Topic: NME votes 'Is This It' as best album of the decade. (Read 23105 times)

StaedlerMars · « **on:** 17 Nov 2009, 12:06 »

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/entertainment/8363726.stm

really?

Really?

Guys, we definitely did a better job than NME.

SleeperCylon · « **Reply #1 on:** 17 Nov 2009, 12:10 »

Is This It is a pretty good album that's way overrated, but UK critics love overrating stuff from the UK, especially if it influenced British mainstream. The Strokes happened to come up at a time where the UK critics got tired of overrating Oasis and needed another above average UK pop rock band to fill the void.

Acclaimedmusic.net, a site that combines all different critics lists, has Funeral #1, Is This It #2, Kid A #3.

BlahBlah · « **Reply #2 on:** 17 Nov 2009, 12:17 »

The strokes are from the US, I'm not sure what you're on about.
I don't think I would include any of those albums, but, if I had been asked "what albums would the NME choose?", I would certainly have gone for a few of those.

Christophe · « **Reply #3 on:** 17 Nov 2009, 12:23 »

Isn't the NME nothing but a bunch of jokes?
AHHHH C'MON FUCK THE STROKES

Alex C · « **Reply #4 on:** 17 Nov 2009, 12:23 »

You guys are missing the big picture here: They had Original Pirate Music in their top 10.

Joseph · « **Reply #5 on:** 17 Nov 2009, 12:29 »

Quote from: Christophe on 17 Nov 2009, 12:23

Isn't the NME nothing but a bunch of jokes?
AHHHH C'MON FUCK THE STROKES

This is a better line than anything that exists in the song you are spoofing. Consider making a recording of your raps.

StaedlerMars · « **Reply #6 on:** 17 Nov 2009, 12:34 »

Yeah, the Strokes are American.

But he does raise a valid point. This country seems to be obsessed with their style of music, and I'm sure lots of bands that are big now here are influenced by Is This It. That and the Libertines, which can be seen from the fact that their album was voted second. Once again, really?

The article mentions that bands like Radiohead voted, I would be much more interested in finding out what their choices would have been.

RallyMonkey · « **Reply #7 on:** 17 Nov 2009, 12:37 »

Seeing as how both bands mentioned are in the top 10 themselves, I can only assume who they voted for.

michaelicious · « **Reply #8 on:** 17 Nov 2009, 12:44 »

Elvis Costello in the NME,
David Bowie in the NME...

Thrillho · « **Reply #9 on:** 17 Nov 2009, 14:03 »

Quote from: SleeperCylon on 17 Nov 2009, 12:10

Acclaimedmusic.net, a site that combines all different critics lists, has Funeral #1

Oh fuck off.

I approve of the top-ten placement of Radiohead's In Rainbows, mind. I think that actually is their best album. I'll waffle on about why some other time when I can be arsed.

I also approve of such a high placing for At The Drive-In.

But at the end of the day, NME can eat a dick. They are trend-following scene whores without an idea between them. I'm aiming to be a music journalist and I've said to my family they have the right to shoot me if I ever write for NME.

KharBevNor · « **Reply #10 on:** 17 Nov 2009, 16:05 »

Guys, it's 2009, why do we care what NME thinks? They haven't been relevant for at least thirty years.

Kill.kenada · « **Reply #11 on:** 17 Nov 2009, 16:51 »

Quote from: KharBevNor on 17 Nov 2009, 16:05

Guys, it's 2009, why do we care what NME thinks? They haven't been relevant for at least thirty years.

Exactly.

I mean, I don't know what people were expecting.

David_Dovey · « **Reply #12 on:** 17 Nov 2009, 16:55 »

I for one was expecting The Arctic Monkeys to win.

mberan42 · « **Reply #13 on:** 19 Nov 2009, 13:26 »

Quote from: Ptommydski on 17 Nov 2009, 15:07

On the plus side, think how apt the number one album's title is now.

That, Tommy, is the most perfect thing one could say in this thread. Bravo.

valley_parade · « **Reply #14 on:** 20 Nov 2009, 03:47 »

Guys, this is a decade in which Boris dropped like 26 amazing albums, and we're talking about Radiohead and the Stokes?

Scandanavian War Machine · « **Reply #15 on:** 20 Nov 2009, 10:44 »

only 26?

sean · « **Reply #16 on:** 20 Nov 2009, 12:55 »

shane that is over two albums a year.

i am sorry that is too many albums for me to care about. plus they play drone.

drone

Reed · « **Reply #17 on:** 20 Nov 2009, 14:48 »

If you think that Boris is only about the drone, then you must not have listened to them enough.

