This thread got resurrected, so I don't know if the OP is even looking for advice anymore, but I just survived another round of finals, and have a suggestion/complaint about the coffee shop I frequent.
I like to write papers in my local coffee shop. I feel more compelled to work since I made the effort to get there, and it has little booths that make great "study nooks." The music they play is usually really conducive to study too. Good, but easy to ignore when you're working.
Unfortunately Holiday season coincides with fall semester finals, so "festive" music is added to the rotation. Low-key or instrumental holiday stuff is fine, but there's also the brassier, harder to zone out tunes, particularly a Dr. Suess compilation that somehow gets played every time I've tried to write a paper there. Who's down in Whoville chirping away do not help me concentrate on study. If I was there socializing, it would be just fine, but based on the number of laptops and textbooks I saw around, lots of people were there to study. Obviously, they have customers that are not students, and I'm not suggesting that they should cater exclusively to college kids. I just think that it'd be nice to hold off on the fun, peppy holiday stuff until finals are over, and everyone is ready to celebrate. No one's going to be hurt if the music is a little mellow for a week or so.
So that is my suggestion, if you are in a college town and within a mile or two of campus. You can get a lot of business during midterms and finals, if it's a good study environment. People are there for hours typing away, and they'll usually order multiple drinks to compensate for sleep deprivation. Observing high stress times for students and making your shop the best place to work could score you some very loyal customers.
P.S. Neon Bible has topped a few "best of" lists this year. Whether the praise is justified or not, I can understand why you'd think someone "hip" would at least recognize the album. I am not equating "hip" with "good." It has to do with the "hip" culture, which seems to think Arcade Fire is all kinds of phenomenal.