All right, I need to analyze TRVA123's death and what that brings about, but in reviewing Day 1 votes in order I noticed something...
1) henri votes no lynch
2) ricco votes no lynch
3) Games votes lynch nervioso
4) Uni votes EvilDog
5) ces votes EvilDog
6) linds votes no lynch
7) J votes lynch EvilDog
Let's stop here and examine the vote count:
No Lynch: 3; nervioso: 1; EvilDog: 3
What happened next:
8 ) Gareth votes lynch nervioso
His motivation?
Calm down, nervioso. I was only voting for you to try to even the score. Deadlock means no execution. Also, voting for TheEvilDog seemed a little on the nose.
Or at least it did, except she was a tiny little girl.
I italicized the part I want to emphasize. His vote did not deadlock anything. If he wanted no execution, he'd vote no lynch. So while Gareth doesn't appear to be doing anything inherently malicious, he does seem to be trying to actively hold us up AND seems to be fibbing about it. And there's no reason to lie as a villager. Even if you think there's an advantage in doing so, getting caught will cost you (and the town) big time (werewolves should be the only people to have to lie, so if you lie... you must be a
witch werewolf!). This practice is known as "lynch all liars."
Anyway, I hope Gareth will explain himself. Also... please double check me to make sure I counted votes correctly. Even the mod missed a vote last game, it wouldn't be a surprise if I screwed up, so the more eyes we have, the better.
I'll post sometime later with more specific findings per person and any more info I can get from digging through the votes. Once I do, expect to see my vote.