ok, so, that was good. i liked it. i liked your voice, it fit well with the song. it had an ethereal quality that i thought was nice. the main criticism i would have is the fact that it was just one acoustic guitar. me, personally, i like a little more substance, even if it is just another guitar. that one guitar sounded so...lonely. but i understand that it was probably just you making this.
but, overall, i thought it was a really good cover. btw, i happen to like bad recording sounds. i think they add a certain depth. one of my favorite records of all time is a billy holiday vinyl from 1960-something (it's a reissue) that i picked up at a garage sale for 2 bucks. it's all hissy and poppy and sounds like she was singing through a tin can. it's great.