Burn sir, burn.
His early shit was immense, however, much like a highly rated indie badn, things went slightly to shit when he became 'commercial'. Balck & White had nice ideas, but was wrong at a somewhat fundamental level.
Fable I've not played enough to comment, when I did play, it was certainly more fun and involving than most other things of that ilk.
Spore sound v.interesing. I doubt it will cahnge the way that games are made, but hopefully it will prove to be a unique and very involving experience. I have everything crossed, if it is a success it'll be huge, good for Will, bad because there will lots of shitty copies, but still, should be interesting if nothing else.