well let's dig:
# dig ALICEGROVE.COM @NS1.HOVER.COM
[..]
ALICEGROVE.COM.         900     IN      A       66.6.44.4..that's tumblr .. that's a smart idea, but does not work that way (as long tumblr configures your site on their servers ...)
They have nice error pages ..
Jeph, I'm looking forward to the new comic  

 and that you solve out the site stuff, good luck!
But this DNS magic made me smile 

greetings from the depths of lurkverse,
trstn
EDIT  oct 1 2014: Ahh, it's a tumblr page. Nice.