Indeed! A nice little time capsule there.
I never did read any of the "Penny is an atheist" thread, it both grew too fast, and I have issues with the issues anyway. I do take exception to the notion that getting involved with philosophy majors will make you an atheist, but it's also pretty clear that a) it's second (or third, or fourth) hand info, and b) it's probably being grossly oversimplified, the way other people's lives often are. But still, a nice, tight well-written narrative.
I've had an idea bobbling around for the last few days since the fanfic topic came up, we'll see if I have any time to write it down...