The thing is, the cops shouldn't reveal themselves, they'll get hit right away. Neither Mafia for the vigilante will reveal themselves either, of course, and the masons are the only other ones who can coordinate anything - I'm still not sure what role they really play except for being a group that knows its members aren't anything else (wait, can a mason be the vigilante, or a cop? I don't think there are dual roles, there were exactly 14 roles and 14 people before doubled names were removed).
Dr.Nervioso, if you bled when you shaved like I do, you'd have beard, too. And it's only itchy if you don't keep it clean...
I'm clean! I'm clean! (oooh, double entendre, and it's not even sexual!)
I agree Gareth probably got whacked because he was acting out, I'm sure the mafia thought he was covering something up; but since he wasn't revealed to be the vigilante or a cop or even a mason, it all must have been a ruse. But here we seem to be going the other way, thinking that people who are quiet are covering something up. But even idontunderstand didn't feel right about his vote.
*sigh*. We're going to wake up tomorrow to another death (probably two), and we've really got nothing to go on. All we can do at this point is hope we're lucky enough to take out a mafiosi.
But I'm going to make it a real race, and nominate the one person who hasn't felt the need to defend themselves - I move we take Whitey Fats out back.