Fun Stuff > ENJOY
harry potter and the half blood prince - WITH SPOILERS
JJMitchell:
--- Quote from: Tactical Error ---I just thought of another small thing to support the wild theory of Dumbledore's not being dead. Remember in Goblet of Fire that Moody said you have to really mean it for the Avada Kedavra curse to work. Well, Snape could have cast the spell without the desire to kill Dumbledore and to everyone watching it wouldn't look any different. But that's just a crazy theory, don't listen to me, but it would fit into Rowlings style of planting ideas in earlier books.
--- End quote ---
I would agree that it fits Rowlings style but I think he is dead for good.
LeeZion:
>>I just thought of another small thing to support the wild theory of Dumbledore's not being dead. Remember in Goblet of Fire that Moody said you have to really mean it for the Avada Kedavra curse to work. Well, Snape could have cast the spell without the desire to kill Dumbledore and to everyone watching it wouldn't look any different.<<
In which case, Snape would be dead because of the Unbreakable Vow
>>I would agree that it fits Rowlings style but I think he is dead for good.<<
My guess is Harry will have a heart-to-heart with Dumbledore's portrait at some point in the book.
yelley:
i agree about the portrait of dumbledore thing.
by the way, does she ever go into detail about how that works and who can be portrait-ized? like could sirius talk to harry through a portrait?
est:
maybe he'll just come back and hang with the rest of the ghosts at Hogwarts, giving people advice, etc.
KTkat:
I like that theory, but I believe someone pointed out before that people only become ghosts if they're afraid to cross over. Which I highly doubt of Dumbledore.
Plus, Harry said he's not going back to Hogwarts, so that wouldn't really be helpful to him.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version