Also, with Boris, there's no such thing as too much.

valley_parade · « **Reply #18 on:** 20 Nov 2009, 15:54 »

Quote from: sean on 20 Nov 2009, 12:55

shane that is over two albums a year.

i am sorry that is too many albums for me to care about

Given singles and collabs, It's honestly around 35 in this decade. Holy shitfucks.

scrubadub · « **Reply #19 on:** 22 Nov 2009, 15:03 »

Quote from: Alex C on 17 Nov 2009, 12:23

You guys are missing the big picture here: They had Original Pirate Music in their top 10.

I hope that wasn't meant as bad thing >_>
That'd be in my top 10 as well, it's The Streets best album.

sean · « **Reply #20 on:** 22 Nov 2009, 21:20 »

Quote from: Reed on 20 Nov 2009, 14:48

If you think that Boris is only about the drone, then you must not have listened to them enough.

Quote from: sean on 20 Nov 2009, 12:55

i am sorry that is too many albums for me to care about.

De_El · « **Reply #21 on:** 22 Nov 2009, 21:43 »

That's silly! It's not hard to know which records are drone and which aren't. And just because there are lots of albums doesn't mean you have to care about all of them. Like, Iggy Pop has a bunch of albums, but it's pretty common practice to only care about 2 of them.

valley_parade · « **Reply #22 on:** 23 Nov 2009, 04:45 »

Quote from: scrubadub on 22 Nov 2009, 15:03

Quote from: Alex C on 17 Nov 2009, 12:23
You guys are missing the big picture here: They had Original Pirate Music in their top 10.
I hope that wasn't meant as bad thing >_>
That'd be in my top 10 as well, it's The Streets best album.

There are more than 9 artists/bands better than The Streets, though.

Thrillho · « **Reply #23 on:** 23 Nov 2009, 08:27 »

Quote from: De_El on 22 Nov 2009, 21:43

That's silly! It's not hard to know which records are drone and which aren't. And just because there are lots of albums doesn't mean you have to care about all of them. Like, Iggy Pop has a bunch of albums, but it's pretty common practice to only care about 2 of them.

Yeah, but I for one get pretty annoyed when people haven't at least given an artist's canon a chance. I wouldn't call myself an Iggy Pop fan based on the one album I've heard. I'd call myself a Stooges fan because I've heard three of the four albums they've made, which is at least a majority. If I only liked a couple of his albums, having only heard those, I'd call myself a fan of those albums rather than the artist.

Reed · « **Reply #24 on:** 23 Nov 2009, 09:26 »

Quote from: sean on 20 Nov 2009, 12:55

i am sorry that is too many albums for me to care about.

If you don't like the drone, then just listen to Heavy fucking Rocks.

scrubadub · « **Reply #25 on:** 23 Nov 2009, 10:22 »

Quote from: valley_parade on 23 Nov 2009, 04:45

Quote from: scrubadub on 22 Nov 2009, 15:03
Quote from: Alex C on 17 Nov 2009, 12:23
You guys are missing the big picture here: They had Original Pirate Music in their top 10.
I hope that wasn't meant as bad thing >_>
That'd be in my top 10 as well, it's The Streets best album.

There are more than 9 artists/bands better than The Streets, though.

Yes there are, I'd rather force screwdrivers into my ears than listen to The Streets new stuff.
On it's individual merit, I would have Original Pirate Material in my top 10. I like an awful lot of bands but for me personally that album never gets old.

Ã¶de · « **Reply #26 on:** 23 Nov 2009, 12:21 »

Quote from: Reed on 23 Nov 2009, 09:26

If you don't like the drone, then just listen to Heavy fucking Rocks.

Quoted for Heavy Rocks \m/

KharBevNor · « **Reply #27 on:** 23 Nov 2009, 12:24 »

Remember to always use Heavy Cement with your Heavy Rocks.

This message bought to you by the British Heavy Cement, Hardcore and Heavy Rock board.

Reed · « **Reply #28 on:** 23 Nov 2009, 18:08 »

Quote from: Ã¶de on 23 Nov 2009, 12:21

Quoted for Heavy Rocks \m/

\o

Seriously, Sean, I will throw this up on the mf thread if you promise to listen to it. This is the album that will convince you that Boris isn't just about drone.

