I can't remember how much of this I posted already, so, sorry! I'm having a boring work day and here we are.
I bought the Bioshock HD remastered collection a few months ago and have been slowly working my way through it.
My original plan was to work my way through the games as they came out, finishing with the end of Infinite. In the end, having learned from Guillermo del Toro ('I don't want to do homework in my life'), I decided to bin that order.
I played the first one first, again, and it's still pretty much a masterpiece, but has been somewhat eroded over time with 1. familiarity 2. the fact that whole lot of people love that game and have paid zero attention to any of its ideas.
Being a HD collection, it has all the DLC in it, which was one of the selling points for me. Thank FUCK I didn't pay for the DLCs for the first one when they came out, they're a fucking joke.
I got a few hours into replaying Bioshock 2, the runt of the litter, before hopping to Infinite, which was the one I mainly wanted to play again. Infinite was about exactly as good as I remembered it being, which was a good story trying to get out of a quite disappointing gameplay experience. The DLC was a lot better, although I was extremely aggravated about how incredibly sexed-up Elizabeth was now, given that the character you are playing as is
HER FATHER FOR FUCK'S SAKE
. The second half of the DLC I found very annoying because you play as her and she has a bunch of non-lethal weapons... that may as well just be lethal because the people you use them on never get up.
So I kinda circled back to Bioshock 2, just because I have playthroughs going on in multiple other games and I find it hard to exist with that as an ongoing state. It has a number of significant story problems, and a few gameplay choices that make it feel much more like a sequel rather than a story full of ideas that needed to be explored, but otherwise I think is actually one which has actually improved this time round if anything.
Then, having finished it, I figured I may as well try the DLC, even though it had been pretty poor for the other two - Minerva's Den, it's called. And to my absolute shock, I'm probably close to the end as I have got the achievement for saving all the Little Sisters, but it is some of the most fun I have ever had in a Bioshock game. The early stages are some of the best levels areas I've played in any of the games - I wanted to explore just for exploration's sake, to see what was around the place, rather than to progress. I had severely limited choices about how to defend myself, and it made it genuinely tense and scary in a way that these games haven't been for me in years. Story-wise, it's still shaking out (although I am pretty sure I've seen the twist a mile off), but after getting past the incredibly tense opening sections, I instead now am massively overpowered, which some folks may not like and yes makes it way less challenging, but basically means that the back half of this DLC is pure pleasure centre stimulation. Destroy everyone using any weapon, bring a Big Sister to her knees. This one DLC has basically all the fun gameplay parts of Bioshock you can ask for in a short space.
Who knows whether the ending will ruin it? But whatever, it's been a fun ride along the way!