THESE FORUMS NOW CLOSED (read only)

  • 28 Apr 2024, 14:24
  • Welcome, Guest
Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

Poll

What do we have left to look forward to?

Gloomy Tai at the library
- 33 (43.4%)
Dora trying to make up with her GF
- 14 (18.4%)
Hannelore seeking vengeance on Juicy
- 8 (10.5%)
Marigold seeking medical aid
- 2 (2.6%)
Pintsize having an existential crisis
- 11 (14.5%)
Faye learning that 'creepy' is a state of mind
- 8 (10.5%)

Total Members Voted: 71

Voting closed: 10 Mar 2015, 08:40


Pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5 6 ... 12   Go Down

Author Topic: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)  (Read 85532 times)

FunkyTuba

  • Scrabble hacker
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1,297
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #150 on: 09 Mar 2015, 11:21 »


His slowly backing away, never breaking eye contact and locking himself in the office really doesn't strike me as a 'NOPE'. It's more like someone who just saw a big, dangerous animal about to strike and is slowly backing away from the danger.

Not trying to be pedantic or overly sarcastic here, but I don't understand the difference between the two.

Perhaps I'm not a good enough student of The Way of Nope to see the subtleties involved, please enlighten me?
Logged

chaospersonified

  • Duck attack survivor
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1,721
  • My brain's wired weird
    • My art blog
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #151 on: 09 Mar 2015, 11:26 »


His slowly backing away, never breaking eye contact and locking himself in the office really doesn't strike me as a 'NOPE'. It's more like someone who just saw a big, dangerous animal about to strike and is slowly backing away from the danger.

Not trying to be pedantic or overly sarcastic here, but I don't understand the difference between the two.

Perhaps I'm not a good enough student of The Way of Nope to see the subtleties involved, please enlighten me?

I think it's the difference between fear of hurting himself or someone else, and not caring enough about his friends to try and help
Logged
There's at least a 27% chance I'm full of shit
synesthetictranslations.tumblr.com
AlsoPersonifyingChaos

Neko_Ali

  • Global Moderator
  • ASDFSFAALYG8A@*& ^$%O
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 4,510
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #152 on: 09 Mar 2015, 11:28 »

Chaospersonified beat me to it but yeah. Basically the distinction I was making was that Marten's reaction seemed more instinctual reaction than him rationally decided he didn't want to be involved. The difference of "OH SHIT! A BEAR!" and "Not my circus, not my monkies. I'm out of here."
Logged

Rghfrgl

  • 1-800-SCABIES
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 859
  • *Crunch* *Crunch* *Crunch*
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #153 on: 09 Mar 2015, 11:32 »

The difference of "OH SHIT! A BEAR!" and "Not my circus, not my monkies. I'm out of here."

THAT'S what Marten sees. The bear that put Faye in the hospital isn't done. He's going to strike out at Faye's loved ones to draw her out for the rematch.
Logged

swapna

  • Curry sauce
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 295
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #154 on: 09 Mar 2015, 11:49 »


That's not an Allosaurus, that's a Velociraptor and the Raptor is Claire.
(click to show/hide)
That... is kind of disturbing  :psyduck:
Can't stop looking o.O
« Last Edit: 10 Mar 2015, 01:05 by pwhodges »
Logged

Oenone

  • FIGHT YOU
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 406
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #155 on: 09 Mar 2015, 12:30 »

I want him to have noped  so hard, he somehow ends up in Amherst in front of Dora's new apartment, where she's crying by herself because that's safer than crying in front of people.
Logged

Cattus

  • Plantmonster
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 35
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #156 on: 09 Mar 2015, 13:01 »

I think it's pretty clear what just happened here.  Marten has recently gotten into a happy place with Claire.  While this has been happening, the relationships of his closest friends have gone into the crapper.  He is zoning out, suffering from WTF syndrome.  And to top it off, he's at the core of this all - best buds and roomie with Faye, ex-bf of Dora, good friend and minion of Tai.  He's just hoping that Hanners and Marigold don't come to blows.  Bad Karma all around.  How will things settle out in the end?  I suspect things will get worse before they get better.
But better they WILL get - I'm banking on it.  It's FigNewton's law of the conservation of feels.  Positive feels will eventually balance all the negative feels until we get to feels equilibrium - because of the ever increasing entropy of feels.
Logged

chaospersonified

  • Duck attack survivor
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1,721
  • My brain's wired weird
    • My art blog
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #157 on: 09 Mar 2015, 13:11 »

I think it's pretty clear what just happened here.  Marten has recently gotten into a happy place with Claire.  While this has been happening, the relationships of his closest friends have gone into the crapper.  He is zoning out, suffering from WTF syndrome.  And to top it off, he's at the core of this all - best buds and roomie with Faye, ex-bf of Dora, good friend and minion of Tai.  He's just hoping that Hanners and Marigold don't come to blows.  Bad Karma all around.  How will things settle out in the end?  I suspect things will get worse before they get better.
But better they WILL get - I'm banking on it.  It's FigNewton's law of the conservation of feels.  Positive feels will eventually balance all the negative feels until we get to feels equilibrium - because of the ever increasing entropy of feels.