Koremora · « **Reply #29 on:** 23 Nov 2009, 18:19 »

Thirding Heavy Rocks. Shit will make a believer out of you.

Near Lurker · « **Reply #30 on:** 23 Nov 2009, 18:34 »

Thou shalt not read NME.

Lummer · « **Reply #31 on:** 24 Nov 2009, 00:27 »

Quote from: KharBevNor on 17 Nov 2009, 16:05

Guys, it's 2009, why do we care what NME thinks? They haven't been relevant for at least thirty years.

Precisely. This is, after all, the magazine that considers Beth Ditto worthwhile.

valley_parade · « **Reply #32 on:** 24 Nov 2009, 08:47 »

Quote from: Reed on 23 Nov 2009, 09:26

Quote from: sean on 20 Nov 2009, 12:55
i am sorry that is too many albums for me to care about.

If you don't like the drone, then just listen to Heavy fucking Rocks.

Hell, just listen to "1970", nevermind the whole album.

elizaknowswhatshesfor · « **Reply #33 on:** 24 Nov 2009, 15:48 »

Quote from: valley_parade on 24 Nov 2009, 08:47

Quote from: Reed on 23 Nov 2009, 09:26
Quote from: sean on 20 Nov 2009, 12:55
i am sorry that is too many albums for me to care about.

If you don't like the drone, then just listen to Heavy fucking Rocks.

Hell, just listen to "1970", nevermind the whole album.

Forthed/Fifthed. Do it. I met Beth Ditto once, she was lovely. She hit on me.

scarred · « **Reply #34 on:** 30 Nov 2009, 23:39 »

Speaking of the strokes...

http://pitchfork.com/news/37230-strokes-announce-return-to-the-stage/

Lummer · « **Reply #35 on:** 01 Dec 2009, 00:40 »

Guys, "Jane Doe."

Just sayin'..

tricia kidd · « **Reply #36 on:** 13 Dec 2009, 14:34 »

other than the bizarre placing of "is this it" at #1, i actually liked more albums on nme's list than on pitchfork's, i think. i'm sure this makes me a horrible person but eh.

elizaknowswhatshesfor · « **Reply #37 on:** 16 Dec 2009, 09:45 »

Yeah it's from Vice, but it's also pretty true & quite funny:

Quote

As 2009 slams the brakes on, editors the breadth of the land put their feet up on the desk and just serve you some reconstituted yesterdays: top 10/20/30/50/100 countdowns of stuff that happened over the past twelve months. But as you grind your way through one end-of-year music supplement banging on about Animal Collective and Girls after another, your eyes go oblong and there’s a sense of intense, giddying deja vu. Haven’t we seen it all before? In every other magazine/paper/webzine/cereal box? Like, every year? Forever?

Slice through the crap: this is The Only Top 35 Albums of the Year Countdown You’ll Ever Need.

