Nothing will ever beat Silent Hilll.
I did not intend to make it sound like I was saying Amnesia was
the best survival horror game I've ever played, but rather, the best of recent.
Amnesia is a damn well-made game, as well as a successful game in the sense that it accomplishes what it sets out to with aplomb and seat-shitting grandeur, but I would have a hard time wanting to compare it to Silent Hill 2, which is also a triumph of a game, but in a different time and way. Amnesia is also an interestingly made game in that it directly learns from the Penumbra series to the point where I'm suspicious that those games were made largely in preparation for mastering the system they would use here.
That said, you should play Amnesia. If yea be a fan of harrowing experience, thou shalt look none further than Amnesia: The Dark Descent.
Oh wait. Whoa. Sorry Dead Island thread.
I'm sure Dead Island will be awesome and live up to the cool CG short film!