I think that they did quite well on their list. In the modern age of ROMness, it's pretty much guaranteed that any gamer worth their papier mache art class Triforce has played nearly every one of those games, and owned at least fifty percent of them. I think I saw maybe fifteen games on that list that I haven't owned at one time or another, including Bill and Ted. Their choice for the Top Ten was well done, though I would personally contest SMB 3 being #1, but that's just me.
BTW, after reading this list, I bookmarked the site and I've been looking through it- brilliant! Lots of, like, really funny game reviews and things.