*blink blink* Hanners and Marigold weren't IN today's strip, though? And in the last strip, they didn't seem to have nearly the falling out everyone was predicting for them last week. Hanners was angry, then they were talking about farting, and all seemed okay between them. The scene shifted to Marten and Tai, then, so presumably, those two strips were just filler.
Logged
There's at least a 27% chance I'm full of shit
synesthetictranslations.tumblr.com
AlsoPersonifyingChaos

TheEvilDog

  • Guest
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #158 on: 09 Mar 2015, 13:55 »

Here's the thing though, Marten has been in the exact same position that Tai now finds herself. Hindsight really is 20/20 and right now, Marten has crystal clear vision. He knows all the warning signs, they are plastered everywhere. There might as well be giant flashing lights with guards posted to divert people from the upcoming crash. From Marten's perspective, if he tried to offer any advice or help in any way, he'd just end up taking the controls of a runaway train that's about to fly off the tracks.

No matter what happens now, someone is going to be hurt, someone is going to cry. By removing himself from the situation, Marten has made sure he can't be made a scapegoat by anyone if the crap does hit the fan.
Logged

cesariojpn

  • Scrabble hacker
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1,392
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #159 on: 09 Mar 2015, 13:56 »

The issue of readers having unrealistic expectations of perfection has been brought up a couple of times in the past week. That's not why there are objections to the way certain characters are handling their business. When we consume fiction and react to fictional characters, we're (generally) not holding them to an unrealistic standard of perfection, but we do compare them to the real world, particularly when the characters are well-rounded, realistic, and relate-able.

To that end, we don't ask them to be perfect, but we do ask: are their actions, attitudes, and motives understandable? Reasonable? Sympathetic? That's what shapes our reactions to the characters and their role in the plot.

We can't ask fictional characters to not be perfect. Then again, we can't ask the creator of said characters to bend to the whim of the fandom. HOWEVER, said creator obviously cannot ignore the fandom that have genuine criticism and gripes about how a story or characters are progressing.
« Last Edit: 09 Mar 2015, 15:00 by cesariojpn »
Logged

aliensporebomb

  • Larger than most fish
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 119
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #160 on: 09 Mar 2015, 14:08 »

Marten had the look of post-breakup PTSD deja vu!  Poor guy! 
Logged

Is it cold in here?

  • Administrator
  • Awakened
  • ******
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 25,163
  • He/him/his pronouns
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #161 on: 09 Mar 2015, 14:35 »

One thing Marten could do is to give Tai the Cliff Notes on Dora's relationship history. Of course that might enrage Dora.
Logged
Thank you, Dr. Karikó.

chaospersonified

  • Duck attack survivor
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1,721
  • My brain's wired weird
    • My art blog
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #162 on: 09 Mar 2015, 14:44 »

One thing Marten could do is to give Tai the Cliff Notes on Dora's relationship history. Of course that might enrage Dora.

Which he knows, hence the back-away-slowly strategy.

Basically, I'm on his side here.  Nothing helpful Marten could say in this instance would do anything but anger someone. He probably could have said something to that effect, but that's at the risk of Tai jumping at him and begging him for more information and getting irritated if he didn't give it.

Logged
There's at least a 27% chance I'm full of shit
synesthetictranslations.tumblr.com
AlsoPersonifyingChaos

Is it cold in here?

  • Administrator
  • Awakened
  • ******
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 25,163
  • He/him/his pronouns
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #163 on: 09 Mar 2015, 14:49 »

Here's a funny interpretation.

We don't really see what's on the other side of the door.

Did Marten just lock himself in a closet?
Logged
Thank you, Dr. Karikó.

