carissa's wierd - so you wanna be a superhero
So, it starts out all wandering with distinct melody, but a bunch of stuff going on. The acoustic guitar sounds really poor, though. It sounds sloppy (not just rhythmically, it's also not consistent in volume and attack). It also sounds like trying to play metal rhythm guitar on an acoustic. Probably because it's only using power chords, which leads to a boring an anemic sound. I like that other guitar bit (the one with a bunch of delay on it), but I don't want to hear it the entire song. It builds a little bit, but only in volume. Nothing changes harmonically, melodically or rhythmically, except it sped up a little. Judging by the quality of the acoustic guitar player, I don't think that was intentional. The vocal melody isn't too bad, but the singer doesn't know how to sing softly, so her voice just sounds weak and unsupported. The entire track just sounds kind of flaccid and uninteresting. Plus, they really shouldn't have ended it that way. It just kind of fizzles.
3/10 - For excessive underproduction and lack of variety.
I was going to post some Webern, but the pianist on the recording I have isn't very good. So, then I was going to put up some Michael Daugherty, but the piece I want to put up is a verly large file (high quality rip), and I don't have the CD with me because I dropped it off at my college radio station to get uploaded so I can play it on air. Alas, I'm stuck with John Adams (sorry it's so large, the other one was larger):
John Adams - Lollapalooza