to take too long, only to realize that afterward you can read the entire arc in a few minutes and it seems a bit too short? Or would you rather him take his time with the story and let it unfold a bit more slowly, and make it a little more cohesive in the archives than "Okay thisstorythatstorythatstorythisstoryagain"?
I completely agree with this. Thank you for stating it so clearly.