Pilchard123

  • Older than Moses
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 4,131
  • I always name them Bitey.
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #164 on: 09 Mar 2015, 14:51 »

Didn't the raptor pic get removed from a previous thread?
Logged
Piglet wondered how it was that every conversation with Eeyore seemed to go wrong.

hedgie

  • Methuselah's mentor
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 5,382
  • No Pasarán!
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #165 on: 09 Mar 2015, 14:55 »

It did.  IIRC, it was posted with entirely innocent intentions, but its source, being a nasty cesspit made it a bit problematic.
Logged
"The highest treason in the USA is to say Americans are not loved, no matter where they are, no matter what they are doing there." -- Vonnegut

Zebediah

  • Born in a Nalgene bottle
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3,278
  • I'm a bandicoot!
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #166 on: 09 Mar 2015, 15:00 »

Marten locked Tai in the office. Of course the latch is on her side so she can get out easily, but it will slow her down for a crucial second or two while he runs for the front door.
Logged
"It CAN'T be a bad decision, it resulted in CARROT CAKE!"

Pilchard123

  • Older than Moses
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 4,131
  • I always name them Bitey.
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #167 on: 09 Mar 2015, 15:07 »

She's obviously a student of the Havelock Vetinari school of door design.
Logged
Piglet wondered how it was that every conversation with Eeyore seemed to go wrong.

Is it cold in here?

  • Administrator
  • Awakened
  • ******
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 25,163
  • He/him/his pronouns
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #168 on: 09 Mar 2015, 15:08 »

The mods are hypervigilant about some issues. If there's a complaint about the "clever girl" picture it will disappear again.

I'm not up on meme meanings but something disquieting came up when I researched it.
Logged
Thank you, Dr. Karikó.

ReindeerFlotilla

  • Scrabble hacker
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1,339
  • All Your Marriage Are Belong to Everyone
    • Singular Blues
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #169 on: 09 Mar 2015, 15:15 »

The issue of readers having unrealistic expectations of perfection has been brought up a couple of times in the past week. That's not why there are objections to the way certain characters are handling their business. When we consume fiction and react to fictional characters, we're (generally) not holding them to an unrealistic standard of perfection, but we do compare them to the real world, particularly when the characters are well-rounded, realistic, and relate-able.

To that end, we don't ask them to be perfect, but we do ask: are their actions, attitudes, and motives understandable? Reasonable? Sympathetic? That's what shapes our reactions to the characters and their role in the plot.

We can't ask fictional characters to not be perfect. Then again, we can't ask the creator of said characters to bend to the whim of the fandom. HOWEVER, said creator obviously cannot ignore the fandom that have genuine criticism and gripes about how a story or characters are progressing.

Really? I see you point. Ignoring gripes and going in directions that upset fandom really killed George Lucas's career and made the Star Wars brand worth... 4 billion when sold to Disney.

Yeah. So a creator can definitely ignore the fandom.

MIDICHLORIANS MOFOS!

grez

  • Plantmonster
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 29
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #170 on: 09 Mar 2015, 16:42 »

The issue of readers having unrealistic expectations of perfection has been brought up a couple of times in the past week. That's not why there are objections to the way certain characters are handling their business. When we consume fiction and react to fictional characters, we're (generally) not holding them to an unrealistic standard of perfection, but we do compare them to the real world, particularly when the characters are well-rounded, realistic, and relate-able.

To that end, we don't ask them to be perfect, but we do ask: are their actions, attitudes, and motives understandable? Reasonable? Sympathetic? That's what shapes our reactions to the characters and their role in the plot.

We can't ask fictional characters to not be perfect. Then again, we can't ask the creator of said characters to bend to the whim of the fandom. HOWEVER, said creator obviously cannot ignore the fandom that have genuine criticism and gripes about how a story or characters are progressing.

Err... yes, yes they can. The criticism can be genuine and the gripes can be gripey, but the creator can ignore whatever the heck they want to. It may not be wise - it may even be stupid in some cases - but it's their right as creator to bend, break, mish, mash, and do whatever to their story.
Logged

ASB84

  • Guest
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #171 on: 09 Mar 2015, 16:48 »

It's not about catering to the fanbase, though. It's about having characters that the audience becomes invested in and subsequently react to, in accordance with their own perceptions. I don't think anyone expects the cast of QC to always say or do the right thing - the strip would be pretty bland and boring if they did - but what the characters do still resonates with us the audience, and we evaluate the proceedings in accordance to what we each find understandable, reasonable, and sympathetic.

