Indie is the genre for you, I'd say.
It's in a constant state of flux because the indie taste dynamic has no stable equilibrium point. Not like rock where you can stay at an equilibrium point for decades upon decades.
The likability of a band is inversely proportional to the amount of people who like it. So no matter where you're starting point, you will spiral away from any number of repulsion points. There are only three final destination points for indie bands. There's the 'Obscurity graveyard' where most of them end up. There's 'mainstream sellout', a mixed blessing. And the truly lucky few get to become 'indie dinosaurs', but only if they retire around the peak of their popularity. This follows from the 'Neil Young Theorem' which states 'it's better to burn out than it is to rust'.
There's also that even rarer fourth category, 'Critical legend'. But that's only possible if you're consistently good for a long period, while being known in the mainstream, and keeping your indie cred. This was way easier in the 60's when mainstream didn't suck quite as much, but it's nearly impossible now.