Nos that I've looked at panel 2 again, I'm pretty sure that's Henry's 'here goes another pair of shoes' look (he's also the only one, judging by the bubbles, who isn't inebriated yet—fixed in the next panel, presumably by more booze). To me, Wil looks as though he's trying to determine who this older guy is who look so much like Marten. It's possible no one's been introduced yet.
Also, even with more proportional eyes, no character in the strip can emote 'distressed' like Hanners.
A final note: we know how Marten feels/felt on the subject (seems like he got a grab in somewhen), we've had opinions from Ellen (Steve's ex.), and now Henry succumbs. Is Faye's ass really that irresistibly smackable? Also, is 'smackable' a word?