Sometimes there's multiple layers to that. Take Sven's recent appearance, for instance. It's understandable and reasonable that he'd develop romantic feelings for Faye, and we can sympathise with the fact that it causes him some confusion as he finds himself in unfamiliar territory. However, his attitude towards the situation, perception of himself as the protagonist of a romantic comedy, and expectations of Faye are not reasonable and do not make him sympathetic. Arguably understandable, given he's uncharacteristically out of his depth, but it fails on the other counts.
Logged

ReindeerFlotilla

  • Scrabble hacker
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1,339
  • All Your Marriage Are Belong to Everyone
    • Singular Blues
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #172 on: 09 Mar 2015, 17:35 »

John Grisham.

I should explain.

IMO, Grisham's protagonists have been uniformly detestable people. I was once trapped in a dull place with nothing to keep my sanity but a stack of his novels. I finished none of them.

I could argue that Grisham had failed in the characterization department. Except, best selling author, a multitude of film adaptations.

You simply can't argue that a characterization fails because you don't feel sympathy for the character's position. You can poll to find out if a supermajority finds the character wildly unrealistic or unreadable, but being unlikable is actually a valid way to be a character. Being addictively unlikabe is a kind of characterization super-combo finish.

I have never related to fictional Jerry Seinfeld, or Greg House, or Sherlock Holmes, or the Doctor, or Kara Thrace, or the Goddamn Batman. I'm not sure they are relatable characters. Each was (or is), in their own way, so the best at what they do, you expect something to go "snikt." They are watchable. Being watchable can cover for any amount of realism fail.

IMO, Marten had a watchable moment. Sven has been generally watchable. Every time he's skated close to relatability, he's done something to dance it back, but in a way the supported the humor of the comic. But all of that is opinion.

cesariojpn

  • Scrabble hacker
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1,392
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #173 on: 09 Mar 2015, 17:51 »

The mods are hypervigilant about some issues. If there's a complaint about the "clever girl" picture it will disappear again.

I'm not up on meme meanings but something disquieting came up when I researched it.

Oh, you saw the ED and Know Your Meme articles about the strip, huh? Like the one that makes fun of the room myself.

You simply can't argue that a characterization fails because you don't feel sympathy for the character's position.

I point to Clariten as a counter-argument to this. The strips we've been given concerning Clariten have been devoid of info of why Marten has gone from a string of failed relationships with Females to him going out with a Transgendered person. It's pretty much "I like you, let's go out." Okay, WHY?!?!?! Is he just sick and tired of being the whipping boy with females that he thinks maybe going non-traditional would be a better shot at happiness? Is it because his childhood with Veronica exposing him to alternative lifestyles kinda gave him a more open mind when it comes to such things? Or some other obtuse reason?   
« Last Edit: 09 Mar 2015, 18:04 by cesariojpn »
Logged

ASB84

  • Guest
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #174 on: 09 Mar 2015, 17:59 »

You simply can't argue that a characterization fails because you don't feel sympathy for the character's position.

I never did.

I was talking about our reaction as readers, and the "What, do you expect (character) to be perfect?" argument that's come up a few times in the past week or so. I doubt anyone's holding the characters to that kind of standard, but our reactions from behind the fourth wall are still driven by how we perceive their words, actions, and motives. We may not always agree with their decisions and course of action, but we can understand it, see reason in it, sympathise with it.

Of course, that's stretching it out and breaking it down in a lengthier manner than we do when we're reading the comics. We make that analysis in an instant, deciding whether or not we agree with a character, and even if we don't, whether we can at least see their point of view. I'm not talking about the quality of the character, whether it succeeds or fails; in fact, if a character is eliciting a response from the audience, I think they're successful by default. I'm talking about our reactions to characters, how they push our buttons, whether we're cheering or jeering them, what we think of the things they're saying and doing when there's a grey area. Reactions to the events of the story and how it makes us feel, not whether we think the characters succeed or fail from a narrative point of view. That's another discussion entirely, as is whether or not the characters are entertaining (or as you said, watchable).
Logged

ReindeerFlotilla

  • Scrabble hacker
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1,339
  • All Your Marriage Are Belong to Everyone
    • Singular Blues
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #175 on: 09 Mar 2015, 18:19 »

I'm not sure I see the distinction. I don't claim there isn't one. I just don't see it.

Humans are emotional beasts. We like to lie to ourselves and each other, by claiming we are rational. But rationality is pretty much a post hoc analysis of our feelings--or a justification. I say pretty much because how we rationalize does set us up for what we feel next. But it seems scientifically solid to say the species is mostly feels. To be otherwise, you'd have to know the mind works like, believe it, and be ever vigilant about how the world view you construct with each thought will impact you emotionally.


That sounds exhausting.

