Did we play the same demo?
Probably not. One thing can be dramatically different for different people so it's not too hard to imagine that we took away completely different impressions from the same thing.
For example, the Dark Void demo that most people seemed to find underwhelming at best and god-awful at worst, I found to be incredibly enjoyable and have been playing it somewhat regularly since I downloaded it a week or so ago.
Anyway, one of my main problems with this particular game was that dodging was assigned to the right stick leaving me with my dick in my hand while trying (and failing) to move the camera around (which may or may not even be possible, I can't remember). Maybe my memory is fuzzy and GoW was like this too but I dunno...it just didn't feel good to move Dante around.
You know what, I'm gonna give the demo another go when I get home, see how I feel about it this time around.