Number 35: Bonkers novelty rap collective. Shows staff have sense of humour.
Number 34: Reserved for Britpop “survivors” who’ve made “their best album in years”.
Number 33: Wacky side-project of big-name band singer, which is a wacky electro-pop concept album about magic animals.
Number 32: Something from Iceland.
Number 31: The name that keeps turning up on every electro/house compilation CD released that year. e.g. Simian Mobile Disco in ‘07.
Number 30: Real authentic alt. country dude who made the album in a cave in the Appalachians/once dated Joanna Newsom.
Number 29: Return of once-derided old-timer who used to symbolise naffness, but has subverted expectations by making an album of honest, brooding ballads with a hip young producer.
Number 28: This space is reserved for Bruce Springsteen if he makes an album in the year of the list.
Number 27: Some dubstep record which actually came out last year but has roundly been heralded as “the sound of the future”.
Number 26: Disappointing third album from previously much-touted act, which is so bad that editorial embarrassment means it’s been crowbarred in here as a Pravda-style exercise in shrinking them slowly rather than dropping them like a hot brick, as would be most appropriate.
Number 25: The band that everyone was tipping as the year’s biggest act in January.
Number 24: You’ve never even heard of this one. You never will. Even as your read the blurb, you find your mind simultaneously erasing the entry.
Number 23: Glitchy and worthy and difficult record you’ve listened to once. Squarepusher, basically.
Number 21: British Sea Power.
Number 20: Token world muso.
Number 19: The band who’ve got a reputation for being “influential”, and have a geographically specific “scene” organised around them that they put on semi-mythical “parties” for at a semi-mythical “venue”. e.g. HEALTH and The Smell.
Number 18: Band who wrote album of songs inspired by the tragic accidental/drug death of their bass player last year. Somewhere the blurb says “courageous”.
Number 17: Fever Ray.
Number 16: Sexy pop act masquerading as “wonky-pop”/”nu-pop”/”underground pop”, which only barely disguises the fact that they’re Lulu with alt. dress sense.
Number 16: Put in a “stunning” performance on Jools Holland.
Number 15: DJ who made “the year’s party-starting mash-up compilation” that you’ve never actually heard at a party that wasn’t put on by media insiders. And never made any of those party-goers do more than pout extra aggressively.
Number 14: Dirty Projectors.
Number 13: Hyper-obscure album everyone was bamboozled into voting for ‘cos Pitchfork gave it a 9.9, despite sounding like every other folk album ever.
Number 12: Rapper facing child sex charges.
Number 11: Dizzee/Chipmunk (pop-grime slot shared on a rotational basis).
Number 10: Album described as a “groundbreaking fusion of dance and rock”.
Number 9: Tape of Bob Dylan coughing up some phlegm in June 1972, found in someone’s attic, dusted off, reissued, and hagiographised in the Sunday papers as a heartbreaking work of staggering genius.
Numbers 8-2: Records that were OK, but no one was mad about them, but no one disliked them much either, so they swum through the middle course, whereas intense records that some people were truly passionate about but others really hated all ultimately failed to make the cut.
Number 1: Coldplay (Q), Arctic Monkeys (NME), Sven Vath (Mixmag), Neil Young (Uncut), Neil Young (Mojo), Neil Young (Classic Rock), Neil Young (Home & Garden), people humming transcendentally over distorted tape loops of concrete being laid (Wire).

Lummer · « **Reply #38 on:** 16 Dec 2009, 10:36 »

Oh god, that was sheer genius, and completely on point. I need to read Vice

valley_parade · « **Reply #39 on:** 16 Dec 2009, 10:36 »

Quote from: elizaknowswhatshesfor on 16 Dec 2009, 09:45

Yeah it's from Vice, but it's also pretty true & quite funny:

Quote
people humming transcendentally over distorted tape loops of concrete being laid (Wire).

I still can't figure out how or why people actually enjoy Animal Collective.

SWOON! at My Gravitas · « **Reply #40 on:** 16 Dec 2009, 13:48 »

They can make really good pop songs, when they put their mind to it.

They usually don't.

Scandanavian War Machine · « **Reply #41 on:** 16 Dec 2009, 13:52 »

MPP has exactly two songs on it that i like. But i like them a fucking lot. ALOT.

everything else i've ever heard from AC has been pretty shitty.

StaedlerMars · « **Reply #42 on:** 16 Dec 2009, 14:07 »

I really like Grass.

Zingoleb · « **Reply #43 on:** 16 Dec 2009, 14:12 »

You are on the marijuana?

elizaknowswhatshesfor · « **Reply #44 on:** 16 Dec 2009, 15:35 »

Quote from: Lummer on 16 Dec 2009, 10:36

Oh god, that was sheer genius, and completely on point. I need to read Vice

Most of the time no. It's just awful, that's a rare little gem. I promise.

Inlander · « **Reply #45 on:** 16 Dec 2009, 15:51 »

Yeah nobody needs to read Vice.

KharBevNor · « **Reply #46 on:** 16 Dec 2009, 16:06 »

Except like, maybe the editor of Vice.

They probably need to read it.

elizaknowswhatshesfor · « **Reply #47 on:** 16 Dec 2009, 16:15 »

They do throw good parties & sometimes have really nice gig photogphy. I know people that work from them & I still agree with Khar. That can't be good.

Inlander · « **Reply #48 on:** 16 Dec 2009, 16:16 »

Quote from: KharBevNor on 16 Dec 2009, 16:06

Except like, maybe the editor of Vice.

They probably need to read it.

Only if you hold to the contention that Vice needs to exist.

a pack of wolves · « **Reply #49 on:** 16 Dec 2009, 18:53 »

Vice isn't just bad. It's genuinely reprehensible.

THESE FORUMS NOW CLOSED (read only)

Author Topic: NME votes 'Is This It' as best album of the decade. (Read 23105 times)

Zingoleb