So, when you say quality of the character, that sounds like an emotional judgment. When you compare that to "our reactions" that sounds like the same thing. Or feels like it. I'm admitting my biases may blind me to line that separates those two evaluations.

When I talk about a supermajority, I mean things like the uncanny valley. We wouldn't even know it existed, IMO, if some people weren't a little less sensitive to its slope. They make a thing and it looks fine to them, but a supermajority of us find it feels wrong. Too lifelike, but not lifelike enough. It's not a well defined edge, but a zone where most of us humans are having similar reactions. So, while I can see how that might sound like a discussion of an objective property, or way of evaluating a character, it all subjective. It's just a widely shared subjective view point.

And that was way too much text to say the same thing I said in the first line.

Gladstone

  • The Tickler
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 946
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #176 on: 09 Mar 2015, 18:21 »

I point to Clariten as a counter-argument to this. The strips we've been given concerning Clariten have been devoid of info of why Marten has gone from a string of failed relationships with Females to him going out with a Transgendered person. It's pretty much "I like you, let's go out." Okay, WHY?!?!?! Is he just sick and tired of being the whipping boy with females that he thinks maybe going non-traditional would be a better shot at happiness? Is it because his childhood with Veronica exposing him to alternative lifestyles kinda gave him a more open mind when it comes to such things? Or some other obtuse reason?   

Oh, right, because Marten realizing he likes Claire as a person and doesn't consider her trans status to be a deal-breaker or a barrier to a potential relationship with her is completely impossible and unrealistic, amiright?  It has to Mean Something, because there's NO POSSIBLE WAY Marten would want to go out with a trans woman unless he realized that he has absolutely no hope of ever dating another cis woman again.  Time to settle for second-best!  Level up!  Or level down!  Or something ridiculous like that!

*headdesk*

Edit: Neko_Ali said it better below.  Read that comment instead.

Also, comic.  Marten could've just said in the first place that he didn't want to get involved; that would've saved us several pages of discussion.  Harrumph.

Logged
You have not experienced Questionable Content until you have read it in the original Klingon.

Neko_Ali

  • Global Moderator
  • ASDFSFAALYG8A@*& ^$%O
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 4,510
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #177 on: 09 Mar 2015, 18:23 »

I point to Clariten as a counter-argument to this. The strips we've been given concerning Clariten have been devoid of info of why Marten has gone from a string of failed relationships with Females to him going out with a Transgendered person. It's pretty much "I like you, let's go out." Okay, WHY?!?!?! Is he just sick and tired of being the whipping boy with females that he thinks maybe going non-traditional would be a better shot at happiness? Is it because his childhood with Veronica exposing him to alternative lifestyles kinda gave him a more open mind when it comes to such things? Or some other obtuse reason?   

This sounds more like projection to me. There has been absolutely no indication in comic that Marten is dating Claire because she's trans. He has never shown any indication of thinking of her as anything other than another girl in hs life. Putting forth the idea that there are (cis) females and trans females is a rather touchy thing. They work together, they hang out together, they went on a road trip and shared a room together. Mutual attraction developed. For some people, for whatever reason, knowing someone is trans is just a non-issue. Look at his initial reaction when Claire told him. It was basically. "Oh, okay cool. Let's head inside."
Logged

wlewisiii

  • Bizarre cantaloupe phobia
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 235
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #178 on: 09 Mar 2015, 18:33 »

You should have kept up with the Nope Marten...
Logged
Emily is the Avatar.

jwhouk

  • Awakened
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11,022
  • The Valley of the Sun
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #179 on: 09 Mar 2015, 18:36 »

I think projection is the number one cause of issues on this forum - but that may just be me...  :claireface:

EDIT: Poor Marten. This time, make like Ardent and RUN.
Logged
"Character is what you are in the Dark." - D.L. Moody
There is no joke that can be made online without someone being offended by it.
Life's too short to be ashamed of how you were born.
Just another Joe like 46

Aziraphale

  • Duck attack survivor
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1,529
  • Extra Medium
    • The First 10,000
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #180 on: 09 Mar 2015, 18:39 »

cesariojpn, for as long as I've been on these boards -- not as long as a lot of people, certainly, but long enough -- you've had a bug up your ass over Claire, and all the more so since she and Marten got together. What is your issue, exactly? Despite all evidence to the contrary (in the comic, in comments and information from other forum members, and a shit-ton of information available out in the world at large), you keep insisting that there's something "off" about Claire, and that there must, by extension, be some deep Freudian thing going on with Marten for being able to befriend and subsequently fall for someone, rather than finding them somehow squicky.

