I got Pavement's "Slanted..." last year after hearing all the hype (granted a little late).
Summer Babe is a nice song, Zurich is Stained is pretty good too, but to me it seems like they've got a couple of Velvet Underground songs and run them through a grungulator.
On the slightly off-topic of dissapointing albums, did anybody else get MBV's Loveless, adore it, then get Isn't Anything and find it almost unlistenably embarrassing? I don't know, maybe it's a serious grower.