So I found this list of songs I would "never get sick of" on my Myspace. From December of 2005. It is HILARIOUS.
0) 30 Seconds to Mars- Buddha for Mary
1) A Perfect Circle- Weak and Powerless
2) Apartment 26- Give Me More
3) The Ataris- The Saddest Song (Acoustic)
4) Audiovent- Rain
5) Ben Jelen- Come On
6) Breaking Benjamin- Forget It
7) The Calling- Stigmatized
Cold- No One
9) Disturbed- Darkness
10) Eating Divas- Fear
11) Elbow- Grace Under Pressure
12) Finch- Ender
13) Flaw- Wait For Me
14) Graham Bickley- Music of the Night
15) Grey Daze- Soul Song
16) hed (PE)- Bartneder
17) Howie Day- Come Lay Down
18) Incubus- 11 A.M.
19) Jamie Cullum- Blame it on My Youth
20) Jet- Timothy
21) Johnnyrook- Swallow Your Tears
22) Jonny Lang- Cherry Red Wine
23) Josh Groban- Mi Mancherai
24) Keane- She Has No Time
25) The Killers- Andy, You're a Star
26) Muse- Blackout
27) Orgy- Eva
28) Reik- Como Me Duele
29) Remy Zero- Fair
30) Revis- Seven
31) Seconds Before- Aftershave and Breathmints
32) Seether- Gasoline
33) Sevendust- Separate
34) Shearwater- Let the Bombs Fall (I Can't Wait)
35) Slipknot- Vermillion
36) Snow Patrol- Spitting Games
37) Stone Sour- Inhale
38) Switchfoot- Twenty-Four
39) Tool- Schism
40) Trust Company- Hover
41) Zero 7- In the Waiting Line