I listened to Apologies To The Queen Mary this afternoon, and I was musing on Wolf Parade, and then just a few minutes ago I saw Jeph's newspost and.... well, I thought the matter should be discussed among us forum dwellers.
A friend sent me the album and their EP about a month or so ago. He'd been hyping them up alot for me, telling me I'd love them and whatnot... but I never really listened to it past a few scans of each song. Upon that first pass, I found the singer's voice to be grating and the music to be generic jangly indie folk/rock.
Aaaand...that first impression was about right.
Now, I know this is an obvious and probably unfair comparison, but I'd be remiss not mention that the singer's voice is like a deeper, more growly version of CYHSY's vocalist. Thing is, there's a difference there that, for me, makes a huge difference. i.e. I like CYHSY's vocals; I generally do not like Wolf Parade's. That's obviously going to be a galvanizing factor when it comes bands with odd vocalists.
I can say that I really like the song "This Heart's On Fire", but that's mainly because I sense a lot more restraint in the vocalist's voice. It sounds... prettier, for lack of a better term. It's more listenable to me.
Of course, there's more to a band than the vocalist, and I will say that I enjoy Wolf Parade's instrumentation for the most part. The little twee-like electronic flourishes are nice decoration for the jangly, almost raw folk/rock Parade play.
Overall... I think they're a decent outfit, but nowhere near deserving of all the hype they've been getting.
Thoughts?