So it bears asking: What is so inexplicable to you that someone could fall in love with a trans* person? Put differently, what is your major malfunction?
Logged
May goldfish leave Lincoln Logs in your sock drawer.

ReindeerFlotilla

  • Scrabble hacker
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1,339
  • All Your Marriage Are Belong to Everyone
    • Singular Blues
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #181 on: 09 Mar 2015, 18:39 »

I point to Clariten as a counter-argument to this. The strips we've been given concerning Clariten have been devoid of info of why Marten has gone from a string of failed relationships with Females to him going out with a Transgendered person. It's pretty much "I like you, let's go out." Okay, WHY?!?!?! Is he just sick and tired of being the whipping boy with females that he thinks maybe going non-traditional would be a better shot at happiness? Is it because his childhood with Veronica exposing him to alternative lifestyles kinda gave him a more open mind when it comes to such things? Or some other obtuse reason?   

Why?

Why not.

Consider this:

1. A person who identifies as straight probably never thought about that in any detail. Society doesn't challenge straightness. If this person has had prior relationships, they are overwhelming likely to have had relationships with people who are biologically the opposite sex.

2. A person who identifies as straight can accept a transperson's gender without questioning it. I have never (no really) questioned a transperson's gender. The biggest issue I have, so far is one person who has been fairly random in they way the self refer so I'm not clear on whether this person is trans, CD, or gender queer. And I don't care, but it does lead to some pronoun mixing in my head which is a first for me.

3. SYLOGISM TIME!!!!!!!!! Should a person who meets conditions 1 and 2 enter a relationship with a transperson, that relationship overwhelmingly likely be after having a string of failed relationships with people who are biologically the opposite sex. (This bars the minority who have had a string of relationship that all ended in the death of their partner.)

It is, in fact, utterly unremarkable that Marten's first relationship with a transwoman follows a string of failed relationships with ciswomen. It's nearly tautological, akin to saying wet things are wet.

Gladstone

  • The Tickler
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 946
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #182 on: 09 Mar 2015, 18:44 »

EDIT: Poor Marten. This time, make like Ardent and RUN.

Bad idea.  There's always a bigger fish.  Has George Lucas taught us nothing?
Logged
You have not experienced Questionable Content until you have read it in the original Klingon.

Is it cold in here?

  • Administrator
  • Awakened
  • ******
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 25,163
  • He/him/his pronouns
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #183 on: 09 Mar 2015, 18:48 »

Global Moderator Comment There are many excellent reasons, scientific and humane both, to treat trans women as simply women. There are only bad reasons to do otherwise outside a doctor's examining room. In addition, there is a formal forum rule on the subject more specific than the general civility rule.
Logged
Thank you, Dr. Karikó.

TheEvilDog

  • Guest
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #184 on: 09 Mar 2015, 18:50 »

Aaaaaaaand now he's caught.
Aaaaaaaand Tai might end up disappointed.
Aaaaaaaand for some reason, I keep writing Asssssss.
Logged

DonInKansas

  • FIGHT YOU
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 427
  • Grammar Nazi
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #185 on: 09 Mar 2015, 18:51 »

Marten is going to find Hannelore and ask for a lift to her dad's space station so that he can nope this from orbit.

It's the only way to be sure.
Logged
I mean, it would still suck, but at least it would suck creatively.

cesium133

  • Preventing third impact
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 6,148
  • Has a fucked-up browser history
    • Cesium Comics
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #186 on: 09 Mar 2015, 18:52 »

I keep writing Asssssss.
Buuuuuttts!
Logged
The nerdy comic I update sometimes: Cesium Comics

Unofficial character tag thingy for QC

ASB84

  • Guest
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #187 on: 09 Mar 2015, 18:56 »

I'm not sure I see the distinction. I don't claim there isn't one. I just don't see it.

Determining whether or not a character succeeds or fails from a narrative point of view is a more academic discussion. Reacting to the plot and talking about what the characters are doing is a more casual, "water cooler" type of conversation. That's how I'd sum up the distinction.

As I said, I'm not saying that a character's actions being understandable, sympathetic, or reasonable indicate a better quality of character. Of course, I would say that a well-written character will engage us, and as we watch the story unfold, our feelings and reactions are governed by the aforementioned criteria. It is, as I said, something that we decide almost instantly upon reading dialogue and seeing the action take place. It's only when we discuss it later, put those thoughts and opinions into words, that it becomes a lengthier breakdown.

