Nope, not buying it. Most glaringly, the bass is buried throughout the album, which renders "Only Shallow" and "Soon" almost impotent unless you manually turn up the bass on your stereo. I've played those songs on good stereos, bad stereos, on radio, and in large dance clubs and the only time I've gotten them to properly kick ass like they should has been in a club, when I turned up the volume and pumped the bass.
And normally I am the kind of person who flips out if somebody puts their equalizers on anything but flat out of respect for the artists.
Eh, I thought the whole point of shoegaze was to be washed out. I think "Only Shallow" and "Soon" are amazing as they are; it'd be so cool to hear "Soon" in a DJ set (Andrew Weatherall did a remix of it, incidentally).
Oh, and has anyone heard the song "Drive It All Over Me" on the
You Made It Realise EP? Makes me wonder if MBV's just as good as a (somewhat distorted) indie pop band.
Also, to be honest, I'm more of a Slowdive guy. Have you guys heard Morr's
Blue Skied 'An Clear comp? I really like Lali Puna's take on "40 Days"