Alright kids, there has been hella debate about this in meebo today. So here's the deal.
Currently the poll sits at 23 for NYC and 14 for San Francisco. And five whiny people that want another city. I would say that 23-14 is a pretty sizeable victory, which means that NYC has come out on top. What I propose, as backed by a few people in Meebo, is that we go ahead and decide to do NYC next year (2010) and let the runner up, San Francisco, be the location for the year after (2011). As it stands, there are a ton of people in New England/East Coast, the midwest, eastern Canada, and Europe that want to attend a con, so New York makes the most sense for next year, given the amount of time to save money. And if we decide right now that 2011 will be San Francisco, anyone that thinks they might want to attend will know to start saving for that as well, so maybe a few Europeans can make a west coast meet-up.
Now, if anyone has strong feelings against this decision and good reasons to back up these feelings, please share. We can talk it over if necessary but really, this seems like the best decision.
Go team go!