When fiction has engaged us, it plays out before us or in our minds as though the events are actually taking place. We're focusing on the experience rather than the inner workings, though we may well have an awareness of them. Characters stimulate us and provoke reactions: "Man, he's a jerk. I want to see him get his comeuppance!", "I know she's technically the villain, but her backstory is pretty tragic, I actually feel kind of sorry for her", "He may technically be the hero, but he sure doesn't act like one!", "I don't agree with their methods, but you can understand how it got to this point", "Their intentions are good, but their actions are short-sighted"...and so on.

So, take Marten backing out of the room. One reaction is "Whoa, that wasn't cool, he just cut and run when a friend of his needed help and support." A counterpoint raised to that was essentially "Well, it's not fair to criticise him for that, what, do you expect him to be perfect?" My counterpoint to that is that no, we're not expecting perfection; however, we do recognise these scenarios, we have our own ideas of what's appropriate and what isn't, what we make of what we see, and how understandable, reasonable, and sympathetic it is to us...which may or may not gel with how agreeable we find the characters to be. In other words, "That wasn't the best thing to do, but I understand why he did it".

It has nothing to do with the construction of the character, whether it's failing or not. That's meta-level stuff. I'm talking about following along with the events in-universe, observing what's going on from behind the fourth wall as if it's actually happening, and having a reaction and opinion on the events that are taking place. That's the distinction.
Logged

mary tyler murder

  • Plantmonster
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 28
  • lights up the world with her
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #188 on: 09 Mar 2015, 19:01 »

Ugh, back to Tai being a rotten, selfish, emotionally abusive gutterdyke.

I know it's the character, she's just an awful person, as a character.

...I know, I know:

I can't say she's emotionally abusive. I'll take my ban now.

Moderator Comment As you wish

Global Moderator Comment So say we all.
« Last Edit: 09 Mar 2015, 21:20 by Is it cold in here? »
Logged

Tova

  • coprophage
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 7,725
  • Defender of the Terrible Denizens of QC
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #189 on: 09 Mar 2015, 19:04 »

And there Marten is, helping out the best he can. The backing away thing was, as so many people pointed out, purely for comedy. Marten isn't suddenly some kind of dickhead. And yet so many people who admitted it was uncharacteristic of Marten were so ready to believe it.

Who was it that said that the character haters were fond of basing their rants off limited data? Here is a classic example.

Ptptpttttth.jpg

Edit: oh, so we're going to move on to hating Tai now. Dear God.
Logged
Yet the lies of Melkor, the mighty and the accursed, Morgoth Bauglir, the Power of Terror and of Hate, sowed in the hearts of Elves and Men are a seed that does not die and cannot be destroyed; and ever and anon it sprouts anew, and will bear dark fruit even unto the latest days. (Silmarillion 255)

TheEvilDog

  • Guest
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #190 on: 09 Mar 2015, 19:05 »

I keep writing Asssssss.
Buuuuuttts!

Oh no! I have contracted the Butts Disease!
This was something of a sprung surprise, of that I can not lie.
Logged

mary tyler murder

  • Plantmonster
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 28
  • lights up the world with her
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #191 on: 09 Mar 2015, 19:07 »

There is a fine line between being cool with your friend dating your ex, and getting involved with their problems to the point that you are vicariously experiencing everything you hated about that relationship.

Actually, it's not a fine line at all, it's more of a canyon.

Yes, there is that. However, there is also the aspect of friendship that involves gritting your teeth and dealing with vicarious pain because, damn it, your friend is hurting and maybe, just maybe, you can make things better.

Remember: Tai didn't ask for help; Marten effectively offered it, sight unseen.

No, you're just failing to read the parts you don't want to read.

If you're playing "effectivelies" then she effectively demanded it by greeting Marten with a "bleh", and as every narcissist with a nasty attitude has demonstrated everywhere in the world since time immemorial, if he *hadn't* given into her demand she would have been a massive cunt to all and sundry the entire rest of the day.

I know there's this weird rule that some people are entitled to bleed other people emotionally dry, it's just, you know, a bullshit rule, believed in by bullshit people.

Still, Marten showed a little spirit for once. Here's hoping his learning curve continues on its upswing.
Logged

SomeCanadianWeirdo

  • Beyond Thunderdome
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 556
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #192 on: 09 Mar 2015, 19:11 »

Marten is pretty much Tai's best friend.  She admitted a good while back that she really didn't have any deep friendships before meeting him, just casual acquaintances  and sex partners.  So she's going to ask him for help, even though she does realise it puts him in a bit of an awkward position.  The other people in her life either have limited experiences in dealing with relationships, or are dealing with their own problems.  Perhaps someone in her family could help, but so far we know nothing of them, or how she gets along with them.
Logged

ElvisRevenge

  • Balloon animal serial killer
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 79
  • PLEASE HANNERS, DON'T HURT 'EM
    • Tumblr
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #193 on: 09 Mar 2015, 19:13 »

I just read Marten's dialogue in Bob Belcher's voice and it was toooooooo perrrrrrrfeeeeeeeect.
Logged

ReindeerFlotilla

  • Scrabble hacker
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1,339
  • All Your Marriage Are Belong to Everyone
    • Singular Blues
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #194 on: 09 Mar 2015, 19:13 »

Still not seeing the distinction.

I had a friend from highschool who didn't like Fight Club because Disassociative Personality Disorder doesn't work like that. I don't really dig Big Bang Theory because the nerds aren't really realistic. Just caractures.

Whether a character succeeds or fails from a narative point of view is still a subjective assessment that's based on a reaction no different from "what that character did was uncool." How you feel about what see happens before you find the words to define that feeling. Whether that word is "unrealistic" or "uncool" is really just whim based on how you feel about analyzing the character or the narrative in that moment. That's why one person can come to the thread with a character response and another with a perspective on the framework of the story in which the event took place. Same coin, different sides. Could be twenty-five cents, or it could be a quarter of a dollar.

jeph

  • Administrator
  • Duck attack survivor
  • ******
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1,848
  • MON DIEU!
    • Questionable Content
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #195 on: 09 Mar 2015, 19:15 »

There is a fine line between being cool with your friend dating your ex, and getting involved with their problems to the point that you are vicariously experiencing everything you hated about that relationship.

Actually, it's not a fine line at all, it's more of a canyon.

Yes, there is that. However, there is also the aspect of friendship that involves gritting your teeth and dealing with vicarious pain because, damn it, your friend is hurting and maybe, just maybe, you can make things better.

Remember: Tai didn't ask for help; Marten effectively offered it, sight unseen.

No, you're just failing to read the parts you don't want to read.

If you're playing "effectivelies" then she effectively demanded it by greeting Marten with a "bleh", and as every narcissist with a nasty attitude has demonstrated everywhere in the world since time immemorial, if he *hadn't* given into her demand she would have been a massive cunt to all and sundry the entire rest of the day.

I know there's this weird rule that some people are entitled to bleed other people emotionally dry, it's just, you know, a bullshit rule, believed in by bullshit people.

Still, Marten showed a little spirit for once. Here's hoping his learning curve continues on its upswing.

Hey asshole quit throwing around words like "cunt" and "gutterdyke" on my website
Logged
Deathmole Jacques' head takes up the bottom half of the panel, with his words taking up the top half. He is not concerned about the life of his friend.

ReindeerFlotilla

  • Scrabble hacker
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1,339
  • All Your Marriage Are Belong to Everyone
    • Singular Blues
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #196 on: 09 Mar 2015, 19:22 »

Sometimes you want to feed the troll, even though you shouldn't. Sometimes you want to call a mod. Sometimes you want to do both.

Then this happens and you just want to lead with a slow clap into a standing ovation.

Gladstone

  • The Tickler
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 946
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #197 on: 09 Mar 2015, 19:23 »

I could use a cigarette right about now, and I don't even smoke.
Logged
You have not experienced Questionable Content until you have read it in the original Klingon.

jwhouk

  • Awakened
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11,022
  • The Valley of the Sun
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #198 on: 09 Mar 2015, 19:25 »

EDIT: Poor Marten. This time, make like Ardent and RUN.
Bad idea.  There's always a bigger fish.  Has George Lucas taught us nothing?
Or, in Ardent and Gavia's case, bigger birds.
Logged
"Character is what you are in the Dark." - D.L. Moody
There is no joke that can be made online without someone being offended by it.
Life's too short to be ashamed of how you were born.
Just another Joe like 46

jwhouk

  • Awakened
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11,022
  • The Valley of the Sun
Re: WCDT 2912 to 2916 (9-13 March 2015)
« Reply #199 on: 09 Mar 2015, 19:26 »

I'll take my ban now.
As you wish

It might be, it could be, IT IS!

I was wondering why I saw Jeph's avatar on here.

It's never a good thing to see Jeph's avatar on here.

Logged
"Character is what you are in the Dark." - D.L. Moody
There is no joke that can be made online without someone being offended by it.
Life's too short to be ashamed of how you were born.
Just another Joe like 46
Pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5 6 ... 12   Go Up